“O you who have believed, if there comes to you a disobedient one with information, investigate, lest you harm a people out of ignorance and become, over what you have done, regretful.” (Qur’an 49:6)
﷽
Perhaps one of the biggest accusations against Ali Ibn Abi Talib by his opponents is the claim that he killed his wife Fatima bint Muhammed (ra).
The opponets of Ali Ibn Abi Talib claim that Ali was a Nasibi who had hatred for the Ahl Bayt, meaning in this case Aisha (ra). Some say this because his army aimed arrows at Aisha (ra) while she rode upon the camel.
Likewise, it is claimed Ali impugned the honor of the Mother of the Believers Aisha (ra) in the incident of the slander.
It cannot be denied that based upon the reports we have that Usama bin Zaid had consoled the heart of the Prophet (saw), whereas Ali had goaded him to inquire further.
“When the Divine Inspiration was delayed. Allah’s Messenger (saw) called `Ali bin Abi Talib and Usama bin Zaid to ask and consult them about divorcing me. Usama bin Zaid said what he knew of my innocence, and the respect he preserved in himself for me. Usama said, ‘(O Allah’s Messenger (saw)!) She is your wife, and we do not know anything except good about her.’ `Ali bin Abi Talib said, ‘O Allah’s Messenger (saw)! Allah does not put you in difficulty and there are plenty of women other than she, yet, ask the maid-servant who will tell you the truth.’ On that Allah’s Messenger (saw) called Barira (i.e. the maid-servant) and said, ‘O Barira! Did you ever see anything which aroused your suspicion?” Barira said to him, ‘By Him Who has sent you with the Truth. I have never seen anything in her (i.e. Aisha) which I would conceal, except that she is a young girl who sleeps leaving the dough of her family exposed so that the domestic goats come and eat it.’
The opponents reason that if Ali Ibn Abu Talib had no problem with his army raining arrows down upon the howdah of Aisha (ra), then killing Fatima (ra) would be a small matter.
First, we need to remove the emotive rhetoric behind and ask ourselves: In theory is it plausible that someone who is related to a Prophet of Allah can commit something so heinous as cold blooded murder?
“And recite to them the story of the two sons of Adam in truth, when they both offered a sacrifice, and it was accepted from one of them but was not accepted from the other. He said, “I will surely kill you.” He said, “Indeed, Allah only accepts from the righteous. If you should raise your hand against me to kill me, I shall not raise my hand against you to kill you. Indeed, I fear Allah, Lord of the worlds. Indeed, I want you to bear my sin and your sin and become among the companions of the Fire, and that is the recompense of the wrongdoers.” So his soul prompted him to kill his brother, and he killed him, and he became among the losers. Then Allah sent a crow searching in the ground to show him how to hide the shame of his brother. He said, “O woe to me! Have I failed to be like this crow and hide the shame of my brother?” And he became among the regretful.” (Qur’an 5:27-31)
This claim hinges on several factors.
That Ali Ibn Abi Talib had a motive for killing her.
That there were no witnesses other than Ali in regard to what actually happened to her.
That Ali Ibn Abi Talib burried her at night preventing the people of the city of light, Al Madina to pray over her.
Examining the motives for Ali Ibn Abi Talib’s alleged killing of Fatima (ra).
She prevented him from marrying other wives.
He found out that she was giving information to Umar (ra) about Ali’s dealings.
In relation to point 1. He killed Fatima (ra) to marry Umama bint Abi al-As ibn al-Rabi’ and eventually prevent Muawiya from marry her and having offspring from her, so they would become descendants of the Messenger of Allah (saw).
She prevented him from marrying other wives.
This is perhaps the strongest motive with the strongest evidence.
Narrated Al-Miswar bin Makhrama:
I heard Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) who was on the pulpit, saying, “Banu Hisham bin Al-Mughira have requested me to allow them to marry their daughter to `Ali bin Abu Talib, but I don’t give permission, and will not give permission unless `Ali bin Abi Talib divorces my daughter in order to marry their daughter, because Fatima is a part of my body, and I hate what she hates to see, and what hurts her, hurts me.”
Miswar b. Makhramali reported that he heard Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) say, as he sat on the pulpit:
The sons of Hisham b. Mughira have asked my permission to marry their daughter with ‘Ali b. Abi Talib (that refers to the daughter of Abu Jahl for whom ‘All had sent a proposal for marriage). But I would not allow them, I would not allow them, I would not allow them (and the only alternative possible is) that ‘Ali should divorce my daughter (and then marry their daughter), for my daughter is part of me. He who disturbs her in fact disturbs me and he who offends her offends me.
So we some interesting information from the above hadith.
Had the matter not been serious, the Messenger of Allah (saw), would not have ascended the pulpit and said: “I will not permit it, then I will not permit it, then I will not permit it.” The Messenger of Allah (saw), made it clear that if Abu Talib’s son wanted to marry Abu Jahl’s daughter, he would have to “divorce my daughter Fatima.”
Then he could marry whomever he wished.
What is striking is that it was the Banu Hisham ibn al-Mughira who informed the Messenger of Allah (saw) of Ali’s proposal to their daughter, Which indicates that Ali did not inform Fatima (ra)!
And he did not seek the Messenger of Allah’s (saw) permission for this proposal! Fatima was hurt by Ali, so the Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “Fatima is a part of me; what troubles her troubles me, “and what hurts her hurts me.”
Thus, if Fatima (ra) is dead nothing prevents Ali from getting remarried.
Summary of the above hadith.
Ali was not content with being married to Fatima (ra) alone. He entertained the idea. He could have simply said, ‘not interested’.
Ali did not inform Fatma (ra) of the proposal.
Ali did not inform the Prophet (saw) of the proposal.
Ali by hurting Fatima (ra) hurt the Prophet (saw).
The Prophet (saw) ascended the pulpit. Which shows the gravity of the matter. The Prophet (saw) could have simpy advised and told Ali directly. However, ascending the pulpit shows how upset the Prophet (saw) himself was over the matter.
The above text we translate it as follows:
“And Ali (peace be upon him) married eleven women, and died leaving four free women and seven concubines.“
“And one of the princes of Syria, if he heard of his numerous marriages, would say: “She is neither a divorcee nor a widow,” hinting at that. And it is said: He married after the death of Fatimah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon her and her father) nine [women] in total, and he married Umamah bint Zaynab, the daughter of the Messenger of Allah, for Fatimah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon her) had recommended that to him.”
“Some of the rulers of Syria, upon hearing of his numerous marriages, would say, ‘It’s neither a marriage nor a divorce,’ alluding to this. It is said that he married nine nights after the death of Fatimah, peace be upon her and her father. He married Umamah, the daughter of Zaynab, the daughter of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) as Fatimah, peace be upon her, had instructed him to do so.
It is said that he married nine nights after the death of Fatimah, peace be upon her and her father.
“And Al-Hasan bin Ali (may Allah be pleased with them both) married two hundred and fifty women, and it is said: three hundred. And Ali (peace be upon him) used to forbid him from that and disliked it out of jealousy for his family. If he divorced [them], he would say: “Indeed, Hasan is a divorcer, so do not marry him.” So a man from Hamdan said: “O Commander of the Faithful, let us marry him whomever you wish. Whoever you love, we will keep, and whoever you hate, we will separate [divorce].”
Source: (“Qūt al-qulūb fi Mu’amalat al-Mahbub wa Wasf Tariq al-Murid ila Maqam al-Tawhid” (Nourishment of Hearts in Dealing with the Beloved and Describing the Seeker’s Path to the Station of Monotheism volume 3 page number 1621) written by the Sufi scholar, the mystic and Shafi’i hadith scholar, Abū Ṭālib Muhammed ibn Ali ibn Atiyya al-Harithi al-Makkī
The key themes of the book are as follows:
Strictly following the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammed (saw).
Cultivating sincere intention (ikhlas).
Striving for spiritual excellence (ihsan).
Purifying the heart from blameworthy traits.
This is also quoted by: Muhammed-Baqir al-Majlisi in Bihar al-Anwar
Some may say how can one love again after having loved and been loved by Fatima (ra)? How can Ali after 10 years of marriage and having children move on so quickly?
This only increases the suspicion of murder. However, this suspicion is easily answered. Ali had children who were still quite small. Even if he re-married rather quickly it doesn’t mean he ‘moved on’ so to speak.
Also, this report does not have an authentic chain. It is something that has been handed down by tradition without anything solid to back it up. However, the same can be said about intervals (meaning when Ali actually remarried) after the passing of Fatima (ra). It is all based upon speculation.
Some pay point out what seemingly is a flippant attitude towards women by Ali in the hadith concerning Aisha (ra) above: ‘there are plenty of women other than she‘ Ali is actually addressing a stark reality. People are replaceable.
After all, there is a beautiful and powerful saying attributed to Ali ibn Abi Talib: Attachment is not that you dot own anything but rather nothing owns you.
Then there is Explanation of Sahih Al Bukari by Ahmad ibn Ali ibn Hajar al-Asqalani concerning what triggered the ‘Ghadir Khum’ incident.
This is the summary:
Khalid bin Al-Walid and Buraidah Al-Aslami were in Yemen to fight in the way of Allah and to call people to Islam, so the Messenger of Allah (saw), sent Ali to them to “seize the spoils.” Ali came and took the spoils, and his eyes fell on a Yemeni girl whom he liked, so he took her into the tent, after he fufilled what he did with her, and went out to the companions, his head dripping with water.
Conclusion: That Ali Killed Fatima (ra) in order to marry other women is not sound.
In the Sunni tradition according to Ibn Hajar’s commentary and Sunni hadith Ali certainly had access to other women. Just not as wives. These are the type of reports that those who attack Ali rely upon to begin with. So their whole premise is destroyed.
Fatima (ra) found out about Ali’s plans to overthrow the caliphate.
The second motive that is given by the opponets of Ali ibn Abu Talib is that it is alleged that when Umar (ra) went to the house of Fatima (ra), Umar (ra) informed her: “Tell Ali not to meet with those trying to overthrow the caliphate and to stop their plots.” Thus it is alleged that she then kept an eye on Ali and saw that her husband was indeed meeting people to gather support. And when Fatima (ra) discovered this, Ali killed her.
We can say based upon our research that we have not come across a shred of evidence for this. Not in the books of the Sunni nor in the books of the Shi’i.
Conclusion: That Ali killed Fatima (ra) because he found out that she was leaking his plans is certainly pure speculation.
Fatima (ra) was an obstacle for Ali to marry Umama bint Abi al-As ibn al-Rabi’ who could possibly marry Muawiya
Translation from above:
“From Qasim ibn Asbagh, who said: [narrated] to us Ismail, who said: [narrated] to us Hammad ibn Zayd, from Aisha, that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) … [when] he gathered [them], he said: “Shall I not inform you of the most…?” … loyalty. So the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) … and he married her to Ali ibn Abi Talib after Fatimah, and Abu al-As had recommended her [in marriage] to him. And her mother is Umm al-Haytham al-Nakha’iyyah: “Ummamah, when she departed from the loved ones, made my forelocks grey and humbled my support. She circles around him for her need to him, and when she despaired, she raised a wailing cry.”
“And Ali ibn Abi Talib had ordered al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal ibn al-Harith ibn Abd al-Muttalib to marry Ummamah bint Abi al-As ibn al-Rabi’, his wife after him, because he feared that Mu’awiyah would marry her. So al-Mughirah married her, and she gave birth to Yahya, and by him he was given the kunyah. And she died while with al-Mughirah.”
“And it has been said: She did not give birth to [a child] for Ali nor for al-Mughirah. Likewise, al-Zubayr said: She did not give birth to [a child] for al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal. He said: And Zaynab has no offspring.”
“And Umar ibn Shabbah mentioned, saying: [narrated] to us Ali ibn Muhammad al-Nawfali, from his father that he narrated to him from his family that Ali, when death approached him, said to Ummamah bint Abi al-As: “I do not feel safe that this tyrant will propose to you after my death, meaning Mu’awiyah. So if you have a need among men, I have approved al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal as a husband for you.”
Source: (Al-Istiʿāb fī Maʿrifat al-Āṣḥāb (Comprehensive Knowledge of the Names of the Companions) by Ibn Abd al-Barr Volume 4, Page 1789)
This theory proposes that Ali killed Fatima (ra) as she was an obstacle for him to marry another wife. Ali needed to do this to marry Umama bint Abi al-As ibn al-Rabi’ (ra) whom was eventually given to al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal. This was to prevent Muawiya from marry her and having offspring from her, so they would become descendants of the Messenger of Allah (saw).
We can say based upon our research that there is no historical basis that Ali had al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal(ra) marry Mughirah ibn Nawfal to prevent Muawiya from marrying her.
Conclusion: This theory is proven to be false.
How old was Fatima (ra) at the time of her death?
The most common view in the Shi’i tradition is that she was 18 at the time of her death.
The most common view in the Sunni tradition is that she was 27-29 at the time of her death.
The point being here is that no matter what tradition you wish to go with in regard to her age at the time of death she was by all accounts a healthy young woman.
The manner of her death: The clash of historical perspectives.
Some late Shi’i sources Fatima (ra) dies as the result of Umar Ibn Al Khattab (ra) and his alleged assault on the house.
Many Shi’i scholars and researchers reject this account. Ahmad al-Katib mentions its absence in early Shi’i text. Foundational compilations like Al-Kulayni’s Al Kafi and Nahj al-Balagha do not contain it. The absence of its mention by Shaykh al-Mufid.
Sayyid Muhammed Hussein Fadlallah believes the Muslims of that era would not assault the daughter of the Prophet (saw) so soon after his death. That a warrior like Ali would not remain passive while his wife was physicallly beaten.
He douts details such as the actual burning of the house, the breaking of Fatima’s (ra) ribs or her misscarriage.
‘Ahl Sunnah Wal Jammah’ a project of the Abbasids, will claim she died of grief and some kind of ‘natural illness‘. Whils this is plausible, it still leaves the matter ambiguous.
The secret burial of Fatima bint Muhammed (ra). It raises more questions then it answers.
The following are from Sunni sources:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:” We (prophets) do not have any heirs; what we leave behind is (to be given in) charity.” The household of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) will live on the income from these properties, but, by Allah, I will not change the charity of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) from the condition in which it was in his own time. I will do the same with it as the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upun him) himself used to do. So Abu Bakr refused to hand over anything from it to Fatima who got angry with Abu Bakr for this reason. She forsook him and did not talk to him until the end of her life. She lived for six months after the death of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). When she died, her husband. ‘Ali b. Abu Talib, buried her at night. He did not inform Abu Bakr about her death and offered the funeral prayer over her himself. During the lifetime of Fatima, ‘All received (special) regard from the people. After she had died, he felt estrangement in the faces of the people towards him. So he sought to make peace with Abu Bakr and offer his allegiance to him. He had not yet owed allegiance to him as Caliph during these months. He sent a person to Abu Bakr requesting him to visit him unaccompanied by anyone (disapproving the presence of Umar). ‘Umar said to Abu Bakr: BY Allah, you will not visit them alone. Abu Bakr said: What will they do to me? By Allah, I will visit them. And he did pay them a visit alone. ‘All recited Tashahhud (as it is done in the beginning of a religious sermon) ; then said: We recognise your moral excellence and what Allah has bestowed upon you. We do not envy the favour (i. e. the Catiphate) which Allah nas conferred upon you; but you have done it (assumed the position of Caliph) alone (without consulting us), and we thought we had a right (to be consulted) on account of our kinship with the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). He continued to talk to Abu Bakr (in this vein) until the latter’s eyes welled up with tears. Then Abd Bakr spoke and said: By Allah, in Whose Hand is my life, the kinship of the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) is dearer to me than the kinship of my own people. As regards the dispute that has arisen between you and me about these properties, I have not deviated from the right course and I have not given up doing about them what the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) used to do. So ‘Ali said to Abu Bakr: This aftetnoon is (fixed) for (swearing) allegiance (to you). So when Abu Bakr had finished his Zuhr prayer, he ascended the pulpit and recited Tashahhud, and described the status of ‘Ali, his delay in swearing allegiance and the excuse which lie had offered to him (for this delay). (After this) he asked for God’s forgiveness. Then ‘Ali b. Abu Talib recited the Tashahhud. extolled the merits of Abu Bakr and (said that) his action was nott prompted by any jealousy of Abu Bakr on his part or his refusal to accept the high position which Allah had conferred upon him, (adding: ) But we were of the opinion that we should have a share in the government, but the matter had been decided without taking us into confidence, and this displeased us. (Hence the delay in offering allegiance. The Muslims were pleased with this (explanation) and they said: You have done the right thing. The Muslims were (again) favourably inclined to ‘Ali since he adopted the proper course of action.
Fatima the daughter of the Prophet (ﷺ) sent someone to Abu Bakr (when he was a caliph), asking for her inheritance of what Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) had left of the property bestowed on him by Allah from the Fai (i.e. booty gained without fighting) in Medina, and Fadak, and what remained of the Khumus of the Khaibar booty. On that, Abu Bakr said, “Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “Our property is not inherited. Whatever we leave, is Sadaqa, but the family of (the Prophet) Muhammad can eat of this property.’ By Allah, I will not make any change in the state of the Sadaqa of Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) and will leave it as it was during the lifetime of Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ), and will dispose of it as Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) used to do.” So Abu Bakr refused to give anything of that to Fatima. So she became angry with Abu Bakr and kept away from him, and did not task to him till she died. She remained alive for six months after the death of the Prophet. When she died, her husband `Ali, buried her at night without informing Abu Bakr and he said the funeral prayer by himself. When Fatima was alive, the people used to respect `Ali much, but after her death, `Ali noticed a change in the people’s attitude towards him. So `Ali sought reconciliation with Abu Bakr and gave him an oath of allegiance. `Ali had not given the oath of allegiance during those months (i.e. the period between the Prophet’s death and Fatima’s death). `Ali sent someone to Abu Bakr saying, “Come to us, but let nobody come with you,” as he disliked that `Umar should come, `Umar said (to Abu Bakr), “No, by Allah, you shall not enter upon them alone ” Abu Bakr said, “What do you think they will do to me? By Allah, I will go to them’ So Abu Bakr entered upon them, and then `Ali uttered Tashah-hud and said (to Abu Bakr), “We know well your superiority and what Allah has given you, and we are not jealous of the good what Allah has bestowed upon you, but you did not consult us in the question of the rule and we thought that we have got a right in it because of our near relationship to Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) .” Thereupon Abu Bakr’s eyes flowed with tears. And when Abu Bakr spoke, he said, “By Him in Whose Hand my soul is to keep good relations with the relatives of Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) is dearer to me than to keep good relations with my own relatives. But as for the trouble which arose between me and you about his property, I will do my best to spend it according to what is good, and will not leave any rule or regulation which I saw Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) following, in disposing of it, but I will follow.” On that `Ali said to Abu Bakr, “I promise to give you the oath of allegiance in this after noon.” So when Abu Bakr had offered the Zuhr prayer, he ascended the pulpit and uttered the Tashah-hud and then mentioned the story of `Ali and his failure to give the oath of allegiance, and excused him, accepting what excuses he had offered; Then `Ali (got up) and praying (to Allah) for forgiveness, he uttered Tashah-hud, praised Abu Bakr’s right, and said, that he had not done what he had done because of jealousy of Abu Bakr or as a protest of that Allah had favored him with. `Ali added, “But we used to consider that we too had some right in this affair (of rulership) and that he (i.e. Abu Bakr) did not consult us in this matter, and therefore caused us to feel sorry.” On that all the Muslims became happy and said, “You have done the right thing.” The Muslims then became friendly with `Ali as he returned to what the people had done (i.e. giving the oath of allegiance to Abu Bakr).
