Ahl Al Khilaf-Engaging with Shi’a

“And each one hath a goal toward which he turns; so contend with one another in good works. Wheresoever you may be, Allah will bring you all together. Lo! Allah is Able to do all things.” (Qur’an 2:148)

Allah will judge between you on the Day of Resurrection concerning that over which you used to differ.” (Qur’an 22:69)

“So after the truth, what else can there be, save error? How then are you turned away?” –(Qur’an 10:32).

﷽ 

Insh’Allah the following section in the future will be found under the section above: Ahl Al-Qibla/Ahl Al-Khilaf.

This is a collection of articles in regard to the Shi’i and their various claims. Also are articles in relation to the Shi’i.

“Do not fight the kharijites after me, because one who seeks a right but does not find it, is not like the one who seeks a wrong and finds it.” –Ali Ibn Abu Talib

Source: (Nahju Al-Balagha Vol. 1, p. 67, speech no. 56.)

The words “He who seeks a right but does not find it” – as ‘Ali himself says – is an allusion to the Nahrawanees who are otherwise known as the Khawarij. The words “Unlike he who seeks misguidance intentionally” refer to Mu’awiya and his Syrian forces.

“Are the Khawarij mushrikun?” Ali said: “They flee from shirk.” Are they munafiqun? Ali said: “The hypocrites remember Allah only a little.” Then what are they? Ali said: “They are our brothers who transgressed against us (ikhwanuna baghaw ‘alayna), so we fought them for their transgression.” 

Source: (Al-Bidāya wa l-Nihāya 10:591)

The Ibadi are obviously not Khawarij to anyone who has common sense. However, for those who insist that we are you have to contend with those statements.

DO READ THIS FIRST. It is important to understand that we believe and accept that those who call themselves ‘Shi’i’ are Muslims.

We understand that ‘Shi’i’ is a term for a loose federation of various sects that all come under the understanding that Ali Ibn Abu Talib should have been the first Amir of the Muslims or was the most deserving of being that Amir.

We endorse the Amman accord: http://ammanmessage.com/the-three-points-of-the-amman-message-v-1/

Even before the Amman accord the Ibadi have regarded the Shi’a as Ahl Al Qiblah.

You have your polemical works directed towards each other -Ithna-Ashari versus Zaydi versus Ismaili.

Thus it is in that spirit that this section is created. We have just as much right to contend for the truth as anyone else does.

We have the right to allow the Muslim community to make an informed decision on various controversial issues.

You have your narrative and we have our narrative. Allah is with those who are the truthful!

“So after the truth, what else can there be, save error? How then are you turned away?” –(Qur’an 10:32).

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/04/the-ibadi-stance-on-ali-bin-abi-talib/embed/#?secret=B9dGPrUv6v#?secret=tPhEcQjA0C

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/05/my-own-experience-with-shia/embed/#?secret=SOc0VDOhGb#?secret=1z1UXYVOCF

Inter Shi’i conflicts: After Ali Then Who?

Are we to follow Infallible Imams according to the Qur’an?

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/04/are-we-to-follow-infallible-imams-according-to-the-holy-quran/embed/#?secret=3jNsH3qZ4n#?secret=gvvmdkSyTb

https://primaquran.com/2024/05/08/imami-shia-attempts-to-respond-to-an-article-on-infallible-imams/embed/#?secret=EFFhHaBd5i#?secret=IoXkkIHGAV

Imami Shi’i 700 years of no Prophet and No Imam After Jesus (as)?

How did the Shi’i imams prevent the corruption of the Torah and the Gospel?

A garden variety refutation of Shi’i Imami concept being from the Qur’an.

https://primaquran.com/2024/05/10/a-garden-variety-refutation-of-shiaism/embed/#?secret=uMZwEkimKs#?secret=VKPAZCokwo

Purification of the Ahl Bayt?

The Shi’i believe the Prophets are Masoom (Infallible) however..

Ali ibn Abi Talib his ijtihad and burning people alive.

Sunni and Shi’i narrators state that Ali bin Abi Talib drank alcohol and offered prayers while intoxicated?