Prima Qur’an comments: It is quite clear that these companions had very strong difference of opinion in regard to the inheritence of the Blessed Prophet (saw). This hadith tells us that Fatima (ra) did not wish to speak to Abu Bakr (ra) for the rest of her life. The death of Fatima (ra) is mentioned in passing. We are not told the reason for her death. It simply states that Ali buried her at night and he prayed over her himself. What follows is interesting: During the lifetime of Fatima, ‘Ali received (special) regard from the people. After she had died, he felt estrangement in the faces of the people towards him.
So this either means. That ‘Ali was nothing without his connection to Fatima (ra). Or, that Ali’s actions of praying over the daughter of the Messenger of Allah (saw) alone made people feel scorn towards him.
What is unresolved. The ‘how’ Fatima (ra) dies.
The following are from Shi’i sources.
“And Hasan and Husayn (peace be upon them), along with a group from Banu Hashim and some of the close companions of Amir al-Mu’minin (peace be upon him), buried her in the depth of the night, concealed her grave, and Ali (peace be upon him) leveled around it approximately seven false graves so that her grave would not be known, and he leveled her grave with the ground to hide its location [1]. And it is narrated that he (peace be upon him) sprinkled forty graves so that her grave would not be distinguishable from other graves and they would not pray over her [2].
Ibn Abbas was asked: When did you bury Fatimah (peace be upon her)? He said: We buried her at night after the night had quieted. It was said: So who prayed over her? He said: Ali (peace be upon him.”
“And in the narration: Voices of weeping rose from the house of Ali (peace be upon him), so the people of Medina let out a single cry, and the women of Banu Hashim gathered in her house and let out a single scream that almost made Medina tremble. And the people came like the mane of a horse to Ali (peace be upon him), while he was sitting, and Hasan and Husayn were before him weeping. And Umm Kulthum came out saying: “O my father, O Messenger of Allah, now we have truly lost you, a loss after which there is no meeting ever again.” And the people gathered and sat, clamoring, waiting outside the funeral to pray over her. And Abu Dharr came out and said: “Disperse, for the daughter of the Messenger of Allah has had her burial delayed until the evening.”
“And Abu Bakr and Umar came to offer condolences to Ali (peace be upon him), saying to him: “O Abu al-Hasan, do not precede us in praying over the daughter of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon him and his family).” But Ali (peace be upon him) washed her and shrouded her... Then Ali prayed over the funeral, and it was accompanied by Hasan, Husayn, Aqil, Salman, Abu Dharr, Miqdad, Ammar, Buraydah, al-Abbas, and Ibnat al-Fadl. When the voices quieted and eyes slept and a portion of the night passed, the Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him) brought her out and buried her secretly and poured earth over her, while the mourners around him kept watch lest the people know and the hypocrites prevent them. So they buried her and effaced the earth of her grave.”
From Ibn Nubatah, who said: The Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him) was asked about the reason for his burying Fatimah, daughter of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah’s peace and blessings be upon him and his family), at night. He said: “She was angry with a people and disliked their attendance at her funeral, and it is forbidden.”
[Bihar al-Anwar: 43/201, at the end of hadith 30].
107 Misbah al-Anwar: From Abu Ja’far (peace be upon him), who said: The Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him) buried Fatimah bint Muhammad (may Allah’s blessings be upon them) in al-Baqi’, and he sprinkled water around those graves so that the grave would not be known. And it reached Abu Bakr and Umar that Ali had buried her at night, so they said to him: “Why did you not inform us?” He said: “It was night, and I disliked to summon you!” So Umar said to him: “This is not [the reason], rather it is rancor in your chest!” So the Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him) said: “As for this, since you two refuse, she made me swear by the right of Allah and the sanctity of His Messenger and by her right upon me that you two should not attend her funeral.”
[Bihar al-Anwar: 81/255, hadith 15].
108 In al-Kashf: From the paths of the common people (Ahl al-Sunnah); that Abu Bakr and Umar reproached Ali (peace be upon him) for not having informed them to pray over her, so he excused himself that she had instructed him to do so, and he swore an oath to them, so they believed him and accepted his excuse.
[Bihar al-Anwar: 43/190, hadith 19, from Kashf al-Ghummah 2/68.
Prima Qur’an comments: Folks! There are more contradictions here than you can shake a stick at!
Get that scuba gear on, here comes the deep dive!
Contradiction 1: Who Was Present at the Burial and Who Prayed Over Her?
Report A (first source): Ibn Abbas-ra says, “We buried her at night… Ali prayed over her.” This implies a small, private burial with Ali leading the prayer.
Report B (second source): Lists a detailed roster of attendees at the funeral prayer: Ali, Hasan, Husayn, Aqil, Salman, Abu Dharr, Miqdad, Ammar, Buraydah, al-Abbas, and Ibnat al-Fadl eleven named individuals. It also says “the mourners around him kept watch” (plural), suggesting a larger group.
Contradiction: Report A implies a tiny, secret burial (Ibn Abbas -ra says “we”), while Report B describes a structured funeral prayer with a specific list of attendees and guards. If the burial was truly secret and concealed from the people of Medina, how did this many people attend without word spreading? Conversely, if eleven prominent Companions attended, how was it kept secret from Abu Bakr-ra and Umar-ra (who, in Report D, only learn of it afterward)?
Further tension: Report B says Ali “washed her and shrouded her” and then “prayed over the funeral” but Report A has Ibn Abbas-ra saying “we buried her,” which could imply Ibn Abbas-ra was present at the burial. Yet Report B’s attendee list does not include Ibn Abbas. So either Ibn Abbas-ra was present (and omitted from the list), or he was not present (and his “we” is rhetorical/imprecise). This is never reconciled.
Contradiction 2: Was the Grave Made Unrecognizable, or Was It in al-Baqi’?
Report A: Ali “leveled around it approximately seven false graves” and “leveled her grave with the ground to hide its location.” A second narration says he “sprinkled forty graves.”
Report C (Misbah al-Anwar): Ali “buried Fatimah (ra)… in al-Baqi’, and he sprinkled water around those graves so that the grave would not be known.”
Contradiction: Report A describes the grave as being leveled to the ground and surrounded by false graves (7 or 40). Report C says she was buried in al-Baqi’ (the known cemetery) and that water was sprinkled around “those graves” (plural) to obscure which one was hers. These are two different concealment methods:
Report A: false graves + leveling the actual grave to the ground (i.e., no identifiable mound at all).
Report C: burial in the public cemetery of al-Baqi’ + sprinkling water around multiple graves (i.e., the grave exists but is indistinguishable).
If the grave was leveled to the ground (Report A), there would be no need to sprinkle water around “those graves” (Report C). The leveling itself would conceal it. If she was buried in al-Baqi’ among other graves (Report C), then the “seven false graves” and “forty graves” narrations (Report A) describe a different scenario entirely. The reports are not harmonized.
Also: The number of false graves is itself inconsistent: seven in one narration, forty in another. This is a numerical discrepancy within Report A itself.
Contradiction 3: Did Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) Know Before or After the Burial?
Report B: “Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) came to offer condolences to Ali… saying: ‘O Abu al-Hasan, do not precede us in praying over the daughter of the Messenger of Allah.'” This implies they arrived before the funeral prayer and asked to participate. Ali then washed and shrouded her, prayed over her, and buried her at night with the implication that Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) were excluded despite their request.
Report D (Bihar 81/255): “And it reached Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) that Ali had buried her at night, so they said to him: ‘Why did you not inform us?'” This implies they learned of the burial after the fact and were not present beforehand.
Contradiction: In Report B, Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) are present at the house before the funeral, explicitly asking to pray over her. In Report D, they only learn after the burial that it happened at night. These are mutually exclusive timelines. If they were at the house asking to join the prayer (Report B), they would have known the burial was imminent and would not later be surprised that it happened at night (Report D).
Possible harmonization attempt: One could argue Report B’s “do not precede us” happened, then Ali delayed the burial until night specifically to avoid them, and then Report D’s “it reached them” describes their reaction the next morning. But Report B says Ali “brought her out and buried her secretly” while the mourners kept watch lest the people know and the hypocrites prevent them . If Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) had already been at the house asking to join, the “secret” was already partially compromised. The reports do not explicitly reconcile this.
Contradiction 4: Was the Funeral Prayer Public or Private?
Report B: “The people gathered and sat, clamoring, waiting outside the funeral to pray over her.” Abu Dharr comes out and tells them to disperse because the burial has been delayed until evening. Then Ali prays over her with the named attendees. So there was a public expectation of a funeral prayer, which was deliberately thwarted.
Report A: Ibn Abbas (ra) says “we buried her at night”. Here there is no mention of a public gathering or Abu Dharr dispersing anyone.
Report C: No mention of a public gathering or dispersal. It is just Ali burying her in al-Baqi’ and sprinkling water.
Discrepancy: Report B describes a significant public event. The people of Medina gathering, women of Banu Hashim screaming, Abu Dharr dispersing the crowd which is entirely absent from Reports A and C. If such a public commotion occurred (Report B says the scream “almost made Medina tremble”), it is difficult to understand how the burial could remain secret from Abu Bakr(ra) and Umar (ra) until afterward (Report D). The reports describe vastly different scales of public awareness.
Unresolved Question: Why Would Ali Level the Grave If He Buried Her in al-Baqi’?
Report C says she was buried in al-Baqi’ The well-known public cemetery. Report A says Ali leveled seven (or forty) false graves and leveled her actual grave with the ground so it would not be known.
Question: If she was buried in al-Baqi’ (Report C), a public cemetery with many graves, why would Ali need to create seven or forty false graves (Report A)? The existing graves of al-Baqi’ would already provide camouflage. Conversely, if he created forty false graves (Report A), where did he put them? In al-Baqi’ or elsewhere? The reports do not specify the location of the false graves relative to al-Baqi’. This is a geographic and logistical inconsistency.
Unresolved Question: The Role of Ibn Abbas (ra)
Report A has Ibn Abbas (ra) saying “We buried her at night” implying he was part of the burial party. But Report B‘s detailed attendee list does not include Ibn Abbas (ra). Report C and Report D do not mention him either.
Question: Was Ibn Abbas (ra)present at the burial or not? If he was (Report A), why is he omitted from the only detailed attendee list (Report B)? If he was not, why does he say “we”? This is never addressed.
Contradiction 5: The Nature of the Concealment — Leveling vs. Sprinkling Water
Report A: Ali “leveled her grave with the ground” and “sprinkled forty graves” (i.e., created forty mounds or marked forty spots).
Report C: Ali “sprinkled water around those graves so that the grave would not be known.”
Discrepancy: Report A says he leveled the grave (made it flat, indistinguishable from the ground) and separately sprinkled forty graves (implying mounds or markers). Report C says he sprinkled water around graves (implying the graves were visible but the water obscured which was fresh). These are three different concealment techniques:
Leveling the grave to the ground (Report A).
Creating 7 or 40 false graves (Report A).
Sprinkling water around existing graves in al-Baqi’ (Report C).
They are not mutually exclusive in principle, but the reports present them as alternative explanations without acknowledging each other. A reader trying to reconstruct the event cannot determine which method was actually used, or whether all three were used simultaneously (which would be logistically quite odd. Why level the grave and create forty false graves and sprinkle water around them?).
Contradiction 6: Did Fatima (ra) Make Ali Swear an Oath, or Did Ali Act on His Own Initiative?
Report B: Ali says: “She was angry with a people and disliked their attendance at her funeral, and it is forbidden.” This frames the exclusion as Fatima’s-ra dislike/anger, which Ali honors.
Report D: Ali says: “She made me swear by the right of Allah… that you two should not attend her funeral.” This frames it as an explicit oath Fatima (ra) imposed on Ali.
Report E: Ali “excused himself that she had instructed him to do so, and he swore an oath to them” meaning Ali swore an oath to Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) that Fatima (ra) had instructed him.
Contradiction: In Report B, there is no mention of an oath. It is simply just Fatima’s-ra anger and dislike. In Report D, Fatima (ra) made Ali swear an oath to her (or by Allah) to exclude them. In Report E, Ali swore an oath to Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) confirming Fatima’s-ra instruction. These are three different oath-scenarios:
No oath (Report B).
Fatima (ra) extracts an oath from Ali (Report D).
Ali swears an oath to Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) (Report E).
The reports are not harmonized on this central legal/religious point.
Unresolved Question: Why Did the Women of Banu Hashim Scream If the Burial Was Secret?
Report B: “The women of Banu Hashim gathered in her house and let out a single scream that almost made Medina tremble.” This is a very public, loud event. Yet the same report says Ali buried her “secretly” and the mourners kept watch “lest the people know.”
Question: How can a scream that “almost made Medina tremble” be reconciled with a burial so secret that Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) only learn of it afterward (Report D)? If the whole city heard the screaming, the fact of her death was public knowledge. The “secret” was only the timing and location of the burial. However, Report B also says the people gathered outside “waiting… to pray over her,” meaning they knew she had died and expected a funeral. So what exactly was secret? The reports use “secret” in different senses without clarifying:
Secret = hidden from Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) specifically?
Secret = hidden from the general public?
Secret = the grave’s location concealed?
Report B implies the public knew she died (they gathered for the funeral) but did not know when/where the burial would occur. Report D implies Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) did not know the burial had happened until afterward. These are compatible in a narrow sense, but the dramatic language (“almost made Medina tremble,” “the people came like the mane of a horse”) sits awkwardly with the claim that the burial was concealed from the two most powerful men in Medina.
Contradiction 7: The Number of False Graves — Seven vs. Forty
Report A: “approximately seven false graves” in one narration; “forty graves” in another.
Discrepancy: This is a straightforward numerical contradiction within the same source cluster. Seven vs. forty is not a minor variation. It changes the scale of the concealment effort. No attempt is made to reconcile them (e.g., “seven around the grave and forty in the cemetery” or “seven initially, then forty later”). They are presented as alternative narrations of the same act.
Unresolved Question: Where Was Fatima (ra) Buried?
Report A: Grave leveled to the ground, surrounded by 7 (or 40) false graves. Location not specified.
Report C: Buried in al-Baqi’.
Report B: Buried “secretly”. The location not specified, but the mourners kept watch “lest the people know.”
Report D: Buried at night. The location not specified.
Report E: Buried at night. The location not specified.
Question: If she was buried in al-Baqi’ (Report C), why do Reports A, B, D, and E not mention al-Baqi’? And if the grave was leveled to the ground and surrounded by false graves (Report A), how could it be “in al-Baqi'” in any identifiable sense? The reports leave the actual location ambiguous. Which is ironic given that the entire point of the concealment narratives is that the location was deliberately hidden. But the narrators themselves disagree on whether it was in the public cemetery or in an unmarked location outside it.
BUT WAIT THERE’S MORE!
Shi’i Claim A (the “aggression” narrative): Umar (ra) & Abu Bakr (ra) attacked Fatima’s (ra) house, threatened to burn it, caused her injury (including the miscarriage of Muhsin in the more developed versions), and were responsible for her death. This is the dominant Shi’i narrative of the events between the Saqifa and Fatima’s (ra) death.
Shi’i Claim B (the “exclusion” narrative): Fatima (ra) was so angry with Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) that she made Ali swear an oath to prevent them from attending her funeral and, in some reports, the grave was concealed specifically so they could not visit it or pray at it.
Our question is: if Claim A is true, why would Claim B be necessary? If Umar (ra) had just burned her house and ultimately killed her, why would anyone expect him to want to visit her grave? Why would concealing the grave be the mechanism to stop him? The concealment implies a man who wants to show up and pay respects, which sits awkwardly with a man who allegedly just committed violence against her.
Why This Is a Genuine Problem Within the Shi’i Sources
This isn’t just some polemical jab or cheap shot. The reports themselves create the tension:
Report B has Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) coming to offer condolences and asking to join the funeral prayer. Which is a posture of respect and reconciliation, not aggression. This is the same report that says Fatima (ra) was “angry with a people and disliked their attendance.”
Report D has Umar (ra) saying “this is rancor in your chest!” a hostile exchange, but still one in which Umar (ra) is engaging with Ali about attending the funeral. He wants to be there!
Report E has Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) reproaching Ali for not informing them, then believing his excuse and accepting it again, a posture of wanting to participate and then being reconciled.
So the reports themselves portray Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) as wanting to attend the funeral and visit the grave. That is the premise the concealment is responding to. The concealment only makes narrative sense if the expectation was that they would come.
If we take the aggression narrative seriously, the following questions arise:
Why would Umar (ra) want to pray over her or visit her grave? If he had assaulted her and caused her death, attending her funeral would be either (a) a cynical public-relations move, (b) an act of hypocrisy, or (c) evidence that the aggression narrative is overstated or later polemical development. The reports don’t explore any of these possibilities . They simply assume he wanted to attend.
Why would concealing the grave be the effective mechanism? If Umar (ra) was willing to burn down her house and assault her, concealing a grave would hardly stop a determined man from finding it or from making a public issue of it. The concealment narrative treats Umar (ra) as someone who respects the grave’s sanctity enough to be deterred by not knowing its location which is a strange characterization of a man who (in the same narratives) allegedly desecrated her home.
Why would Fatima (ra) need to extract an oath from Ali? If the relationship was as hostile as the aggression narrative suggests, an oath would be superfluous. Ali would naturally exclude them. The oath narrative implies that without the oath, Ali might have allowed them to attend, which implies a baseline of normal social relations, not mortal enmity.
The concealment rationale reads as retrofit. The most natural reading of the reports is:
Fatima’s grave was concealed for some reason.
Later narrators, operating within a framework where Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) were already cast as usurpers and aggressors, needed to explain why the grave was concealed specifically from them.
The explanation chosen “she made Ali swear they would not attend” which serves to retroactively justify the exclusion while simultaneously implying they wanted to attend, which inadvertently softens their image.
In other words, the polemical need to have Fatima(ra) reject Abu Bakr (ra) and Umar (ra) required them to be present and asking to participate (otherwise the rejection has no object). But this creates the awkward implication that they were eager to honor her. This itself cuts against the aggression narrative.
The fact that the reports disagree on why the burial was secret is itself telling:
Report B: Fatima (ra) was angry at “a people” and disliked their attendance. (No mention of house-burning here.)
Report D: Umar (ra) accuses Ali of rancor; Ali says Fatima (ra) made him swear to exclude them specifically. (Hostile, but they still wanted to attend.)
Report E: They reproach Ali, he swears an oath, they believe him and accept his excuse. (Reconciled. Which is hard to square with the aggression narrative.)
These are three different rationales, and none of them mentions the house-burning, the miscarriage, or the assault. The concealment narratives operate in a different register from the aggression narratives. They presuppose ordinary political tension and wounded feelings, not lethal violence. That gap is exactly the inconsistency we are pointing to!
Prima Qur’an conclusion and summary.
The title of the article: Investigating theallegations that Ali ibn Abi Talib was responsible for the death and nocturnal burial of Fatima bint Muhammed
We looked at three possible motives and we feel we have given strong rebuttal to all three. Two of which really had no basis to stand on to begin with.
Question: Does this rule out the possiblity of Ali having killed Fatima bint Muhammed (ra)?
Answer: No, it does not. Accidents also happen. However, the three motives do not tally with our findings. Alas, in Islam you need strong evidence for such charges!
However, It is just simply odd that neither the Sunni nor the Shi’i sources mention the cause of her death. The sudden death of a presumably healthy young woman who was 18 according to the Shi’i sources and 27 to 29 according to the Sunni sources.
Ali Ibn Abi Talib burried Fatima(ra) the daughter of the Messenger of Allah (saw) in the middle of the night. It looks like he alone washed her and he aloned prayed over her and it is also very plausible that he alone buried her. No one know to this day knows where her noble resting place is!
Brothers and sisters, dear readers we ask you the following. By today’s standards be it in China, or India, England or the United States, South Africa or Argentina what would happen?
What would happen if a man burried his wife in the middle of the night after she died? Would this be allowed? Would the passing of a man’s wife be treated like an open/shut case?
We cannot say for certain, but it is likely we are the first among the Ibadi to write about these things. That is because as a rule, our school in general has no interest in these matters.
In the books of the Ibadi you do not find things like Iblis loves Imam Ali and narrates from the Prophet (saw) concerning him.
We do not have in our books that Ali would slosh his words about in prayer while intoxicated and thus became the occasion for some verses form the Qur’an.
What our school ask of the Ummah is in reality what Allah (swt) ask of us in the Qur’an.
“Indeed, the Muslim men and Muslim women, the believing men and believing women, the obedient men and obedient women, the truthful men and truthful women, the patient men and patient women, the humble men and humble women, the charitable men and charitable women, the fasting men and fasting women, the men who guard their private parts and the women who do so, and the men who remember Allah often and the women who do so – for them Allah has prepared forgiveness and a great reward.” (Qur’an 33:35)
“Indeed, Allah commands you to render trusts to whom they are due and when you judge between people to judge with justice. Excellent is that which Allah instructs you. Indeed, Allah is ever Hearing and Seeing.” (Qur’an 4:58)
﷽
This is a sociological experiment our colleague conducted on their social media regarding the tale of some from among the Shi’i in relation to Umar (ra), Ali and Fatima (ra).
Narrated `Aisha:
Once, Fatima came walking and her gait resembled the gait of the Prophet (saw). The Prophet (saw) said, “Welcome, O my daughter!” Then he made her sit on his right or on his left side, and then he told her a secret and she started weeping. I asked her, “Why are you weeping?” He again told her a secret and she started laughing. I said, “I never saw happiness so near to sadness as I saw today.” I asked her what the Prophet (saw) had told her. She said, “I would never disclose the secret of Allah’s Messenger (saw).” When the Prophet (saw) died, I asked her about it. She replied. “The Prophet (saw) said: ‘Every year Gabriel used to revise the Qur’an with me once only, but this year he has done so twice. I think this portends my death, and you will be the first of my family to follow me.’ So I started weeping. Then he said. ‘Don’t you like to be the chief of all the ladies of Paradise or the chief of the believing women? So I laughed for that.”
If indeed the Shi’i believe that this narration is true and that Fatima (ra) would be the first from among the family of the Beloved Messenger (saw) to die, it cannot also be true that the “unborn” son of Fatima would die as he would technically be the ‘first of my family’ to follow.
Ali bin Abi Talib said:
“When al Hassan was born, the Prophet (saw) came and said: Show me, my boy, what have you named him? I said: I called him Harb, he said: Nay,” He is Hassan When al Hussein was born, the Prophet (saw)said: Show me my boy, what have you named him? I said: Harb, he said: Nay, he is Hussein, and when the third was born, the Prophet (saw) came, then said: Show me, my boy, what have you named him? I said: Harb. He said: Nay, he is Muhassin, then he said: I have named them after the names of the children of Haroun(Aaron). They are Shibr, Shubeir, Mushabbar.”
Source: (Musnad Ahmad 1/98, Isnad is sound)
لمَّا وُلِد الحَسنُ فقال أروني ابنِي ما سمَّيْتُموه قُلْتُ حَرْبًا قال بل هو حَسنٌ قال فلمَّا وُلِد الحُسَينُ سمَّيْتُه حَرْبًا فجاء رسولُ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم فقال أروني ابنِي ما سمَّيْتُموه قُلْتُ حَرْبًا قال بل هو حُسَينٌ فلمَّا وُلِد الثَّالِثُ سمَّيْتُه حَرْبًا فجاء النَّبيُّ صلَّى اللهُ عليه وسلَّم فقال أروني ابنِي ما سمَّيْتُموه قُلْتُ حَرْبًا قال بل هو مُحَسِّنٌ ثُمَّ قال سمَّيْتُهم بأسماءَ ولدِ هارونَ شَبَرٍ وشُبَيرٍ ومُبشِّرٍ [ وفي روايةٍ ] قال سمَّيْتُهم بأسماءِ ولدِ هارونَ جَبَرٍ وجُبَيرٍ ومُجَبِّرٍ. خلاصة حكم المحدث: رجالهما رجال الصحيح غير هانئ بن هانئ وهو ثقة الراوي: علي بن أبي طالب المحدث: الهيثمي المصدر: مجمع الزوائد الصفحة أو الرقم: 8/55 التخريج : أخرجه أحمد (769)، وابن حبان (6958)، والطبراني (3/ 96) (2773) جميعا بلفظه.
It’s not believable to say that Muhassin was aborted as a fetus and yet the above narration says that he was born.
Here is a video of Ayatollah Sayyid Fadhlallaha, a Shi’i Imam, who thinks this whole tale about Ali, Umar (ra) and Fatima (ra) is a big fat, juicy fabrication. For those who can’t click on English subtitles in the post, we have put the YouTube link where you can click on English subtitles.
Surely the Imam has his reward with Allah (swt) for seeking truth on the matter.
Also, remember the presence of a statement in a book does not necessarily make it authentic. We do not know of anyone who holds this position. The chains of narrators the isnad needs to be scrutinized. Do the reports contradict other pieces of evidence? This is what needs to be understood when engaging in dialogue with anyone from among the Muslims.
Now let us assume, for the sake of argument, that this incident took place as suggested by the Shi’i. Obviously, learned people like the Ayatollah above don’t buy it for a hot minute.
SOCIOLOGICAL EXPERIMENT ON FACEBOOK.We CALL THIS: “THE FATIMA EXPERIMENT”
So, knowing that Muslims have a vested interest in this alleged incident and there are emotional attachments to it, our colleague decided to ask people who were absolutely clueless about this incident.
Our colleague decided that they would would ask their non-Muslim friends about their thoughts concerning the characters of the two major individuals in this incident. So this is the data that our colleague gave to them:
“I want my non-Muslim friends to answer this question. Any Muslim who comments, I’ll delete it. This is a sociological experiment.”
“What would you say about a man (person A) who punched another man’s wife (person B) in the stomach and caused her to miscarry? Person B (a man) does absolutely nothing in response to person A (a man).”
“Later, person B marries one of his daughters to person A.”
“Person B names his son the same name as person A.”
“In the Fatima experiment. Person A is Umar Ibn Al Khattab (ra) and Person B is Ali ibn Abu Talib.”
What follows are their responses. Some of them are quite interesting. We have covered up their names to protect/respect their personal privacy. These are mostly U.S. Americans. They hold nothing back.
Well, so there you have it. 20 different responses to this scenario. Not favourable views of Umar (ra) and almost unanimously unfavourable views of Ali
Now we have The Lady of Heaven film that has created quite a controversy.
May Allah (swt) guide our tongues to speak the truth and our hearts to have the courage to say it. May Allah (swt) guide us from speaking falsely about any person’s incident or matter. Amin!
“And if Allah did not check one set of people by means of another, the earth would indeed be full of mischief (fasad). But Allah is full of bounty to all the worlds.” (Qur’an 2:251)
“And were it not that Allah checks the people, some by means of others, there would have been demolished monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques in which the name of Allah is much mentioned.” (Qur’an 22:40)”
﷽
Islamic scholars point out that the group used to repel an oppressor does not necessarily have to be righteous itself. Allah sometimes uses one aggressive or unjust power to neutralize another, preventing any single force from holding absolute, unchallenged dominion over the earth.
Translation:
“Abu Nami the Second is considered the true founder of the Sharifate, and he is the grandfather of the family that remained holding the Sharifate until Ibn Saud eliminated it in the year 1925. It is known about Abu Nami that he was extremely proud of his lineage and was accustomed in his life to distinguishing between people according to their lineages and their houses, based on the hadith of the Prophet: “I have been commanded to place people in their proper places.” His view was that lineage is the essence of nobility, and lineage is also the elevation of character. As for the common people, in the view of Abu Nami, they are the base of the pyramid. If the high-ranking positions in society go to the base, then perhaps harm may result from that.”
It appears that the Ottoman State supported Abu Nami in this opinion, and in reality, this opinion was widespread among the people, with many believing in it and some of them remain believers in it to this day. This opinion of Abu Nami’s reached the point of laying down rules known as “The Law of Abu Nami,” intended to distinguish the Sharifs from others officially. It is worth mentioning that these rules remained hidden from people, known only to a limited number of Sharifs who passed them among themselves and did not allow anyone else to review them. The author of the book “History of the Hejaz” claims that he reviewed some of these rules and mentioned them in his book as follows:
The text is a legal document listing regulations that applied to the Hashemite Sharifs in Mecca. These rules granted the Sharifs significant legal privileges. Dear brothers and sisters we absolutely cannot go back to this model!
These are the type of unjust and evil rulings that the privledged class deployed.
These specific rules were documented by Hussein Muhammed Nassif in his book Tarikh Al-Hijaz (History of the Hejaz, published in Cairo around 1349 AH / 1931 CE), which references the traditional social laws and codes enforced regarding the status, rights, and protections of the Ashraf class.
Ashraf (Sharif) status is hereditary within the Hashemite family.
It is not permissible for any Sharif to work in any profession or craft except for “Al-Qirashah” namely firewood, charcoal, camels, and agriculture.
If a Sharif is killed, retribution is taken from the killer’s family or their village, where four of them are killed in retaliation.
Whoever slaps a Sharif shall have his hand cut off.
Whoever insults or curses a Sharif shall have his tongue cut off.
A Sharif is not to be triedin the assembly of his adversary.
If someone intends to kill a Sharif or raises a weapon against him, he is banished from the country.
A Sharif is not put to death if he kills a non-Sharif.
The ruling Sharif receives one-third of the blood money (diyyah) of the slain person.
This type of caste system which was instituted by some people who hold special privledge and rank for the Hashemites is antithetical to Islam. It is antithetical to the core!
“If a Sharif is killed, retribution is taken from the killer’s family or their village, where four of them are killed in retaliation.”
So if a person kills someone of this so called ‘noble’ lineage they in turn not only kill the one who killed but from your family they may select your wife, your child, your mother and kill them!
These positions strike at the verses of the Qur’an and seek to abrogate them!
“And We ordained for them therein a life for a life, an eye for an eye, a nose for a nose, an ear for an ear, a tooth for a tooth, and for wounds is legal retribution. But whoever gives [up his right as] charity, it is an expiation for him. And whoever does not judge by what Allah has revealed then it is those who are the wrongdoers.” (Qur’an 5:45)
“O you who have believed, prescribed for you is legal retribution for those murdered the free for the free, the slave for the slave, and the female for the female. But whoever overlooks from his brother anything, then there should be a suitable follow-up and payment to him with good conduct. This is an alleviation from your Lord and a mercy. But whoever transgresses after that will have a painful punishment.” (Qur’an 2:178)
Dear Muslim Ummah, we absolutely cannot go back to this!
As for what Abu Nami relies upon for evidence:
Narrated Maimun ibn Abu Shabib:
A beggar passed by Aisha and she gave him a piece of bread. Another man who wore clothes and had a good appearance passed by her, and she made him sit down and he ate (with her). When she was asked about that, she replied: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: Treat the people according to their ranks.
“And say, ‘My Lord, increase me in knowledge.” (Qur’an 20:114)
﷽
This article will examine how Ahmad Ibn Hanbal’s reform of the Uthmaniyyah position built a bridge toward tashayyu’ and Shi’ism and demolished the bridge toward the pro-Umayyad.
Between the two available directions, the Pro/AlidShi’i-leaning one became crossable and the anti-Alid/Anti-Shi’i one became impassable
Ahmad ibn Hanbal his family background.
Most Sunni Muslims are completely unaware of the background and history of Imam Ahmad’s family. The paternal grandfather of Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal al-Dhuhli al-Shaybani was Hanbal ibn Hilal.
Hanbal ibn Hilal was a governor under the Umayyads: Hanbal ibn Hilal was an administrative and military figure stationed in the restive, eastern frontier province of Khorasan. During the Umayyad era, he was appointed as the local governor of Sarakhs (a strategic oasis city located on the Silk Road between Marw and Nishapur, split today across the Iran-Turkmenistan border.
The Shift to the Abbasid Revolution: As the Hashimiyya (the underground Abbasid revolutionary movement) gained rapid momentum in Khorasan during the 740s, many local Arab military elites grew disillusioned with the Umayyad leadership in Damascus. Hanbal ibn Hilal rebelled against his Umayyad rulers and defected, aligning his family and tribal influence with the Abbasid call (al-Da’wa).
His family’s betrayal of the Umayyads paid off.
Following the successful Abbasid Revolution in 750 CE, the newly established Abbasid Caliphate kept him in his administrative capacity, allowing him to continue governing Sarakhs under the new regime.
A Family Military Legacy: His defiance set the trajectory for his family. His son, Muhammed ibn Hanbal, grew up to become a soldier in the frontier Abbasid army, and his grandson, Imam Ahmad, was subsequently born into a household deeply shaped by the fallout of this Khorasani migration to the new capital of Baghdad.
Al-Jahiz wrote a book in the year 200 AH: titled ‘Kitab al-Uthmaniyyah‘.
There are three majojr political factions that he speaks of.
He did not mention the existence of a sect called ‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah‘ its as if he never heard of it.
Al-Jahiz outlined three major opposing parties.
1- (Al-ʿUthmaniyyah) They do not recognize the caliphate of Ali ibn Abi Talib. Those who upheld the legitimacy of the third caliph Uthman and argued for the superiority and primary right of Abu Bakr. They are the supporters of Uthman ibn Affan, Lady Aisha, Muawiyah, and the Umayyads.
At his time they are the majority of the Islamic nation, including the scholars and jurists.
Rather than vanishing into thin air, they were absorbed into the Abbasid project during the 9th and 10th centuries The Abbasid project became known as: ‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah’.
2-Alids (Al-Shi’a): Those who believed that Ali ibn Abi Talib and the Prophet’s household held the exclusive, divine right to the leadership. This group would split. Partially this movement was absorbed into the Abbasdid project during the 9th and 10th centuries becoming known as: ‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah’.
They would consist of those who considered Ali ibn Abi Talib as the fourth of the Rightly Guided Caliphs and those who believed he had better right all along but were content with his new found recognition. During the formation of the Sufi tariqa the idea that to know the object of love i.e the Prophet (saw) would be to know who it is you are loving. The best way to do this would be via the ‘Ahl Bayt’ -the descendants of who were the heads of Sufi Tariqa.
Those not absorbed were the Zaydi.
3. Abbasids (Al-ʿAbbasiyyah): Those who championed the rights of the descendants of the Prophet’s uncle, Al-Abbas, to the Caliphate. They become the architects of the project known as: ‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah’.
Although Al Jahiz did not put thes following among the big three partially becuase they fall under the Alid camp we would put them in category 4.
4. The Rejectionists: Those who would latter be known as the Imami Shi’i. Defined by their rejection of the caliphates of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman and extreme veneration (Ghuluww) toward Ali.
‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah’ has the task of balancing between these absorbed groups. They must balance between Tashayyu and Nasb.
However, as we will see this balance actually became tilted in one direction with the other direction being completely cut off.
So why would we call ‘Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah’ as ‘diet Shi’i’ rather than ‘diet Uthmaniyyah’?
It is clear to us that with what Ahmad Ibn Hanbal did he tiltled the balance towards the Alid camp and supplied them with amunition that he did not give the Uthmaniyyah camp.
We already saw that his family had a history of betraying the Uthmaniyya and allying with the Abbasids.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal is not a hero of what people perceive as modern Sunni orthodoxy, but a pragmatic reformer who served the Abbasid state.
TheTarbi‘ was a political innovation to absorb Shi’i/Pro Alid sentiment.
The Musnad is jam packed with Shi’i narrators and fabricated hadiths (like the 30-year caliphate hadith, among others).
The So-Called “Mihna” of Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal: The Making of Controlled Opposition.
Many of us have heard of the Abbasid caliph al-Ma’mun instituting this inquisition against anyone who refused to profess that the Qur’an was created. In the Abbasid era, al-Ma’mun intervened as a patron of the Mu’tazili school, resorting to force and coercion to impose his doctrines upon the scholars and the hadith folk. After him came al-Mu’tasim.
The accounts of what happened are narrated by al-Dhahabi, Ibn Kathir, and Ibn al-Jawzi, coming via Ibn Hanbal’s own family members. That is Salih bin Ahmad bin Hanbal and Hanbal bin Ishaq.
Al-Dhahabi’s account identifies figures who remained steadfast and did not comply: Muhammed ibn Nuh, who died while being taken to al-Ma’mun; Nu’aym ibn Hammad, who died in prison; and Abu Ya’qub al-Buwayti, who died in al-Wathiq’s prison.
The great scholar Ahmad ibn Nasr al-Khuza’i was killed and impaled, his head hung in the streets of Baghdad for years. According to Ibn Kathir, al-Wathiq personally beheaded him with his own sword after interrogating him over the createdness of the Qur’an, and the head remained displayed until al-Mutawakkil came to power.
Muhammed ibn Nuh’s fate is instructive. Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi’s account describes him being transported together with Ahmad ibn Hanbal after both refused to assent to the createdness of the Qur’an. They were carried on a single camel, bound together. He became ill during the journey and died on the road. Ahmad reportedly performed his funeral prayer and buried him.