Social experiment: Ali, Umar(ra) and Fatima (ra)

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/04/sociological-experiment-ali-umar-and-fatima/embed/#?secret=EFPnpg56HU#?secret=fpXHbDQw1t

For Those Shi’i who do slander Aisha (ra)

Ali is with the truth and the truth is with Ali.

https://primaquran.com/2023/04/28/examining-the-hadith-ali-is-with-the-truth-and-the-truth-is-with-ali/

I am at war with the one who is at war with Ali.

Iblis loves Imam Ali

The Hadith of the 12 leaders.

https://primaquran.com/2023/01/30/hadith-of-the-12-leaders/embed/#?secret=ejy0uaEQh4#?secret=IdvzagazN1

Hadith on Ghadir Khum

Ibadi hadith master, Shaykh Al Qanoubi on Hadith Al Thaqalyn

https://primaquran.com/2024/11/15/ibadi-hadith-master-shaykh-al-qanoubi-on-hadith-al-thaqalyan/embed/#?secret=iCsqB2Ov8S#?secret=uOTlVzbI2k

The Hadith: You are to me as Aaron is to Moses

https://primaquran.com/2023/04/15/response-to-shii-you-are-to-me-as-aaron-is-to-moses/embed/#?secret=fxlNwUAAe4#?secret=LBHv0Cs8jJ

An Awesome relationship The Shi’i and Abu Huarayrah

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/05/an-awesome-relationship-the-shia-and-abu-huarayrah/embed/#?secret=e6QPXrtBhB#?secret=r5qBL7IQDX

Historical Issues and Politics & Contemporary Issues.

The Blessed Prophet Muhammed (saw) never predicted that Hussain Ibn Ali Ibn Abi Talib would die as a martyr.

https://primaquran.com/2023/07/27/nabi-muhammed-%ef%b7%ba-never-predicted-that-al-hussain-ibn-ali-ibn-abi-talib-will-die-as-a-martyr/embed/#?secret=4yOUDUeSIL#?secret=liza6wh4S2

What really happened at the battle of Siffin?

What really happened at the battle of Nahrawan?

Questions every sincere Shi’i must ask concerning Siffin and Nahrawan.

https://primaquran.com/2023/02/13/questions-every-sincere-shii-must-ask-concerning-siffin-and-nahrawan/embed/#?secret=Q3QDWxjYD3#?secret=aaWZolR3Th

Ex 12er Shi’a sister has questions about Siffin. An Ex Shi’a sister who was in our WhatsApp group had some questions for one of our teachers.

https://primaquran.com/2024/02/17/ex-12er-shia-sister-has-questions-about-siffin/embed/#?secret=LM3LJXgP1B#?secret=vdUgF6P0gW

Response to Ali Hur Kampoonpuri’s attempt to refute Ibadi’s on Siffin.

https://primaquran.com/2023/05/11/response-to-ali-hur-kamoonpuri-attempt-to-refute-ibadis-on-siffin/embed/#?secret=ZmlxNR8vAM#?secret=aVU4DOw4ts

SUNNI & SHI’A NARRATIVES OF SIFFIN AND AL-NAHRAWAN

https://primaquran.com/2022/12/12/sunni-shia-narratives-of-siffin-and-al-nahrawan/

Sunni-Shi’a sectarian/political point scoring over Palestine.

Pro Alid YouTube channel thows Ibn Abbas (ra) under the Bus!

Turkey is home to the 3rd largest Shi’i population in the Middle East.

The Iranian Shi’i Exodus to Atheism and the plans against Iran.

https://primaquran.com/2023/04/12/the-shii-exodus-to-atheism-and-the-plans-against-iran/embed/#?secret=mBTecpxgo2#?secret=LtjYd9bJBY

Isma’ili Shi’i

Isma’ili Nizari Shi’a and Circular Reasoning

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/17/ismaili-shia-and-circular-reasoning/embed/#?secret=Wtpq8duG8l#?secret=jCO1Xmq43f

There is no evidence that the Nizari Isma’ili Imam can properly recite the Qur’an.

https://primaquran.com/2024/09/19/there-is-no-evidence-that-the-nizari-ismaili-imam-can-properly-recite-the-quran/embed/#?secret=HWAjJ8gPYf#?secret=SSO9Xn7Nwf

Can a Child of Zani be an Imam? Isma’ili Shi’a & Ibadi Views.