Abu Ya’qub al-Buwayti is particularly important. He was a prominent disciple of al-Shafi’i, described as the one whom al-Shafi’i designated as “my tongue” when sending answers to questions. He was taken from Egypt to Baghdad under al-Wathiq, refused to affirm the createdness of the Qur’an, and remained imprisoned in chains until his death. Al-Rabi’ reports seeing him in the days of the Mihna, shackled to the middle of his legs, his hands bound to his neck, and he would say: “By Allah, I will die in my iron chains so that a people after me may know that some died for this cause in their iron chains.”
Yet when it comes to Ahmad ibn Hanbal himself, the reports grow strange. According to al-Jahiz whom is a a hostile contemporary source; Ibn Hanbal did not undergo numerous lashings, and the whips themselves were unbarbed with frayed tips, relatively soft and painless. This is if he underwent any lashings at all!
We are also given fantastical narratives, such as the account in Tabaqat al-Hanabila by Ibn Abi Ya’la, in which the earth splits open and two hands emerge to support Ibn Hanbal during his flogging, prompting al-Mu’tasim to order his release.
“Sulayman al-Sijzi said: Then Ahmad ibn Hanbal was stripped of his clothes, wrapped in a woolen garment, and two new ropes were tied around his hands. He took the whip in his hand and said: “Shall I strike him, O Commander of the Faithful?” Al-Mu’tasim said: “Strike.” He struck him one lash, and Ahmad said: “Praise be to Allah.” He struck him a second time, and he said: “What Allah wills shall be.” He struck him a third time, and he said: “There is no might nor power except with Allah, the Most High, the Most Great.” When he wanted to strike him the fourth lash, I looked at the waist-wrapper slipping from his waist and about to fall. He raised his head toward the sky and moved his lips, and behold, the earth split open and two hands emerged and supported him by the power of Allah. When Al-Mu’tasim saw that, he said: “Release him.” Then Ibn Abi Du’ad came forward to him and said: “O Ahmad, say in my ear: ‘The Qur’an is created,’ so that I may save you from the hand of the Caliph.” Ahmad said to him: “O Ibn Abi Du’ad, say in my ear: ‘The Qur’an is the speech of Allah, uncreated,’ so that I may save you from the punishment of Allah.” Al-Mu’tasim said: “Take him to prison.” Sulayman said: He was taken to prison, and the people dispersed and I dispersed with them. The next day, the people came and I came with them and stood facing the chair. Al-Mu’tasim came out and sat on the chair and said: “Bring Ahmad ibn Hanbal.” He was brought, and when he stood before him, Al-Mu’tasim said to him: “How were you in your prison last night, O Ibn Hanbal?” He said: “I was well, and praise be to Allah.”
The source: (Tabaqat al-Hanabila -The Generations of the Hanbalis by Ibn Abi Ya’la)
We have exsposed before these type of fantastical narratives here:
The usual biographical narrative explains Ahmad’s release by pointing to public pressure and the danger of turning him into a martyr. There are reports that the authorities feared the reaction of the people if he died. But we must be careful: that explanation is a historical interpretation of the circumstances, not something that can be treated as conclusively established merely because later biographers repeat it.
If the purpose of the Mihna was to establish the createdness of the Qur’an as an enforceable public doctrine, then releasing a prominent scholar who continued to reject that doctrine was an obvious failure in one important respect. That is unless there is another calculus.
Stage 1. The Mihna was ultimately not as a dogmatic failure of the Abbasids, but as a sophisticated tool of statecraft designed to manufacture controlled opposition.
Stage 2. The state apparatus acts as the anvil, using targeted persecution to forge Ahmad ibn Hanbal into the undisputed, singular champion of the Ahl Hadith.
Stage 3. By ending the Mihna and elevating Ahmad Ibn Hanbal,the state successfully tames the Ahl Hadith and diminishes the threat from their cheif rival; The Umayyads. The chief threat to the caliphate dissolves into a state-sanctioned scholasticism.
Can it truly be believed that so many were killed and imprisoned until death yet Ahmad Ibn Hanbal gets released?
Either Ahmad Ibn Hanbal capitulated and said the Qur’an was created.
Or he was spared altogether for the project of ‘Ahl Sunnah Wal Jammah’.
There is good reason to suspect that the so-called persecution of Ahmad ibn Hanbal served as a smokescreen to establish him as the leader of the Ahl al-Hadith
As the saying goes:
“Beware the enemy who bleeds at your doorstep; he buys your pity today to sell you ruin tomorrow.”
His family ties to the Abbasids are a matter of record.
His grandfather Hanbal was a governor of Sarakhs during the Umayyad period, and his father Muhammed was a soldier in the Abbasid army in Khurasan. His grandfather was among those who fought for the Abbasids during the revolution. We find this in Ibn al-Jawzi’s Manaqib al-Imam Ahmad, which preserves a report identifying Hanbal ibn Hilal as governor of Sarakhs and associating him with those who fought for the Abbasids.
The family’s relationship with the Abbasids and the Hashimites was excellent. Which is precisely why he was singled out for prominence during the ordeal over the createdness of the Qur’an and was not killed, unlike Muhammed ibn Nuh, who died on the road, or al-Buwayti, who perished in chains.
Just as his father and grandfather had done favours for the Abbasid state, Ahmad ibn Hanbal was yet to play his hand. But unlike them, he did not bring a sword to the Abbasid court. He brought something far more powerful: his pen, and the admiration of the Ahl al-Hadith camp.
Ahmad Ibn Hanbal shattered the yoke.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal shattered the yoke,and reformed the direction of the school of Ahl al-Hadith, who are an extension of the “Uthmaniyyah” orientation, for we find him transmitting in his Musnad or his works many narrations concerning the virtues of Ali.
In his mass-volume Hadith compilation, the Musnad, and his book Fada’il al-Sahaba (Virtues of the Companions), Ibn Hanbal narrated an overwhelming amount of traditions exalting Ali’s bravery, spiritual rank, and closeness to the Prophet (saw). He famously noted that no companion had as many verified virtues recorded with good chains as Ali!
In fact, if you research no other hadith collection classified as ‘Sunni’ contains as many narrations and accolades of Ali as the Musnad of Imam Ahmad!
To give you a sense of scale.
The narrations from Ali in the Muwatta are around 21.
Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal equated Ali with the Caliphs, going against the consensus of the Uthmaniyyah community for 200 years that the fourth caliph was Muawiyah. This was the view of the Umayyad Caliphate for 89 years as the Umayyad State of Cordoba for 275 years.
Here is where Ahmad Ibn Hanbal become and effective scholar of the Abbasid state aparatus.
As the researcher Shaykh Rasul Jafarian mentions the iscussion of Fadail al-Sahabah is particularly relevant. He notes the substantial space devoted to Ali’s virtues and discusses reports concerning:
Ghadir Khumm;
The hadith of Manzilah;
The Two Weighty Things;
The revelation of the verse of purification;
Ali’s early acceptance of Islam.
Jafarian argues that Ahmad’s transmission of these reports helped break the older anti-Alid orientation within Ahl al-Hadith.
He was the one who began the Tarbi’ (Squaring) of Ali. He was instrumental in convincing many of his ‘Ahl Hadith’ colleagues to reform. In Particular those of the “Uthmaniyyah” orientation. That who did not permit or allow Ali ibn Abi Talib to be granted the attribute of “legitimate caliph”.
Imam Yahya ibn Ma’in used to order Ahmad ibn Hanbal to stop narrating from Abd al-Razzaq al-San’ani because he was accused of Tashayyu’ or having (Shi’i leanings). Inspite of this Ahmad Ibn Hanbal would continue to narrate from Abd al-Razzaq.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal began to narrate the hadith of Safina about the caliphate lasting thirty years. This was to spite the Umayyad Caliphs. It was a strong slap in the face.
This was narrated by the Iraqi Sa‘id ibn Jumhan, about whom Imam al-Bukhari said: “There are strange things in his hadith.”
Musnad Ahmad ibn Hanbal is the primary source text for this narration.
In fact the hadith itself as it stands before your very eyes does not even attempt to hide it’s political motivations. Observe yourself dear readers.
“Narrated Safinah:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: The Caliphate of Prophecy will last thirty years; then Allah will give the Kingdom of His Kingdom to anyone He wills.
Sa’id told that Safinah said to him: Calculate Abu Bakr’s caliphate as two years, ‘Umar’s as ten, ‘Uthman’s as twelve and ‘Ali so and so. Sa’id said: I said to Safinah: They conceive that ‘Ali was not a caliph. He replied: The buttocks of Marwan told a lie.”
“Safinah narrated to me, he said: ‘The Messenger of Allah(s.a.w) said: “Al-Khilafah will be in my Ummah for thirty years, then there will be monarchy after that.”‘ Then Safinah said to me: ‘Count the Khilafah of Abu Bakr,’ then he said: ‘Count the Khilafah of ‘Umar and the Khilafah of ‘Uthman.’ Then he said to me: ‘Count the Khilafah of ‘Ali.”‘ He said: “So we found that they add up to thirty years.” Sa’eed said: “I said to him: ‘Banu Umaiyyah claim that the Khilafah is among them.’ He said: ‘Banu Az-Zarqa’ lie, rather they are a monarchy, among the worst of monarchies.”‘
Ahmad Ibn Hanbal by authenticating the above hadith stating that the Rashidun Caliphate lasted 30 years, effectively made the history that came after pitch black. So what does that say about Mu’awiya?
What does that say about the Uthmaniyyah?
In fact, his son, Abdullah, said to him: How do you say that Ali ibn Abi Talib was a caliph, when Ali himself said, “I am not a caliph, and what happened was a trial”? Ahmad ibn Hanbal replied that this was humility on the part of Ali! Thus, Ahmad ibn Hanbal attributed to Ali what Ali himself did not claim for himself!
For after Ahmad ibn Hanbal made apparent the doctrine of the “Tarbi'” with Ali ibn Abi Talib, the doctrine at the time caused an uproar and a shock among the general body of hadith scholars, to the point that they came to Ahmad ibn Hanbal debating him on the matter and rejecting it upon him, saying to him: By this doctrine you are impugning Talha and al-Zubayr, because the doctrine of the validity of the caliphate of Ali ibn Abi Talib is a direct impugnment of the religion of Talha and al-Zubayr and Mu’awiya and the Mother of the Believers Aisha and Amr ibn al-As, etc.
The Argument of his oppoents was basically this: If Ali ibn Abi Talib was a legitimately mandated, divinely supported Rashid caliph whose obedience was religiously obligatory, then anyone who took up arms against him or refused to pledge allegiance was in major violation of Islamic law.
The conclusion they deduced was as follows: This framework inadvertently cast figures like Talha ibn Ubaydullah, al-Zubayr ibn al-Awwam, Mu’awiya ibn Abi Sufyan, Amr ibn al-As, and Aisha (the Mother of the Believers) as rebels against legitimate authority. To the traditionalists, affirming Ali’s caliphate meant compromised theological integrity for these revered Companions. In the process that makes all of them kharijites, renegades, rebels, breakers of allegiance, and their blood lawful!
Guess which ‘Sunni’ Imam has controversy surrounding him in regard to the permissiblity on cursing Yazid ibn Mu’awiya? Is it Imam Malik? No. Is it Abu Hanifa? No. Is it Imam Shafi’i? No.
Is it Ahmad Ibn Hanbal? Winner winner chicken dinner!
Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal’s son, Saleh bin Ahmad, narrates: I asked my father about some people who say that they love Yazid. Imam Ahmad replied, “My son, can a person who believes in Allah and the Day of Judgment love Yazid?!” I then asked, “Why don’t you curse him, then?” Imam Ahmad replied, “My son, have you ever seen me cursing anyone?”
Source: (Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah, Vol. 4, Page 483)
And as the Shi’i researcher Shaykh Rasul Jafarian said, “Ahmad shattered the yoke.”
Meaning that he shattered the gate of those Muslims and opened it to the Shi’i, and it will not be closed.
This is why as we mentioned in our earlier article the Neo-Umayyad movement was concerned.
And of course this doctrine opened a door for the Shi’i that they would never have dreamed of, since the Anti-Alid opposition did not acknowledge the caliphate of Ali ibn Abi Talib throughout the Umayyad era, and even into the third century of the Abbasid era, until the era of Ahmad, people at that time did not know the doctrine that Ali was the fourth caliph, and that was considered repugnant among them and a strange doctrine with no evidence for it.
All that the Shi’i wants from the Abbassid ‘Sunni’ is to say that Ali was more in the right and that the Household of the Prophet (saw) are the people of the Hadith of the Cloak (Hadith al-Kisa’).
We have already proved that the narration of (Hadith al-Kisa’) is nothing more than an obvious concoction.
Imagine the Sunni out there who sees him/herself as some adversary of the Shi’i without realizing that they themselves are a form of Shi’i.
The Salafi who burns with rage towards Shi’ism but accepts the various narrations that allows the Shi’i to kick in the front door and park themselves comfortably on the living room couch!
That is just bizzarre to us!
The following the research of Rasul Jafarian on the matter. The article title is: The Schools of Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah (The Role of Ahmad ibn Hanbal in Reform and Change) by Shaykh Rasul Jafarian.
About the author.
Rasul Jafarian is an Iranian Shi’i cleric and researcher in the field of Iranian history. He is currently the Professor of the Department of History at the University of Tehran, the Director of the Specialized library on Islam and Iran, and the Director of the Central Library of the University of Tehran.
We present to you his research and paper.
Introduction (1):
It appears that the divergence of opinions in the doctrinal, jurisprudential, and historical fields emerged in the first Hijri century, as sectarian groups gradually arose. As a result of political conflicts and the accompanying doctrinal, jurisprudential, and historical disputes, over time this led to the sectarian division of Muslims according to their cities at first, then this spread within the cities in a manner proportionate to local sectarian conflicts.
These differences crystallized in the second century to a great extent, but before reaching the level of sectarian groups, they remained revolving in the orbit of the doctrines of specific individuals such as: Abu Hanifa, Ghaylan al-Dimashqi, Jahm ibn Safwan, and others, who can be considered the origins of doctrinal conflict.
However, the clear and distinct differentiation between the sects did not appear except in the time of al-Ma’mun, who was known for his zeal and severity in imposing his own beliefs on people, his inclination toward the Mu’tazila, and his lack of concern for the Ahl al-Hadith despite the status they had among the common people.
Thus the various schools emerged gradually under the influence of different historical, cultural, and social circumstances, allowing a single school, within a span of time, to become susceptible to change and alteration, affected by its historical position, its enemies, and even its leaders, such that it could transform and appear in different phases among them, to the extent that it sometimes leads to the division of a single school into a number of different sects.
(1) Years ago, when I was in the service of Professor Ayatollah al-Hajj Sayyid Mahdi Rohani—may his shadow endure—I was inspired by him with the original idea of this article. He graciously reviewed the article before its publication, and it was as if his tongue was saying at the time: “This is our merchandise returned to us.” [Page – 301]
The most important matter that must be known is to grasp the path of development of a doctrinal current that fell captive to excess and negligence throughout its long history, which may sometimes make it different from its original image in which it arose.
For example, the Sunni school, whose foundation was the events in the era of the two Shaykhs, or what happened of changes in the time of Uthman, and the stance of the Imam Amir al-Mu’minin (peace be upon him) toward them, and most important of all is the form it acquired in the Umayyad era. It differed from what came later under the name of Ahl al-Hadith or the Uthmani school.
A significant part of this doctrinal orientation which did not permit or allow Amir al-Mu’minin Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon him) to be granted the attribute of legitimate caliph was reformed thanks to the efforts exerted by Ahmad ibn Hanbal, which helped in adopting a more appropriate stance toward Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
In the middle of the fourth century, Abu al-Hasan al-Ash’ari introduced many changes into this school in doctrinal matters, and then after that, following the emergence of Sufism, a new image of the school appeared.
It is self-evident that the origin of all that is laxity in the theory of adhering to the hadiths of the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them), and the way of the righteous predecessors. We may see due to acting upon some hadiths and abandoning others, or changing the authority of the righteous predecessors from one to another that the image of a single matter may change to a great extent. This is assuming that individuals like Ibn Taymiyya or Muhammed ibn Abd al-Wahhab did not come after seven or twelve centuries, raising new matters they claim to be the doctrine of the Salaf, and attributing them to the righteous predecessors.
In any case, the common people in the first and second centuries were followers of the ruling school, which represented nothing but what the Umayyads and some Companions and Successors promoted of doctrines, and perhaps contradiction occurred in their matters at times, but the dominance of the Umayyads and their authority over society made many scholars and hadith scholars submit to their service, and promote their ideas and doctrines.
[Page – 302]
All other people in the Umayyad era were “Uthmaniyya”. This school whose orientation came from Aisha, Talha, and al-Zubayr, and it is the school of Basra in general on the one hand, and the Umayyads on the other. Both groups are united by their enmity toward the Imam Amir al-Mu’minin (peace be upon him). It is natural that this discussion is related to political-doctrinal research. As for purely doctrinal research, it can also include tendencies especially in Medina, Syria, Basra, and Kufa that differ from one another, and revolve in the orbit of the doctrines of specific individuals as we indicated earlier, and the state may sometimes intervene in them, but there is an important intervention of the state that only occurs if political interest requires it. An example of this is that some Umayyad caliphs were accused of following the Qadariyya or the Mu’tazila, and perhaps some went further than that. For example, Hisham (2) killed some heads of schools such as Ghaylan al-Dimashqi or Bayan ibn Sam’an.
In the Abbasid era, we find that intervention in doctrinal and jurisprudential matters came on a much wider scale, and the most prominent intervention in this field is what al-Ma’mun undertook as a supporter of the Mu’tazili school, his resort to force and coercion, and his endeavor to impose his doctrines on scholars in general and hadith scholars in particular.
The common people in this era were still following currents that were, from a doctrinal perspective, an extension of the Uthmani school, and they followed well-known individuals in the cities regarding jurisprudential matters. In reality, apart from the Shi’a and the Khawarij who set boundaries for themselves between them and others, the common people did not have clear sectarian tendencies.
Gradually the discussion of the Murji’a emerged, which did not go beyond the discussion of the definition of faith, as well as the Mu’tazila in the late Umayyad era and part of the Abbasid era, where they to some extent set a definition for their sectarian thought. As for the common people or what is called Muslims in general, they were called “Uthmaniyya” according to their doctrinal and political beliefs, and they did not have clear doctrinal and jurisprudential boundaries. As for the term “Uthmani,” from a historical perspective it was placed in contrast to the term “Shi’i,” and its history goes back to the incident of Siffin.
(2) He is Hisham ibn Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan (71–125 AH), who assumed rule in the year (105 AH / 724 CE). (The Journal).
[Page – 303]
In the early third century, the school of the common people was what was called the Uthmaniyya, and the most important evidence of this is the book al-Uthmaniyya by al-Jahiz, in which he defended the doctrines of the common people against their opponents, especially the Shi’a. In this book there is not abundant mention of Uthman; rather, most of it was a defense of the historical and political views of the Uthmaniyya, which in turn formed an important part of Sunni beliefs later on. Al-Jahiz, of course, did not believe or hold to everything he wrote or composed in books and treatises.He was a person of wavering doctrinal position, and what he mostly sought through his writings was merely to establish the reality of the existence of these doctrinal currents. As for his own school, he was known as a Mu’tazili of Uthmani persuasion.
Most of the discussions in the article “al-Uthmaniyya” came mostly in mentioning the virtues of Abu Bakr, establishing his superiority over the rest of the Companions, and responding to some criticisms directed at him. Al-Jahiz in this book expanded on the discussion of the issue of preferring Abu Bakr over Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and considered him braver and more ascetic than Imam Ali (peace be upon him). There are important chapters in the book responding to the Shi’a’s criticisms of Abu Bakr, and other chapters responding to the Shi’a’s evidences for preferring Imam Ali (peace be upon him) or establishing his imamate.
We find in this treatise that the name of Uthman rarely appears, and even the caliphate of Umar is mentioned only briefly. The treatise came primarily to define the Uthmani school’s view of Abu Bakr and his caliphate and to place it in contrast to the Shi’i view.
Of course, al-Jahiz’s view of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) did not match the view of the Uthmaniyya, for he wrote this treatise in the same period when the Uthmaniyya under the banner of Ahmad ibn Hanbal were reforming their former doctrines regarding Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
Al-Jahiz, in reality, drew a line between the Uthmaniyya and the Sufyaniyya. We find him in another treatise of his titled “Risalat al-Hakamayn wa-Taswib Ali ibn Abi Talib fi Fi’lihi” (The Epistle of the Two Arbitrators and the Vindication of Ali ibn Abi Talib’s Actions)rejecting the views of the Sufyaniyya regarding Mu’awiya, and it appears from the end of this treatise that al-Jahiz was displeased with Mu’awiya. And in the treatise “Fadl Hashim ala Abd Shams” (The Superiority of Banu Hashim over Banu Abd Shams) we also find him rejecting the preference of the Umayyads over the Hashimites (3).
Political Undertones: The Banu Hashim produced the Prophet Muhammed (O Allah, bless Muhammed and the family of Muhammed) and later the Abbasid Caliphate, while the Banu Abd Shams gave rise to the Umayyad dynasty through their prominent branch, the Umayyads (descendants of Umayya ibn Abd Shams).
Al-Jahiz’s Objective: Writing during the Abbasid era, al-Jahiz utilized this treatise to argue for the inherent virtues and superiority of the Prophet’s clan (Banu Hashim) over their historical rivals, aligning closely with Abbasid political legitimacy
[Page – 304]
Perhaps the Sufyani sect is itself the Nabitah, which includes a type of fanatical Uthmanis, and the Shi’a refer to it by the name al-Nasiba or the Nasibi school.
Al-Jahiz in the treatise “al-Nabitah,” (The Epistle on the Contemptible/Upstarts)after mentioning the events that occurred from the time of the Prophet’s death (may Allah be pleased with both of them) until the time of Yazid, and his emphasis on Yazid’s deserving of cursing, proceeded to explain the doctrines of the Nabitah in his time. He says: These people say that cursing the rulers is sedition, and that cursing the oppressor is a innovation even if they committed injustice. Al-Jahiz also considers the disbelief of the Nabitah more egregious than the disbelief of Yazid, and declares that the Nabitah are among the anthropomorphists who liken Allah to humans and this is the doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith in the second and third Hijri centuries.
The term al-Nabita (or al-Nawabit) literally means “the upstarts,” “the weeds,” or “the newly sprouted”. Al-Jahiz used this derogatory label to describe the early traditionalists (factions that would eventually form the backbone of the Hanbali school of law.
We also see him as a Mu’tazili by tendency launching a harsh attack on the doctrine of the Nabitah regarding predestination and anthropomorphism, and the issue of the eternity of the Qur’an, and declaring that they are followers of Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and he holds that the latter did not take the doctrine of the eternity of the Qur’an from the Salaf, but rather it is from the products of his own mind (4).
This treatise highlights the extent of the beliefs that Ahl al-Hadith possessed during this period from a historical and doctrinal perspective.
Compilation of Refutations and Authorship of Doctrinal Works
At the beginning of the third century, the leaders of the schools in Baghdad who were mostly from Ahl al-Hadith sought to set down and compile treatises in the field of doctrines to define the differences among them, and to distinguish the sound from the corrupt.
The compilation of this type of treatise led to a kind of self-delineation of the sects. If we take into consideration the issues of declaring others disbelievers and sinners which were on a wide scale then the followers of any sect could form an independent community with its own doctrines, ethics, and teachings. This matter led in many cities to the division of the neighborhoods of a single city among different sects, and this had parallels in the past as well.
(3) You will find these three treatises in “Rasa’il al-Jahiz, al-Rasa’il al-Siyasiyya,” edited by Ali Abu Mulhim. (4) Rasa’il al-Jahiz, al-Rasa’il al-Kalamiyya, pp. 239–247.
[Page – 305]
It is necessary here to give more clarification about Ahl al-Hadith, which is the dominant doctrinal current in Baghdad at the time.
The local authority in the second century was fundamentally formed of two different trends: the first, the Ahl al-Hadith, most of whom were from Medina; the second, the Ahl al-Ra’y, who were originally Iraqis and then gained followers in some cities of Iran as well.
It appears that the term commonly used in contrast to “Ahl al-Hadith” is “Ahl al-Kalam” (5) or “Ahl al-Ra’y.” It can be said that almost all the schools opposed to Ahl al-Hadith arose in Iraq and Iran, yet the influence of Ahl al-Hadith expanded day after day in Iraq and Iran as well, and they were gradually able to become the official representative of the Sunnis or Sunnism alongside the other sects. This is despite the fact that we may find huge numbers of people who did not affiliate with the Mu’tazila, the Murji’a, or the Ahl al-Ra’y, yet they did not accept the doctrines of Ahl al-Hadith, and these did not have a special sect either, but were a distinct group of Sunnis.
It is worth noting that the word “Sunni” began to be used in this period meaning the middle of the second century then its use became widespread later in the third and fourth centuries. Before that, the application of the term “Uthmani” to persons who believed in the caliphate of the first three caliphs was what was common at the time.
It can be said that Ahl al-Hadith appeared at first as a single sect with its own beliefs, then in the second century they became a group of sects that differed among themselves slightly, and they were later called the Sunni school.
The individuals who created this current are a group of hadith scholars who lived mostly in Baghdad in the middle of the second and third Hijri centuries. The most important of these figures are: Abdullah ibn Mubarak (d. 181 AH), Nu’aym ibn Hammad al-Marwazi (d. 228 AH), Ishaq ibn Rahwayh (d. 238 AH), Uthman ibn Sa’id al-Darimi (d. 280 AH), and the most important of them was Ahmad ibn Hanbal (164–241 AH).
(5) See the book: Abdullah ibn Ahmad, al-Sunna, vol. 1, p. 151, hadith 131.
[Page – 306]
Most of the works of these individuals were in refutation of their opponents. In reality, the struggle with opponents strengthened their sense of the independence of their sects. The most important works they left were in refutation of the Qadariyya, the Jahmiyya, the Murji’a, and the heretics. As an example, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, al-Darimi, and Abdullah ibn Muhammed al-Ju’fi (d. 229 AH) wrote treatises in refutation of the Jahmiyya and by the Jahmiyya they meant the Mu’tazila and the Qadariyya, or in other words, those who deny the narrations of anthropomorphism. They sought to establish transcendence regarding Allah Almighty, and perhaps they were also afflicted with some fanaticism.
The compilation of doctrinal treatises began at a time when work on writing refutations was continuous. In order to clarify the boundaries of correct doctrines, they authored their doctrinal treatises, and often the titles of these treatises included the word “al-Sunna,” from which “Ahl al-Sunna” was gradually derived.
The term “al-Sunna” is exactly equivalent to “al-Bid’a” (innovation), and in their view all other sects are people of innovation. We note here a number of those who compiled these works, namely: Abdullah ibn Hanbal (d. 290 AH), Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Amr al-Shaybani (d. 277 AH), Abu Ali Hanbal ibn Ishaq (d. 273 AH), Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Muhammed al-Ashram (d. 273 AH), Abu Bakr ibn Abi Shayba (d. 225 AH), Ibn Abi Asim (d. 287 AH), and Abu Mansur al-Isfahani (6). Ibn al-Nadim also attributed books to Muhammed ibn Umayr al-Waqidi, among them: al-Sunna wa al-Jama’a, Dhamm al-Hawa, and Tark al-Khuruj(7).
(6) His book Risalat al-Sunna is printed in Majallat al-Ma’arif, first issue of 1969. (7) Al-Fihrist, p. 111.
[Page – 307]
Here are the specifications of some of these works: 1. Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 290 AH), and his book: al-Sunna, two volumes, edited by: Muhammed ibn Sa’id ibn Salim al-Qahtani, Dammam, 1994. 2. Al-Barbahari, Abu Muhammed Hasan ibn Ali ibn Khalaf (d. 329 AH), and his book: Sharh al-Sunna, edited by: Abu Yasir Khalid ibn Qasim, Medina, Maktabat al-Ghuraba’ al-Athariyya, 1993. 3. Al-Khallal, Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Harun (d. 311 AH), and his book: al-Sunna, five volumes, edited by: Atiyya al-Zahrani, Riyadh, Dar al-Raya, 1994. 4. Ibn Abi Asim, Abu Bakr Amr ibn Abi Asim al-Dahhak al-Shaybani (d. 287 AH), and his book: al-Sunna, two volumes, edited by: Muhammed Nasir al-Din al-Albani, Beirut, al-Maktab al-Islami, 1993. 5. Al-Lalika’i, Abu al-Qasim Hibat Allah ibn al-Hasan ibn Mansur al-Tabari (d. 418 AH), and his book: Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna wa al-Jama’a, nine volumes, edited by: Ahmad ibn Sa’d ibn Hamdan al-Ghamidi, Riyadh, Dar Tayba, 1994. 6. Ibn Batta, Abu Abdullah Ubayd Allah ibn Muhammed ibn Batta al-Akbari (d. 387 AH), and his book: al-Ibana an Shari’at al-Firqa al-Najiya wa Mujanabat al-Firaq al-Madhmuma, two volumes, edited by Rida Na’san Mu’ti, Riyadh, Dar al-Raya, 1994. 7. Al-Tabari, Muhammed ibn Jarir (d. 310 AH), and his book: Sarih al-Sunna, edited by Badr ibn Yusuf al-Ma’tuq, Kuwait, Dar al-Khulafa’ lil-Kitab al-Islami. Al-Dhahabi mentioned many examples of doctrinal sayings and views on disputed matters in his book Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’ during his exposition of the conditions of the Hanbali scholars and Ahl al-Hadith in Baghdad and other cities.
Jamal al-Din ibn Ahmad ibn Bishr Badi recently collected most of these sayings and expressions in the book: al-Athar al-Warida an A’immat al-Sunna fi Abwab al-I’tiqad (two volumes, Riyadh, Dar al-Watan, 1416 AH).
Aspects of Doctrinal Divergence
We have indicated that the divergence of opinions was prominent in three aspects:
The first: in the doctrinal aspect, which includes important discussions in the science of kalam, such as the discussion of Allah’s attributes and the issue of faith and disbelief. In this field, emphasis was placed on specific hadiths, the most important of which are: the hadith of the vision of Allah, and the hadith of the Prophet sitting beside Allah on His throne. In the field of faith and disbelief, the dispute was fundamentally with Abu Hanifa. Many sayings were reported from the Salaf refuting his sayings, especially regarding the issue of increase and decrease in faith, where evidences from hadiths and traditions were presented.
[Page – 308]
The second: in the jurisprudential aspect; it is natural that there are many minor differences here, but only some of them became a distinguishing feature of certain sects from others. No particular matter was relied upon in the doctrinal treatises available in this field.
The third: in the historical aspect, which is the specific belief of the sects regarding the caliphs, Companions, and Successors. In this area, belief in a number of the early caliphs is considered a doctrinal principle from a practical perspective. Regarding the Companions, the issue of believing in their all being upright and trustworthy is considered a fixed doctrinal principle. Regarding the Successors as well, we find that the issue of ignoring some prominent historical figures was tantamount to a fixed doctrine for some sects, as in the case of denying Abu Hanifa and declaring him a disbeliever. It was tantamount to the official doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith in the third century, which had a special treatment in books.
The Correct Doctrine Regarding the Caliphs according to Ahl al-Hadith
Disagreement regarding the caliphs occurred in the first stage between the Shi’a and the common Muslims. The Shi’a contrary to the common Muslims rejected the caliphate of the early caliphs. Although the Mu’tazila also had criticisms of the caliphs, what is at issue here is not merely the question of recognizing the caliphs, but rather something akin to infallibility was made for them, and tolerating no criticism of them. Thus impugning and directing criticism at the caliphs is considered evidence of Rafidi tendency.
The discussion revolved around the caliphs from different angles including how the caliph is chosen, his pledge of allegiance, obedience to him, and the conditions of the caliphate. Apart from these demands that may pertain to every caliph, there is a specific belief regarding the caliphs of the first era, whom the Sunnis call the “Rightly Guided.” A Muslim, if he is Sunni, must acknowledge the caliphate of these three or four persons, otherwise he is among the people of innovation and outside Sunnism. According to this view, it is not possible for a Sunni to believe in the Qur’an and hadith only and this expression also applies to the Shi’a with respect to the Imams.
[Page – 309]
The issue of the number of caliphs was also among the matters of disagreement among Muslims. The common Muslims apart from the Imami Shi’a and some Zaydis believe in the first and second caliphs, but some Sunnis in the first Hijri century and even the second reject Uthman, although these individuals were accused of Shi’ism when their conditions were explained. However, from a foundational perspective they are completely separate from the Shi’a regarding jurisprudence and doctrines.
Many of the people of Iraq especially the people of Kufa and Wasit rejected Uthman and sided with Ali instead, and they may consider Ali superior even to the first and second caliphs. In contrast, we find Ahl al-Hadith and the Uthmani school exaggerated in their belief in Uthman, and did not allow separation between him and the two caliphs. Based on this belief, a Muslim regarding the issue of the caliphate must believe in the three caliphs: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman, and their order in terms of superiority is exactly their historical order: the first is superior to the second, the second superior to the third, and these are the best of the Companions. This trend from a doctrinal perspective accepts only these three, and there is no place for the fourth caliph.
A look at the book al-Sunna by Abu Bakr al-Khallal (d. 311 AH) shows the scope of the doctrinal principles of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the number of caliphs and the theories stated about them.
This book more than other books of al-Sunna clarified the doctrine of the Sunnis regarding what we should know or believe about the caliphs. The discussion on this topic extended to page five hundred of this book or slightly more, after which the discussion turned to the issue of predestination and free will, faith and disbelief. For this reason, this work can be considered a political work more than a doctrinal and theological one in the technical sense, as it contains the primary material for many issues related to religious politics from a jurisprudential angle. In reality, this book presented the historical view of Sunni Muslims on the issue of the caliphate.
The author in each part of the book proceeded to transmit hadiths from the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them), and various sayings from the senior Companions, Successors, and the Salaf that define the dimensions of correct belief. The following is a section of the book’s chapters: obedience to the Imam and abstaining from revolting against him, the Imams from Quraysh, his emirates and discussions, rulings on those who rebel against the Imam, general discussions of the caliphate, the caliphate of Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali, the discussion of preferring the caliphs over one another, mention of the Rafidis, mention of the trials from the Banu Umayya and others.
[Page – 310]
What we are concerned with is not political discussions in general, but rather the belief of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the early caliphs, and especially their view of the status of Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon him).
The Doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith Regarding the Caliphs
The best of the caliphs and Companions after the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them), from the perspective of Ahl al-Hadith, are: Abu Bakr and Umar. This belief came according to their political perspective, as they assumed the caliphate in an era when Muslims were united, enjoying unity and stability or in other words, they did not face a state of disagreement and division. As for the third caliph, his caliphate was in the view of Ahl al-Hadith by consensus of the Ummah, and there is no doubt or hesitation on this matter (8). Disagreement appeared in the second half of his caliphate gradually, ultimately leading to the revolt against him and his murder. Nevertheless, the political view of Ahl al-Hadith toward this revolt was entirely negative. It was in their view a type of rare rebellion and disobedience, to which the title of rebellion against the Imam may apply.
Ahl al-Hadith’s analysis of these conditions is precisely a defense of the legitimacy of Uthman’s caliphate, as they expressed what happened after it: “Disagreement and innovations came, and people became parties and became sects” (9), and after that only a few remained firm upon the truth. According to the perspective of Ahl al-Hadith, the term “al-Jama’a” appeared in the time of Mu’awiya and after him; it means stability upon the truth, i.e., the Umayyad state. Based on this, the era of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) was an era of disagreement and division. Ahl al-Hadith’s analysis of the revolt of Talha, al-Zubayr, and Aisha against Imam Ali (peace be upon him) which was also a defense of Uthman was not an easy matter. We find Ahl al-Hadith, throughout their history of enmity toward Imam Ali (peace be upon him), at most arguing that the blood of Talha and al-Zubayr was shed in vain in the case of acknowledging the legitimacy of the Imam’s caliphate. The Uthmani view cannot be satisfied with this matter at all, and for this reason we find them committed to silence regarding Imam Ali’s (peace be upon him) war with this group (10).
(8) Al-Barbahari indicated, saying: “The Jama’a is what the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace) agreed upon during the caliphate of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman” (Sharh al-Sunna, edited by: Abu Yasir Khalid ibn Qasim, Medina, Maktabat al-Ghuraba’ al-Athariyya, 1993, p. 105). The name of Uthman appears in some copies and not in others. He said in another place: “Know that the original religion is what was from the death of the Messenger of Allah to the murder of Uthman, and his murder was the first division and the first disagreement” (Sharh al-Sunna, p. 107). (9)Sharh al-Sunna, by al-Barbahari, p. 97. [Page – 311]
Imam Ali (peace be upon him) was martyred in the year forty Hijri, the Shi’a lost, and the Umayyads ruled after that for ninety years, during which they made the Uthmani school the dominant school in the world of Islam. This school that never gave Imam Ali (peace be upon him) any status, but rather tried with difficulty to establish Uthman, as they completely ignored the revolt of the people of Medina against Uthman and his murder, or the rejection of Uthman by the people of Iraq in the time of Imam Ali’s government, and rather considered such matters as innovation in contrast to the Sunna.