What is Tawhid? Debate between a Nizari Ismaili Shi’a and Athari-Salafi Sunni

Imam Mahdi

Shi’a and the Origin of Black People: Blatant Racism

The Ark of Noah and the Descendants of Prophets.

Divorce according to the Imamiyyah 12er Shi’i: A great perspective!

https://primaquran.com/2022/10/05/divorce-according-to-the-imamiyyah-12er-shia/embed/#?secret=tgDty3XeAe#?secret=MNdkaMt28W

Is the Qur’an that we are in Possession of Distorted? | Sayyid Ali Abu Al-Hasan-Great Insights!

https://primaquran.com/2024/07/06/is-the-quran-that-we-are-in-possession-of-distorted-sayyid-ali-abu-al-hasan/

Brother Ilyas shares his thoughts on a recent article concerning Shi’ism.

https://primaquran.com/2024/08/08/brother-ilyas-shares-his-thoughts-on-a-recent-article-concerning-shiism/

Neither Shi’a nor Sunni: An Interview with a Mozabite-Anthony T. Fiscella

https://primaquran.com/2024/02/05/neither-shia-nor-sunni-an-interview-with-a-mozabite-anthony-t-fiscella/

Adnan Rashid gaslighting the Shi’a over the Khawarij

https://primaquran.com/2024/03/11/adnan-rashid-gaslighting-the-shia-over-the-khawarij/

THE TIME ALI IBN ABU TALIB SLAUGHTERED 2/3 OF THE ALIENS IN SPACE

Insh’Allah more to come… 

Taking a look at Mutah Marriages. 

The Virtues of Abu Bakr Sadiq (ra)

Nasibi Tendencies With in Shi’ism: Why do Some Shi’i curse the Prophet (saw) grandson Hassan? His wife Aisha (ra)?

Musta’li Ismaili refutation of Nizari Ismaili claims

May Allah (swt) Guide the Ummah.

May Allah (swt) Forgive the Ummah.

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “Ahl Al Khilaf-Engaging with Shi’a

  1. Truthseeker's avatar Truthseeker

    Regarding Twelver Shiism since it is the largest Shia branch. No offense to the Twelver brothers and sisters but the strongest argument against Twelver Shiism would be that it distracts Muslims from the worship of Allah (swt).

    So much emphasize is given to the tragedies and veneration of Ali, Fatima (ra), Hasan (ra) and Hussain (ra) that it distracts from monotheism of Islam. Twelver brothers and sisters are so invested in these figures that an outsider if he was to look at Twelverism he would think that Islam is based on Ali rather than Allah (swt).

    We can see the similar problems in Christianity where Isa (as) became a barrier instead of a way to Allah (swt). Christians are instructed to remember and live out the passion of Isa (as) and venerate him so much that Christianity is based on Jesus and not on the worship of Allah (swt). Catholic- and Orthodox Christians even have more barriers with their devotions to Miriam (as), their saints and images/statues/relics.

    If you think about the ayahs where Allah (swt) talks about Islam being the same monotheistic religion throughout mankind then how does “Ahlul Bayt” fit into this? Are Christians right about venerating Isa’s (as) Ahlul Bayt? I have even heard a Twelver hold that the Qu’ran Al-Kareem is supposedly corrupted and that the ahadith of Ahlul Bayt are sufficient.

    While the Wahhabi Salafis Brethren are repeating the mistakes of Jews in likening Allah (swt) to creation (and also by maintaining that hell is temporary for Muslims which is similar to the jewish concept of hell), Twelver Shias Brethren are repeating the mistakes of Christians by giving a lot of emphasize to the creation (some even claim that Ali created the world like Christians claim that Isa (as) created the world).

Leave a reply to Truthseeker Cancel reply