In such circumstances the belief of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the caliphs arose, and its basis was the Uthmani view. Since the rebellion of Mu’awiya against Imam Ali (peace be upon him) and after, it became a fixed doctrine to the extent that the Abbasids could not change it significantly perhaps because they felt that changing this doctrine was not in their interest, especially after their clash with the Alids in the time of al-Mansur and after Al-Ma’mun insisted on rejecting Uthman not openly, of course and establishing the position of Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and he only took this stance during his severity toward Ahl al-Hadith, and it led to creating a wave of opposition against him. The Uthmani doctrine returned to its previous state immediately after al-Mu’tasim (d. 227 AH) and the dominance of Ahl al-Hadith.
It was clear that the Uthmanis or the new Sunnis were not the only group living in Baghdad or Iraq or other cities of Iran, Syria, and Egypt; alongside them were the Mu’tazila, the Murji’a or the followers of Abu Hanifa, and also the Shi’a, who in turn formed a large community.
The cornerstone of the emergence of Sunni doctrines is the current of Ahl al-Hadith, which at the beginning of the third decade of the third century and after turned quietly toward reform in order to be able to stand easily before the opponents. Among the most important chapters of this reform is the acceptance of Imam Ali as the fourth caliph, and this means changing the doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the caliphate and the person against whom they had monitored enmity yesterday to the extent that it can be said that the Uthmani doctrine arose in opposition to him has today become a caliph in the doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith, just as in our current era, where we see the Khawarij in Oman and northern Algeria venerating Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and rejecting what they used to believe in the past, which was fundamentally based on enmity toward Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
Prima Qur’an comments: The statement: “just as in our current era, where we see the Khawarij in Oman and northern Algeria venerating Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and rejecting what they used to believe in the past, which was fundamentally based on enmity toward Imam Ali (peace be upon him).” This is due to the ignorance of Shaykh Rasul Jafarian. An ignorance that we would be happy to clarify for him if given the opportunity.
(10) The previous source, p. 111. [Page – 312]
“Al-Sunna” by Abu Bakr al-Khallal and the Correct Doctrine on the Caliphate
The demands that al-Khallal mentioned in the chapters related to the caliphate were long and short texts transmitted by a number of individuals as narrations from the Noble Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them), or sayings issued by the Companions and Successors, each of which raised a particular issue. Most of the narrations in this chapter are undoubtedly of later fabrication. We mention here in order excerpts from these reports, each of which represents an angle of the correct doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the caliphate of the early caliphs.
The first report: the narration of Thursday i.e., the report of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) requesting that a shoulder blade and inkwell be brought to him, and their refusal of the request and their accusation of the Prophet of delirium. This narration is authentic without doubt according to what the verifier stated in the footnote (p. 271) (11).
In another report: Aisha’s denial of the matter of the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) designating a successor, as she says: If he were to appoint anyone as successor, he would have appointed Abu Bakr or Umar (p. 272).
In another report: It came from Imam Ali (peace be upon him) his saying: We found the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) preferring Abu Bakr in prayer, so we preferred Abu Bakr (p. 274). This report is clearly false and fabricated, and Imam Ali’s (peace be upon him) positions at the beginning of Abu Bakr’s caliphate are the best evidence of its falsity.
In another report: It came from Ibn Abi Hazim that he used to say: I saw Umar in the last days of Abu Bakr’s caliphate with a staff in his hand, seating the people and saying: “Listen to the words of the Caliph of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them).” And this was Abu Bakr’s testament to Umar of the caliphate after him (p. 277).
After that he spoke about Umar’s consultation and texts about the virtues of Abu Ubayda ibn al-Jarrah, where Umar said: “Whom shall I appoint as successor? If Abu Ubayda ibn al-Jarrah were…” (p. 279). He also spoke about Ka’b al-Ahbar who spread the news that Mu’awiya would assume the caliphate (p. 281). We may find this matter mentioned by its title in the old books.
(11) The page numbers in parentheses all refer to the book al-Sunna by al-Khallal.
[Page – 313]
Many expressions were transmitted on the tongue of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) in praise of the first and second caliphs, to remove any trace of disagreement among them. His saying was transmitted: “The best of this Ummah is Abu Bakr, then Umar” (p. 289, 293), and this means nothing but the doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith.
Muharib ibn Dithar said: Hatred of Abu Bakr and Umar is hypocrisy (p. 290). This saying is the content of the Prophet’s (may Allah be pleased with both of them) narration regarding Imam Ali (peace be upon him), which is mutawatir, and it came here inverted. Likewise Muhammed ibn al-Hanafiyya said: The best of the Ummah is Abu Bakr and Umar, and when he was asked about his father, he said: “A man from among the Muslims” (p. 291).
He also cited a detailed narration from Abdullah ibn Umar about the death of his father and who would assume the caliphate after him (pp. 294–297).
At the beginning of the second volume of the book, reports about the caliphate of Abu Bakr were also presented. In the first expression, he considered Abu Bakr’s appointment to lead the prayer during the Prophet’s lifetime (may Allah be pleased with both of them) as tantamount to his appointment to the caliphate (pp. 301–302). Several sayings came in this regard on the tongue of his supporters, all of whom are in a position of accusation. Sometimes in order to establish the authenticity of these sayings they bring texts on the tongue of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) who certainly did not pledge allegiance to Abu Bakr until the death of Lady Fatima (peace be upon her) containing praise of Abu Bakr and Umar and placing them at the rank of the infallible. These are many, among them: “Abu Bakr and Umar are the best of the people of heaven and the best of the people of earth and the best of the first and the best of the last, except the prophets and messengers” (p. 307).
He added a chapter on the caliphate of Umar in which praise and eulogy of Umar predominated (p. 311 and after). He then cited a chapter on the caliphate of Uthman (p. 319), and here too he transmitted virtues of Uthman and a text confirming that Uthman’s caliphate was completed by consensus of the Ummah (p. 320). He also cited an objection to a person who preferred Ali over Uthman, that there was no pledge more sound or more trustworthy than the pledge to Uthman (p. 321). Why? Because it was by the consultation of six of the people of Badr (p. 322).
[Page – 314]
Regarding the rebels’ request that he abdicate, they brought a text that the caliphate is a garment of Allah that He clothed him with, and it is not permissible for him to remove it (p. 321, 329). Of course due to the doubts of the Shi’a of Kufa regarding Uthman’s caliphate Ahl al-Hadith sought to narrate more virtues of Uthman. Most importantly, in order to deny the people’s revolt against him, they tried to create justifications for it, among them: that the murder of Uthman is the first “fitna,” and that the last fitna is the fitna of the False Messiah (p. 335).
Up to here, the doctrine of the Sunnis regarding the validity of the caliphate was a settled matter, and it was described in some reports of this book with the phrase “the caliphate of prophethood” (p. 284, 334) (12).
Ahl al-Hadith and the Order of Preferring the Caliphs
It has passed before us that the caliphate of the Imam (peace be upon him) was not officially recognized in the Uthmani school, who are the Salaf of Ahl al-Hadith. The background of this goes back to the role of the Umayyads in the emergence and appearance of the Uthmani school, which was widespread in Basra and Syria, while it was fought against in Kufa. As for the people of Medina, they were neutral toward it. In other countries such as the cities of Iran, we also find according to the principle of “the right belongs to the one who prevails” the spread of this doctrine throughout the Umayyad era.
There are many evidences confirming that Ahl al-Hadith regarding the core of their doctrine on the caliphate used to say that it suffices to believe in the validity of the caliphate of the first three caliphs. Meanwhile, we see the Shi’a of Kufa, most of whom were not Imami or Zaydi Shi’a, but rather from the perspective of Ahl al-Hadith of Uthmani persuasion were Shi’a because they preferred Imam Ali (peace be upon him) over Uthman. At the same time, we find them in the second century acknowledging the four caliphs and ranking Ali above Uthman.
As for the Ahl al-Hadith in Basra, they reformed their matter somewhat in the late second century, acknowledging the four caliphs. As for the people of Baghdad, in the peak of their fanaticism, they were satisfied with only the three caliphs.
(12) See also: al-Sunna, by Ibn Abi Asim, p. 522.
[Page – 315]
This division came in the book Masā’il al-Imāmah, (The Matters of the Imamate) which was compiled in the third century, as follows: The Ahl al-Hadith in Kufa, such as Waki’ ibn al-Jarrah and Fadl ibn Dukayn, held this view: “The best of people after the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) is Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Ali, then Uthman. They prefer Ali over Uthman.This is the Shi’ism of the Ahl al-Hadith of the Kufans, and they affirm the imamate of Ali.” In contrast to this view was the doctrine of the Ahl al-Hadith of Basra, which is: “The best of the Ummah after the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) is Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, then Ali, then they equate the rest of the consultative committee.” This is while the elders of Ahl al-Hadith in Baghdad fundamentally deny the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him): “As for the elders of the Ahl al-Hadith of the Baghdadis, they do not affirm the imamate of Ali, among them: Ibn Ma’in, Abu Khaythama, and Ahmad ibn Hanbal. They used to omit Ali from the imamate and claim that his governance was a fitna!” (13).
Masā’il al-Imāmah (The Matters of the Imamate) is a seminal early Islamic theological and heresiographical text attributed to al-Nāshi’ al-Akbar (d. 293 AH / 906 CE), which was famously discovered, edited, and published by the renowned German Islamic scholar Josef van Ess.
It is highly prized book by historians because it captures the fluid ideological landscape of the 2nd and 3rd centuries of the Hijra. Particularly the evolving positions on political legitimacy, the status of the early Caliphs, and the foundational theological divides between the Mu’tazilites, and Shi’ites (such as the Zaydis).
In the book al-Sunna by al-Khallal there is a heading on this topic: “The Sunna on Preference”—i.e., what is the correct belief regarding preferring the caliphs over one another. We have here many evidences indicating that the early Ahl al-Hadith who are the Salaf of the Sunni current in the world of Islam until the early second century and sometimes its middle, used to deny the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
Al-Khallal cited in this chapter many transmitted reports lacking logical order, but they nevertheless represent the doctrinal vision of Ahl al-Hadith on the issue of preference among the caliphs.
In the first report: Salih ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal asked his father about one who does not prefer Abu Bakr and Umar over others. He said: The Sunna with us regarding preference is what Ibn Umar said: We used to count, while the Messenger of Allah(may Allah be pleased with both of them) was alive: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and we would remain silent (p. 371).
It appears from another report that the doctrine of the Kufans was contrary to that, because they believed in Imam Ali (peace be upon him). As for the people of Medina, they did not prefer anyone over another (p. 371).
In the chapter on preference, there are persons who express their view only about Abu Bakr and Umar and then remain silent. Ahmad ibn Hanbal saw that this was not part of the complete doctrine of the Sunna i.e., that one must add the names of the others (p. 372). Ahmad believed that if someone stops after these two, he is not among the people of the Sunna (p. 373).
(13) Masa’il al-Imama, pp. 65–66. We will see Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s attempt to reform this position later. [Page – 316]
Yahya ibn Sa’id al-Qattan, who was among the prominent Successors and followers of Sufyan al-Thawri, used to stop after the name of Umar, and it was argued against him that the doctrine of the people of Basra was not like that (p. 372 and 373) (14).
We also find Sufyan ibn Uyayna in his beliefs mentioning only Abu Bakr and Umar(15).
Al-Shafi’i, who was accused of Shi’ism, held the view in the second century when Ahl al-Hadith still rejected Imam Ali (peace be upon him) that the order of the caliphate was from Abu Bakr to Ali (peace be upon him) (16). There are many common Muslims who did not join the Ahl al-Hadith sect, but we find them from the first and second centuries placing Ali among the other three.
The doctrine of the Kufans was the major obstacle in the path of the intellectual tendency of Ahl al-Hadith, as the Kufans not only were satisfied with Ali, but preferred him over Uthman as well. The Imami Twelver Shi’a among them preferred him even over Abu Bakr (17). This prompted Abu Bakr al-Khallal to add another heading: “The Denunciation of One Who Prefers Ali over Abu Bakr and Those After Him” (18).
The first report was from Ibn Hanbal, where he says: “Whoever prefers Ali over Abu Bakr has impugned the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them). Whoever prefers him over Umar has impugned the Messenger of Allah(may Allah be pleased with both of them) and Abu Bakr. Whoever prefers him over Uthman has impugned Abu Bakr and Umar and the people of the consultation and the Muhajirun and the Ansar” (p. 374).
Sufyan al-Thawri said: “Whoever prefers Ali over Abu Bakr and Umar has disparaged twelve thousand of the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them)” (p. 375).
Perhaps, to confront this conception which is abundantly mentioned in the hadith books of Ahl al-Hadith they brought this report from Imam Ali (peace be upon him) and claimed his saying: “Abu Bakr and Umar are the best of people” (19).
(14) It came in another report: “Sufyan used to prefer Ali over Uthman” (Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’, vol. 7, p. 273). It was mentioned in another report that Sufyan said to Shu’ayb ibn Harb that one must prefer Uthman. (15)Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 1, p. 175. (16) The previous source, vol. 8, p. 1450. On p. 1451 this was also attributed to Malik. Unfortunately, doubt and hesitation occurred in most of these attributions, because shortly before it, on p. 1450, he transmitted from Malik his saying on the issue of preference: one must prefer only Abu Bakr and Umar, and he remained silent about Ali and Uthman. (17) The Shi’a of Kufa in general are not considered Imami or Zaydi Shi’a. The reason for their existence was the presence of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) in Kufa and his dispute with the Uthmaniyya. They fundamentally reject Uthman and do not acknowledge the well-known theory of Ahl al-Hadith regarding the uprightness of all the Companions. Among them we note here Abu Ishaq al-Sabi’i and al-A’mash. It was said that Salam ibn Abi Muti’ took the hadith book of Abu Awana, which was about the Companions, and burned the hadiths of al-A’mash, and said to Abu Awana: Show us the innovations you brought from Kufa. Then he put it in the oven. Khalid ibn Khidash said: I asked what hadiths were in this book. He said: One of them was the hadith of Ali (peace be upon him): “I am the divider of heaven and hell” (al-Sunna by al-Khallal, pp. 509–510).
Al-Dhahabi also wrote: “Most of the Syrians among them had hesitation about Amir al-Mu’minin Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) from the day of Siffin just as the Kufans except whom your Lord wills had deviation from Uthman and loyalty to Ali, and their Salaf were his Shi’a and supporters. Then a group of the Shi’a of Iraq love Ali and Uthman, but prefer Ali over Uthman, and do not love those who fought Ali, while seeking forgiveness for them. This is a light Shi’ism” (Mizan al-I’tidal, vol. 3, p. 552).
(18) Al-Lalika’i transmitted several reports regarding this topic in which many senior Ahl al-Hadith directed whatever insults they could at everyone who preferred Ali over Uthman. See (Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 8, p. 1452). (19) al-Sunna by Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal, vol. 2, pp. 574–589. [Page – 317]
Ahmad ibn Hanbal said: “Whoever claims that Ali is superior to Abu Bakr is a bad man; we do not associate with him nor sit with him” (p. 377).
Maymun ibn Mihran also became angry at a person who preferred Ali over the two Shaykhs, and said: “The two Shaykhs are the head of Islam and the head of the Jama’a” (p. 379).
The title of the next chapter in al-Khallal’s book was “The Denunciation of One Who Prefers Ali over Uthman,” and Ibn Hanbal described the holder of this belief as also a bad man (p. 378). Ahmad ibn Hanbal was asked about one who prefers Ali over Uthman: “Is he in your view an innovator?” He said: “This one deserves to be deemed an innovator. The Companions of the Messenger of Allah(may Allah be pleased with both of them) preferred Uthman” (p. 380).
Then al-Khallal transmitted the evidences for preferring Uthman over Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and in this field he cited expressions from Ibn Mas’ud and Abdullah ibn Umar. As for the report transmitted from Abdullah ibn Umar, it is undoubtedly pure fabrication, and they relied on it heavily. It is: “We were in the time of the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) not equating anyone with Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, then we would leave off and not prefer among them” (p. 384, 396, 398, 399) (20).
Yazid ibn Harun used to say: “It makes no difference to us whether we prefer Ali over Uthman or the reverse.” Ibn Hanbal said on this matter: “I do not know whether Yazid ibn Harun held this doctrine or not. As for ‘the common people of Wasit, they practice Shi’ism'” (p. 394) i.e., they preferred Ali over Uthman. In another report it came from Ahmad: “The people of Kufa all prefer Ali over Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him, and over all the Companions” (p. 395). He also said: “If I were to find a Sunni among the people of Kufa, he would certainly be known: ‘he surpassed the people’” (p. 395) because the people of Kufa all prefer Ali over Uthman and even over the rest of the Companions. So if there was a dissenter, he would be known. In another report the phrase “a Kufan Sunni” came instead of “a Kufan rational and religious,” and that “he surpassed the people,” and in his view he is among the people of the Qur’an (p. 396). Accordingly, in the view of Ahmad ibn Hanbal, the real Sunni is one who does not prefer Ali in any case over the caliphs and even over Uthman.
The basis of Sunnism was the denial of the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him), and Abu Bakr al-Khallal placed a chapter under this heading and brought many reports. He transmitted from Ibn Umar his saying: “We used to count while the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) was alive, saying: Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, then we would remain silent” (p. 396). This hadith is considered authentic by Ahl al-Hadith, and it is in their view the basis of the correct belief of the Sunni, and they always cite it. Ahmad ibn Hanbal himself says: “We say: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and we remain silent, following the hadith of Ibn Umar” (p. 397).
(20)Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 8, p. 1446. [Page – 318]
Ahmad ibn Hanbal contrary to the rest of Ahl al-Hadith used to add the name of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) to the names of the first three caliphs, although he declared that one who acknowledges the three caliphs has no blemish in his Sunnism. When they asked him about preference, he said: “The Sunna is that Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali are among the caliphs, and that we prefer them over others.”
In another report, a questioner asked him: Is the belief in this order Abu Bakr, Umar, Ali, and Uthman correct or not? He said: “I am not pleased with this.” The questioner said: They say whoever believes thus is an innovator. Ahmad said: “This innovation is nothing.” The questioner said: If they say: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Ali, and remain silent. Ahmad said: “I am not pleased with this saying.” The questioner said: Is one who believes that an innovator? Ahmad said: “I am not pleased with this attribution either.” Ahmad added: Some of the Companions used to prefer Uthman. Ibn Mas’ud used to say about Uthman: “The best of those remaining.” He said it when the news of Uthman’s pledge reached Kufa (p. 391). Aisha also used to say: “Uthman has become better than Ali” (p. 378 and 379), with our knowledge of what was attributed to these two of sayings disparaging Uthman, although Aisha after Uthman’s murder expressed regret for what she said.
This report establishes that Ahmad was not very strict regarding the order after the two Shaykhs. It is worth noting that there are reports contrary to that, which we will indicate later. At the same time we will see that Ahmad was exerting his effort to add the name of Ali to the list of caliphs, and the real Sunni in his view is one who believes in the preference of these four according to their order. The strange thing about Ahmad is that despite this, he also saw no problem in omitting the name of Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
Harun al-Dik said: I heard Ahmad say: “Whoever says: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman is a person of the Sunna, and whoever says: Abu Bakr, Umar, Ali, and Uthman is a Rafidi,” or he said, “an innovator” (p. 381).
[Page – 319]
Ahmad ibn Hanbal before his fame and the spread of his name used to promote the former doctrine of Ahl al-Hadith, which says that belief in the three caliphs suffices. He believed until the end of his life that whoever held this doctrine, it would suffice him, but there is no harm if we also add to them the name of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). For this reason, sayings that appear contradictory may sometimes be transmitted from him. For example, Yahya ibn Ma’in considered belief in those three sufficient, and perhaps he had no doctrinal necessity to add the name of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). It was said to him: Ahmad ibn Hanbal says: “Whoever says: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali I do not reproach him.” Yahya said: “I was alone with Ahmad and asked him: What do you say? He said: ‘I say: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman I do not say: Ali'” (p. 397) (21).
Immediately after that, al-Khallal transmitted from Yahya his saying: “I say Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman” (p. 398, 404). What is strange is what came in another book from Yahya ibn Ma’in: “The best of the Ummah after its Prophet is Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, then Ali. This is our saying and our school.” The narrator confirmed that he heard this saying from him repeatedly (22).
Sulayman ibn Harb used to say: “After the death of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them), the best of people was Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman; and we remain silent after these three” (p. 402). Yazid ibn Zuray’ also used to say: “The best of this Ummah after the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) is Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, then we stop” (p. 403).
Likewise Musa ibn Isma’il al-Tanbudhaki used to say: “This is how we learned” meaning the order of the three caliphs “and our flesh grew upon it and we found the people upon it: preferring Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman, then silence” (p. 403).
Bishr ibn al-Harith used to say about preference: “Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman” (p. 403). Ayyub al-Sakhtiyani said: “I entered Medina while the people were numerous al-Qasim ibn Muhammed and others and I did not see anyone differing regarding the preference of Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman” (p. 403).
Qutayba ibn Sa’id (d. 240 AH) one of the imams of Ahl al-Hadith wrote in his brief doctrinal treatise: “The best of this Ummah after its Prophet is Abu Bakr, then Umar, then Uthman, and refraining from the faults of the Companions of Muhammad…” (23).
Given the date of his death, it can be said that he was not influenced by Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s position, but rather continued on the old path of Ahl al-Hadith.
(21) Nevertheless, it was transmitted from Yahya that he said: “Whoever says Abu Bakr and Umar, there is nothing against him; and whoever says Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman, there is nothing against him either; but the best is to say: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali” (Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 8, p. 1476). (22)Shi’ar Ashab al-Hadith, edited by Subhi al-Samarra’i (Kuwait, Dar al-Khulafa’ lil-Kitab al-Islami, 1404), p. 35. [Page – 320]
Ahmad ibn Hanbal and the Doctrine of Tarbi’
We attempt here to clarify the role of Ahmad ibn Hanbal in the matter of “tarbi'” (making Ali the fourth caliph). It is useful to recall his prominent role in the emergence and formation of the Sunni school. He undertook this role because of his wide influence among Ahl al-Hadith. We find him resisting al-Ma’mun with determination on the issue of the Qur’an, not retreating from his doctrine or acknowledging the createdness of the Qur’an, even with the insistence of the Mu’tazili caliph. For this cause he gained a prominent status after him with al-Mutawakkil.
In the era of al-Mutawakkil, who brought Ahl al-Hadith near, Ahmad ibn Hanbal who was considered their head gained wide authority, although Ahmad ibn Hanbal was known from the fifth and sixth centuries onward as a jurist, and the Hanbali school became attributed to him. But before that, in the third to fifth centuries, he was known as the leader of a school, as the Hanbalis referred to him in various doctrinal matters.
In most of the books of al-Sunna compiled in the third century and after, they referred in most chapters to the words of Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and considered his saying the decisive word on disputed matters. An index was made of his theories found in numerous works, among them the book al-Sunna by his son Abdullah, then they were collected in a book, a section of which was devoted to the caliphate (24).
Al-Khallal emphasized in many places in his book, on his own tongue or the tongue of others, the necessity of following Ahmad in doctrinal matters. It came in a treatise containing a response to one of the scholars of Tirmidh mentioned in this book, and in reality it is a response to him for his denial of the hadith of the Prophet sitting on the throne beside Allah as he ceaselessly repeated this saying many times: “May Allah protect us and you from the misguiding trials, and deliver us and you from the misleading whims by His grace and power, and keep us and you firm upon the Sunna and the Jama’a and following the Shaykh Abu Abdullah—may Allah have mercy on him and be pleased with him” (p. 227).
(23) The previous source, p. 31. (24)al-Masa’il wa al-Rasa’il al-Marwiyya an al-Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal fi al-Aqida, by Abd al-Ilah ibn Salman al-Ahmadi (two parts, Riyadh, Dar Tayba, 1412), vol. 1, p. 368 and after.
[Page – 321]
Here the obligation of following Ahmad ibn Hanbal came directly after the obligation of steadfastness upon the doctrine of the Sunna and the Jama’a. After several pages, he said in the words of Ali ibn Dawud al-Qantari: “Now then, hold fast to the guidance of Abu Abdullah Ahmad ibn Hanbal may Allah be pleased with him—for he is the imam of the pious for those after him” (p. 234).
It also came at the end of this treatise: “I ask Allah to bestow upon us and you adherence to the Sunna, and following the righteous Salaf, Abu Abdullah may Allah be pleased with him for he clarified the innovated matters sufficiently for whoever follows him” (p. 236).
The repetition of such expressions came in other places (p. 243).
At the end of the discussion about the hadith of sitting, which came in connection with the verse {It may be that your Lord will raise you to a praised station}, Abu al-Fadl Abbas al-Duri said: “We say about these hadiths what Ahmad ibn Hanbal said, following him and his works in that” (p. 258).
These affirmations show the extent of Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s influence on the emergence of the doctrines of Ahl al-Hadith. What is noteworthy is that Muhammed ibn Jarir al-Tabari who did not consider Ahmad a jurist cited in several places of his treatise Sarih al-Sunna which is his doctrinal treatise the sayings of Ahmad ibn Hanbal. Sometimes, after transmitting Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s words, he says: “This word suffices us.” At the same time, he denies the hadith of the Prophet’s sitting; and for this he was severely attacked by the fanatical Hanbalis in Baghdad (25).
The important part of this influence is related to reforming the view of Ahl al-Hadith regarding Imam Ali (peace be upon him). Ahl al-Hadith, who are a continuation of the Uthmani current, used to harbor enmity toward Imam Ali (peace be upon him). They did not consider him a caliph, nor did they see any merit distinguishing him from the rest of the Companions. As Ibn Qutayba mentioned, Ahl al-Hadith, because of their hatred of the Rafidis, also denied his most famous virtues such as the hadith of Ghadir and the hadith of Manzila (26).
Ahmad ibn Hanbal shattered this yoke. We find him transmitting in his Musnad or his other works many narrations concerning the virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). He spoke in his book Fada’il al-Sahaba(27) printed in two volumes about the virtues and reports of the Companions, beginning in order with Abu Bakr (pp. 65–243), then speaking about Umar (pp. 244–502), then about Uthman (pp. 503–527), then about the virtues of Amir al-Mu’minin (pp. 528–727), and after that up to p. 990 he also spoke about a number of other Companions.
(25) See: the book: al-Maqalat al-Tarikhiyya, the second notebook, the article: (Ahl al-Hadith and the book Sarih al-Sunna of al-Tabari), p. 239. (26)al-Ikhtilaf fi al-Lafz, pp. 47–49, edited by Muhammed Zahid al-Kawthari. This text is detailed and attractive, and we have provided its translation in the book “The Historical and Human Geography of the Shi’a” (pp. 121–122).
Ibn Hibban, the well-known scholar of men in the fourth century, wrote: I do not recall where I saw Malik ibn Anas or al-Zuhri narrating anything of the virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). See: al-Majruhin, vol. 1, p. 258.
[Page – 322]
His devoting approximately two hundred pages (28) to the virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) in this book with all the narrations transmitted through Ahmad ibn Hanbal establishes the extent to which he went in breaking the yoke of the Uthmani Ahl al-Hadith.
In these two hundred pages there came many matters related to the Imam’s life and virtues, among them: the hadith of Ghadir (p. 569), the Manzila, closing the doors (p. 582), the Two Weighty Things, the revelation of the verse of purification regarding the Ahl al-Bayt (p. 588), the first to embrace Islam (p. 590), the brotherhood (p. 598), and most of his virtues and merits.
Ahmad may transmit virtues for Amir al-Mu’minin that may sometimes be a cause of astonishment (29).
The matter of transmitting the merits of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) expanded over time among Ahl al-Hadith. A look at the book al-Sunna by Ibn Abi Asim shows the extent of the spread of this phenomenon in the books of Ahl al-Hadith. Many of the prominent virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) are mentioned in this book, among them the hadith of Ghadir. Al-Lalika’i devoted a special chapter to the narrations of the virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) (30), among them the hadith of Jabir ibn Abdullah where he said: “We, the Ansar, used to know our hypocrites only by their hatred of Ali ibn Abi Talib” (31).
We have seen up to now that Ahl al-Hadith insisted that belief in the three caliphs was sufficient for the real Sunni in the sum of his beliefs. Hence the efforts of Ahmad ibn Hanbal were directed toward making the matter of the tarbi’ of the caliphate with Imam Ali (peace be upon him) something harmless.
Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal says: I heard from my father that he said on the issue of preference: “Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman,” then added: “And we do not fault one who makes Ali the fourth, due to his kinship, his marriage relation, his early Islam, and his justice” (32) (p. 404).
(27) Edited by Wasi Allah ibn Muhammed Abbas, Mecca, Umm al-Qura University, 1403 AH.
(28) From p. 609 onward there are narrations about the virtues of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) narrated by Abu Bakr ibn Malik from his shaykhs other than Abdullah ibn Ahmad ibn Hanbal.
(29) As an example, look at this hadith: Abdullah ibn Ahmad narrated from his father, who said: My father told me, Sufyan told us, from Abu Musa and he is Isra’il from al-Hasan, from Ali may Allah be pleased with him who said: “By Allah, concerning us was revealed: {And We shall remove from their hearts any rancor brothers, on couches facing one another}” (al-Sunna, Abdullah ibn Ahmad, vol. 2, p. 573). (30)Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 8, pp. 1455–1468. (31) The previous source, p. 1462. (32)al-Sunna, by Abdullah ibn Ahmad, vol. 2, p. 590, 573. [Page – 323]
A group of individuals transmitted from Ahmad that he said on the issue of preference: “Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman; and there is no fault on one who adds Ali ibn Abi Talib” (p. 406).
He said in another report: “I hope there is no harm in it” (p. 406).
Ahmad affirmed in another text that both expressions were correct i.e., if we say Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman and remain silent, or we add Ali to them. As for the one in error, it is he who prefers Ali over Uthman (p. 407).
It appears that Ahmad was accommodating Ahl al-Hadith, and feared that his insistence on the doctrine of tarbi’ would provoke the anger of others and their standing against him. This claim can be established from some transmitted texts, as he was striving earnestly to transmit the virtues of Amir al-Mu’minin (peace be upon him). It came in one text that a person asked him: What about one who says: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali in your view is he not a Sunni? Ahmad said: “He is a Sunni. Why? Because there came about Ali such virtues as make the skins shiver, such as: ‘You are to me as Aaron was to Moses'” (p. 407).
Harun ibn Sufyan said: I said to Ahmad: Is it correct if someone says: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman? He said: “This is the saying of Abdullah ibn Umar, and we accept it.” I said: How about if he says: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali? He said: “A person of the Sunna.” I said: If he says: Abu Bakr and Umar? He said: “This is the saying of Sufyan al-Thawri, Shu’ba, and Malik ibn Anas.” I said: If he says: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Ali? He said: “This now is severe” (p. 408).
The condition of Ahmad ibn Hanbal and what he feared from the Uthmani Sunnis can be perceived from the following text: Ahmad was asked in the city of Homs known for its Uthmanism about the issue of preference, and his view was that the correct doctrine is belief in the first three only. When they asked Yahya ibn Ma’in about Ahmad’s saying, he said: “Abu Abdullah has spoken the truth; it is my school” (p. 408).
At the same time, we find him expressing his clear belief in other places. Hamid ibn Yahya al-Balkhi used to say: “Ahmad ibn Hanbal used to hold on preference: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali” (p. 409).
[Page – 324]
Despite this clarity, we find Abu Bakr al-Khallal directly after this text clarifying matters that may draw attention. He says: The well-known saying of Ahmad on the issue of preference is: “Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman,” but he used to say to Asim and Abu Ubayd: “I do not reject your saying on the tarbi’ with Ali.” Perhaps these two persons are the origin of the doctrine of tarbi’.
After that, a group of the senior leaders contemporary to him transmitted from him that he said: “Whoever believes in Ali is a Sunni.” Likewise Ahmad ibn Abi al-Hawari transmitted from him that he also believed in Ali. Al-Khallal added: “In my view, he did not like that the people of Syria take from him what they would adopt from him on that, because he is the imam of all people in his time no one among the people denied that so he did not like that anything be taken from him except the moderate saying, because the people of Syria exaggerate about Uthman as the people of Kufa exaggerate about Ali. Sufyan al-Thawri (may Allah have mercy on him) did something similar when he came to Yemen. He said: In what are they famously engaged? It was said: In nabidh and in Ali. So he did not narrate any hadith on that until he left Yemen. Scholars have insight into things and choose what they see as correct for the common people” (p. 410).
In another text, the matter of the opponents’ debate with Ahmad and his ambiguous answers also appears, as follows: Abu Hatim al-Razi said: I heard Ahmad ibn Abi al-Hawari say: Ahmad ibn Hanbal came to us (perhaps in the city of Homs itself), so I went to him and asked him about his belief on the issue of preference, and I said: “What is your doctrine on preference?” He said: “What conforms to the hadith of Sufayna on the issue of preference and the caliphate” (p. 409). The hadith of Sufayna was the hadith: that the caliphate after the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) is thirty years, then it becomes kingship.
Ahmad ibn Hanbal resorted to another type of ambiguity in the matter of including Imam Ali (peace be upon him) within the circle of the doctrines of Ahl al-Sunna, and so that he would not be a subject of accusation, we find him making a distinction between belief in preference and belief in the legitimacy of the caliphate.
It came in a report about him that on the issue of preference he mentioned only the names of the three caliphs, while on the issue of the caliphate he mentioned all four caliphs (33).
His evidence on preference was the saying attributed to Abdullah ibn Umar, while on the issue of the caliphate it was the hadith of Sufayna (p. 412) (34).
(33)Sharh Usul I’tiqad Ahl al-Sunna, vol. 8, p. 1453. [Page – 325]
According to the hadith attributed to the Prophet (may Allah be pleased with both of them) which says: “The caliphate is thirty years,” and since the caliphate of all the caliphs is thirty years, the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) must also be a valid and legitimate caliphate. In another report about him, he considered the hadith of Sufayna to be the evidence for the validity of Imam Ali’s (peace be upon him) caliphate from a legal perspective, and this matter is also part of the doctrines of the Sunnis i.e., the real Sunni must believe in it. In the continuation of this report there is a saying from Ahmad: “Ali (may Allah have mercy on him) is a just imam” (p. 412). Ahmad was compelled to support this saying of his with evidences and proofs so that it would be acceptable to Ahl al-Hadith, who were on the path of change and reform from their Uthmani school toward Sunnism.
What is certain is that Ahmad perhaps did not decisively affirm the doctrine of tarbi’, because he was accommodating the people of Syria in those regions. But in general he strove to establish the status of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) among Ahl al-Hadith, and to establish the doctrine of tarbi’ as well, which may have been formulated by some of the Shi’a-leaning Ahl al-Hadith.
Ahmad touched in other sayings on the matter of distinguishing between preference and the caliphate. His saying was transmitted: “I say: Abu Bakr, Umar, and Uthman in preference, and in the caliphate Ali is with us among the caliphs” (p. 413). In reality, the Uthmanis who were raised in the Umayyad era did not consider the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him) a legitimate caliphate at all. In a saying transmitted from Ahmad by which he intended to establish the legitimacy of Imam Ali’s (peace be upon him) caliphate he said: The Companions of the Messenger of Allah(may Allah be pleased with both of them) were satisfied with the caliphate of Ali and gathered around him. Ali established the legal punishments in the presence of a group of them and they did not oppose him. They used to consider him a caliph, addressing them and distributing the spoils, and they did not deny him.
Hanbal, the nephew of Ahmad, says: I said to Ahmad: “Is the caliphate of Ali established?!” Ahmad said: “Glory be to Allah! Ali (may Allah have mercy on him) establishes the legal punishments, cuts off, takes the charity and distributes it without right, and it becomes obligatory for him?! I seek refuge in Allah from this saying. Yes, a caliph whom the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) were pleased with, prayed behind him, fought alongside him, strove and performed pilgrimage, and they used to call him Amir al-Mu’minin, satisfied with that, not denying it. We are followers of them, and we hope from Allah the reward for our following them.”
(34) al-Sunna, by Abdullah ibn Ahmad, vol. 2, p. 590. [Page – 326]
Then Hanbal proceeded to explain Ahmad’s doctrine on the order of preference among the four, adding: “And Ali (may Allah have mercy on him) is a just imam after these. His imamate is established, his rulings are effective, and his command is binding. He was the most deserving of people after Uthman. These imams are the imams of guidance (may Allah have mercy on them)” (p. 413).
Al-Khallal later cited reports about a number of Imam Ali’s (peace be upon him) rulings, the distribution of spoils and fay’, which he brought to demonstrate the stability and firmness of authority for the Imam. In reality, the primary evidence for the imamate in the view of Ahmad and Ahl al-Hadith is the satisfaction of the Companions, who used to call him “Amir al-Mu’minin” (p. 414).
Ahmad said: Ammar and Ibn Mas’ud called him Amir al-Mu’minin (p. 415). It is worth noting that Ibn Mas’ud did not live to see the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him).
Then al-Khallal brought a detailed narration from Muhammed ibn al-Hanafiyya containing a description of how Imam Ali (peace be upon him) came to the caliphate and how people received him, and he mentioned the pledge of the Muhajirun and Ansar to him in these reports (pp. 415–417).
Al-Khallal transmitted other reports to establish the validity of the Imam’s caliphate, sometimes documented by some hadith scholars, among them the report of Abu Sa’id al-Khudri, where he said: I was with Ali in his war against the Khawarij, and I witnessed the killing of Dhu al-Thadiyya, and I searched for him among the slain and he was brought according to the description the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) had described. And I bear witness that I heard this from the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them). Then he transmitted from Ahmad ibn Hanbal his saying: “There is nothing with me more established in affirming the caliphate of Ali than this hadith of Abu Sa’id al-Khudri” (p. 418) (35). This establishes that Ahmad was earnestly searching for evidences to strengthen the status of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). In the continuation of this report there is a matter about Ahmad’s efforts to validate the narrators of this hadith, which al-Khallal also cited in support of Ahmad ibn Hanbal’s position.
In the course of the discussion, a discussion occurred about the hadith of Sufayna: “The caliphate is thirty years, then after that there will be kingship.” A questioner asked Ahmad, saying to him: Yahya al-Qattan used to speak against Sa’id ibn Jahman. Ahmad answered angrily, having well understood that this impugnment came only to deny the caliphate of Imam Ali (peace be upon him). For this reason he said: “This is false. I did not hear Yahya speak against him. More than one has narrated from Sa’id ibn Jahman.” And he said: “Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali these are the imams of justice. It reached the point of Ali’s justice that he distributed pomegranates and spices, established the legal punishments, and the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) used to say: ‘O Amir al-Mu’minin.’ Abu Abdullah began to use harsh language against those who did not say that he was a caliph. He said: ‘The Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) call him Amir al-Mu’minin, and these people do not affirm his caliphate.’ This means giving the lie to the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them)” (p. 419).
(35) Ahmad relied particularly on this narration and its like that the Prophet (may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace) said regarding the Khawarij. See: al-Sunna, by Abdullah ibn Ahmad, vol. 2, pp. 618–648. [Page – 327]
In another report he defended Hammad ibn Salama, who transmitted the narration of Sufayna from Sa’id ibn Jahman, and affirmed that he was becoming more insightful day after day regarding the authenticity of this narration (p. 420 and 421).
It is worth noting that the hadith of Sufayna is other than the well-known hadith of Safina concerning the virtues of the Ahl al-Bayt. What is meant here is the hadith: “The caliphate is thirty years, then after that there will be kingship,” or “The caliphate of prophethood is thirty years, then Allah will bring His kingship to whom He wills.” The narrator of this report is Abu Abd al-Rahman, one of the freed slaves of the Messenger of Allah, and it is said his name was Mihran. He transmitted from the Messenger of Allah(may Allah be pleased with both of them) as has passed: “The caliphate after me is thirty years, then after that there will be kingship.” According to this hadith, Ahmad considered the era of the caliphate to extend until the end of the caliphate of Amir al-Mu’minin, and on this basis he built the foundations of his doctrine on tarbi‘.
The aforementioned report was not narrated from Safina except by a single narrator, Sa’id ibn Jahman. When he was asked: Where did you meet Sufayna? He said: In the valley of Nakhlah during the time of al-Hajjaj (p. 421) (36).
In any case, Ahmad clung strongly to this hadith and tried to defend its narrators and the questions raised about them (pp. 421–423).
To know the role Ahmad played in this field, we cite this striking report:
Salih ibn Ahmad said: I asked my father about this matter, saying: If someone says: Is it incumbent upon one who affirms the caliphate of Ali to make him the fourth? He said: “We only follow what has come. And what is our saying?! Ali is in my view a caliph. He called himself Amir al-Mu’minin, and the Companions of the Messenger of Allah (may Allah be pleased with both of them) called him Amir al-Mu’minin, and the people of Badr, who were numerous, called him Amir al-Mu’minin.” I said: If someone says: We find Al-Albani commented at the end of the hadith in al-Sunna by Ibn Abi Asim: that because of this disagreement regarding Sa’id ibn Jahman, this hadith became hasan and not sahih.
(36) Al-Tirmidhi cited this narration in his Sahih, Book of Trials, chapter on what came regarding the caliphate, hadith 2225 (vol. 4, p. 503); Ahmad ibn Hanbal in his Musnad (vol. 5, p. 220); Ibn Abi Asim in al-Sunna (vol. 2, p. 562).
In terms of the shi’i groups from largest to smallest we have:
Ahl al-Sunnah wa al-Jama’ah.
Twelver.
Ismaili.
Zaydi
For further reading:
I-Wen Su’s 2022 study, Toward a Sunni Consensus on the Rightly Guided Caliphs: Ibn ʿUmar’s Hadith and Its Transmitters. Nimrod Hurvitz’s The Formation of Hanbalism: Piety into Power. The Life of Ibn Hanbal, Ibn Al Jawzi as translated by Michael Cooperson
“And say, ‘My Lord, increase me in knowledge.” (Qur’an 20:114)
﷽
Most people who study Islam or who are Muslims know that when it comes to Tarawih prayers in the month of Ramadan there is a juristic difference among the Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama’ah.
One view holds that Muslims are to do 8 rakats (2, by 2, by 2, by 2). This completes the Tarawih prayers.
However, the other view is that Muslims are to do 20 rakats.
However, what most people are not aware of is the practice in Southeast Asia where the jamāʿah is split after the mention of Uthman ibn Affan. Interestingly enough, this coincides with the 8 cycle rakats.
The mention of Ali Ibn Abi Tallib begins the 12 cycle rakats.
What do we mean?
After the Isha prayers the Bilal will begin with the following phrase:
May Allah be pleased with him and grant him contentment, make Paradise his abode, and benefit us through him in religion, this world, and the Hereafter.
Then two rakats of Tarawih prayer are done.
Before the next two are offered the Bilal will say the following phrase:
May Allah be pleased with him and grant him contentment, make Paradise his abode, and benefit us through him in religion, this world, and the Hereafter.
Then two rakats of Tarawih prayer are done.
Before the next two are offered the Bilal will say the following phrase:
May Allah be pleased with him and grant him contentment, make Paradise his abode, and benefit us through him in religion, this world, and the Hereafter.
Then two rakats of Tarawih prayer are done.
Intermission phase. At this point all the Muslims who believe in only doing 8 rakats of Tarawih leave the Masjid.
Interesting.
Now we continue on with doing 12 rakats of Tarawih.
So what is interesting here is that before the next two rakats of Tarawih the Bilal will say the following phrase:
May Allah be pleased with him and grant him contentment, make Paradise his abode, and benefit us through him in religion, this world, and the Hereafter.
This completes the first two rakats of the next phase of twelve total.
“And DO NOT OBEY the order of the transgressors, Who cause corruption in the land and do not amend their ways” (Qur’an 26:151-152)
﷽
Introduction
Between Rebellion and Oppression: The Ibadi Perspective.
Political authority and its limits have long been debated within Islamic thought. Central to this discussion is the Qur’anic directive:
“O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger.” (Qur’an 4:59)
This verse establishes a hierarchy of obedience while simultaneously allowing for disagreement. The presence of such a mechanism indicates that those in authority (ulī al-amr) are neither infallible nor absolute. This article explores how the Ibadi tradition interprets this framework, particularly in relation to unjust rule and the permissibility of resistance.
The Value of Stability and Governance
A stable government and stable governance is a blessing from Allah (swt).
Before addressing resistance, it is essential to recognize that stable governance is a profound societal blessing. Functional societies depend on key material and institutional conditions, including:
Access to clean water and food
Availability of housing and electricity
Maintenance of law and order
The removal of even a few of these elements can result in rapid societal breakdown. This aligns with modern frameworks such as Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, where physiological and safety needs form the foundation of human well-being.
However, while stability fulfills basic needs, it does not necessarily ensure justice, dignity, or moral development. Governments often promote belonging through nationalism and self-worth through material success. You have a better this. You have more of that. You have greater access to….and so forth. These all give feelings of accomplishment.
The feeling of self-esteem presents itself through merit through the education system, feats of valor in military service, and/or sports. However, even then most feelings of self-esteem and prestige come from the privileged group continuing to hold on to their privilege and usually in today’s market economy where materialistic nihilism is the new spirituality whereby making oneself feel superior to the next guy.
Yet, these may produce superficial or “false” forms of fulfillment. True human flourishing or what might be termed self-actualization is rarely cultivated within systems that prioritize conformity over moral truth, or justice.
In the last part of Maslow’s pyramid, the feeling of self-actualization is never reached or even encouraged in any government that we are aware of. Often for some people reaching that state of self-actualization and a sense of true freedom and/or awakening means going against the status quo.
So indeed having a stable government is a blessing from Allah (swt). That being said having a government that oppresses people, does not allow legal representation, has kangaroo court systems, death squads, etc are not a blessing from Allah (swt).
Violence, Nature, and Islamic Regulation
A key premise of this article is that violence is an inherent aspect of existence. From biological ecosystems to human societies, forms of conflict and self-defense are unavoidable. The Qur’an acknowledges this reality and regulates it rather than denying it.
Relevant verses include:
Permission to fight in response to oppression (Qur’an 22:39–40)
Prohibition of transgression in warfare (Qur’an 2:190)
Legal retribution balanced with the virtue of forgiveness (Qur’an 5:45)
Islam, therefore, does not advocate absolute pacifism. Instead, it establishes ethical constraints on violence, ensuring it is exercised only within moral and legal boundaries.
“So stand firm in your devotion to the faith, inclining to truth, [according to] the innate nature Allah has instilled in [all] people. There is no changing Allah’s creation. This is the correct religion, but most people do not know it..” (Qur’an 30:30)
The innate nature (fit’rata)
“When your Lord told the angels, “I will place a steward on earth,” they said, “Will you put someone there who will corrupt it and shed blood, while we glorify, praise, and sanctify You?” He said, “I know things you do not know.” (Qur’an 2:30)
Islam a religion that regulates violence.
We are commanded to sacrifice animals on certain occasions.
Those of us who are magistrates (judges) are commanded to enact the penalties of the Islamic penal code on those who transgress the limits.
The Blessed Prophet (saw) is threatened with extreme violence if he even were to think of pretending to write something on authority from Allah (swt).
Allah (swt) commands Muslims to fight those who fight them, and that some times Allah (swt) uses some people as a means of checks and balance upon the Earth.
What is violence?
The English definition of violence is as follows:
behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something.
strength of emotion or of a destructive natural force.
So we speak of a violent storm or we say that the volcano had a violent eruption.
There is not a creature on this earth even among plants and corals that do not act violently in some way shape or form or have not been given the means to defend themselves from aggression.
Vegans and vegetarians do violence to plants.
Insects, fish, and all manner of plants, flora, fauna, and creatures do violence to each other in this world.
Even if we were to witness a Jain in seemingly peaceful meditation one may not see the battlefield of violence inside the devotee’s body as different types of bacteria unleash violence on other types of bacteria.
We do not believe that there is a man reading this very article that if someone was to go into his home and try and rape his mother, daughter, sister, wife, or anyone else that he would put his life on the line to defend that person.
This is natural. Even among animals that try to flee a situation if given no other opportunity, they will stand their ground and fight.
“So stand firm in your devotion to the faith, inclining to truth, [according to] the innate nature Allah has instilled in [all] people. There is no changing Allah’s creation. This is the correct religion, but most people do not know it..” (Qur’an 30:30)
Now let us do some thinking for a moment. Let us look at some passages from the Qur’an.
“And if he [Muhammed] had made up about Us some [false] sayings We would have seized him by the right hand; Then We would have cut from him the aorta valve.” (Qur’an 69:44-46)
“Permission (to fight) is given to those upon whom war is made because they are oppressed, and most surely Allah is well able to assist them;[They are] those who have been evicted from their homes without right – only because they say, “Our Lord is Allah.” And were it not that Allah checks the people, some by means of others, there would have been demolished monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques in which the name of Allah is much mentioned. And Allah will surely support those who support Him. Indeed, Allah is Powerful and Exalted in Might.” (Qur’an 22:39-40)
“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed. Allah does not like transgressors.” (Qur’an 2:190)
“Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they are impaled…” (Qur’an 5:33)
“A prophet may not take captives until he has thoroughly decimated [the enemy] in the land. You desire the transitory gains of this world, while Allah desires [for you] [the reward of] the Hereafter and Allah is all-mighty, all-wise.” (Qur’an 8:67)
“So if you come upon such people in war, make a harsh example of them to deter those coming after them so that hopefully they will pay heed.” (Qur’an 8:57)
Turn the other cheek?
The closest verse to pacifism or turning of the other cheek that one will find is the following:
“And We ordained therein for them: Life for a life, eye for an eye, nose for a nose, ear for an ear, tooth for a tooth, and wounds equal for equal. But if anyone remits the retaliation by way of charity, it shall be for him, an expiation. And whosoever does not judge by that which Allah has revealed, such are the wrong-doers.” (Qur’an 5:45)
So in this verse, a person can forgive a wrong that is done to them; however, they are not required to do so.
These verses are only a handful of many many more than can be quoted.
Authority and Its Limits and conditions in the Qur’an
The Qur’an consistently conditions obedience to authority:
Obedience is linked to adherence to divine guidance (Qur’an 4:59)
Disputes must be referred back to revelation
Oppression must be resisted (Qur’an 49:9) & (Qur’an 42:39–43)
Moral Priority of Justice Over Social and Familial Bonds
The Qur’an further emphasizes that moral commitment supersedes even the strongest social ties:
Loyalty to family is conditional upon righteousness (Qur’an 9:23)
Justice applies universally, regardless of status (Qur’an 5:32)
If familial bonds may be overridden in the face of injustice, then political authority being a lesser bond cannot claim unconditional obedience.
Positive proofs from the Qur’an that we can rebel against an unjust leader.
First, it should be understood that if there is a dispute among parties that they refer the matter back to the book of Allah (swt). Second, the administration or government deserves admonishment first and foremost. No one group or individual has the right to take any matters into their own hands.
“Do you not see those who have been given a portion of the Book being invited to let Allah’s Book be the judge between them? But then a group of them turn away.” (Qur’an 3:23)
So the first point of reference is to the Qur’an.
“Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed. Allah does not like transgressors.” (Qur’an 2:190)
“And if two parties from the believers should fight, then you [O men] should reconcile between them. Then if one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah. And if it returns, then reconcile between them in justice and act justly. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.” (Qur’an 49:9)
Understanding the first proof:
These two verses together absolutely debunk the idea that Muslims cannot rebel against a leader. It is not reasonable to think that if two partices from the believers were fighting each other (with intent to kill) that the leader would not be opposed (if not among one of the two warring factions). So it is plausible that the leader could be from the party that oppresses!
Also says until it complies with Allah’s command (amri-l-lahi). Notice it does not say until it complies with the uli-l-amri (those that are given authority over you).
O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in the result. (Qur’an 4:59).
Understanding the second proof.
In this clear verse, we find that in matters of disagreement between those in authority and those under authority, we need to refer back to Allah and the Messenger. Had it been that, those in authority were infallible or divinely appointed, or to be given absolute obedience then, Allah (swt) wouldn’t have given any scope to disagree with them.
The fact that there is disagreement proves that “those in authority aka the Uli-l-amri”, are neither an absolute nor an infallible authority, nor are Muslims to submit to their seat of power in all things and/or all occasions.
In fact, often those who argue that we should obey the ruler no matter what will use this verse to deceive the masses! They will quote, “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you.” However, they do not quote the full verse! Why is that? Because it is proof against them!
“People, be mindful of your Lord, who created you from a single soul, and from it created its mate, and from the pair of them spread countless men and women far and wide; be mindful of Allah, in whose name you make requests of one another. Beware of severing the ties of kinship: Allah is always watching over you. (Qur’an 4:1)
“O you who believe, do not take your fathers nor brothers as allies if they prefer rejection to belief. And whoever of you takes them as such, then these are wicked.” (Qur’an 9:23)
Understanding the third proof.
The proof here is from inference. There can be no greater bonds than that of family, kith and kin. Yet even these blood ties are to be forsaken when our family turns to evil. If this is the case of blood ties how much more to an unjust, impious, or evil ruler?
“For that cause, We decreed for the Children of Israel that whoever kills a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it will be as if he had killed all mankind, and whoever saves the life of one, it will be as if he had saved the life of all mankind. Our messengers came to them of old with clear proofs (of Allah’s Sovereignty), but afterward lo! many of them continued to commit excess on the Earth.” (Qur’an 5:32)
Understanding the fourth proof.
No commentary, no tafsir that we have ever come across said that the verse above applies to everyone except the Caliph/Sultan/Leader/Imam, etc. If there is dear reader bring forth the evidence!
If you saved the life of the Caliph/Sultan/Leader/Imam, etc. It will be as if you saved the life of the whole mankind.
If you took the life of the Caliph/Sultan/Leader/Imam, etc. unjustly it will be as if you destroyed the life of the whole of mankind.
Now there are two caveats here the verse tells us.
You can take a life if someone has taken a life unjustly. You can take a life if someone is spreading fasadin (corruption). Who better to spread corruption on the Earth than a corrupt Caliph/Sultan/Leader/Imam, etc who is in a position of authority, influence, and power.
The killing of one person from a practical perspective outweighs the millions of lives that can be lost due to a leader who continues to kill and oppress. The killing of one may prevent the killing of thousands and millions.
“And that was ‘Aad, who rejected the signs of their Lord and disobeyed His messengers and followed the order of every obstinate tyrant. and they were [therefore] followed in this world with a curse and [as well] on the Day of Resurrection. Unquestionably, ‘Aad denied their Lord; then away with ‘Aad, the people of Hud.” (Qur’an 11:59-60)
Understanding the fifth proof.
Allah (swt) contrary to the hadiths that “Ahl Sunnah” will quote, did not find following the orders of every obstinate tyrant to be something meritorious and praiseworthy but rather something blameworthy and shameful, even to the point of being cursed in this life as well as the life to come! May Allah (swt) protect us from it!
“And those who, when tyranny strikes them, they defend themselves,Although the just requital for an injustice is an equivalent retribution, whoever pardons and makes reconciliation – his reward is [due] from Allah. Indeed, He does not love the unjust. And whoever avenges himself after having been wronged – those have not upon them any cause [for blame]. The cause is only against the ones who wrong the people and tyrannize upon the earth without right. Those will have a painful punishment. And whoever is patient and forgives – indeed, that is of the matters requiring determination.” (Qur’an 42:39-43)
Understanding the sixth proof.
While this verse has in two places that discuss forgiveness when retaliation is due, it also has two places that mention retribution for injustice and avenging oneself if wronged that this person is not to be blamed.
Now of course this verse is not encouraging vigilante justice or taking matters into one’s own hands. However, this verse is general and it equally applies to anyone in authority. No one understands that this verse excuses an officer, a judge, an imam, or a person in a position above others, including the Caliph/Sultan/Leader.
Interestingly, the word used for tyranny l-baghyu is also used for injustice, rebellion, discord. So it is not that masses who are the only one’s who rebel, but rulers, who do rebellion against Allah (swt) and against their sacred trust and duty towards people.
Now you will note that for us we rely heavily upon the revelation of Allah (swt) for our position and our proofs. Whereas those who differ with us rely heavily upon the oral traditions for their positions and their proofs.
Hadith Evidence and Conditional Obedience
It should be known clear as day that we follow the Manhaj of the Blessed Prophet (saw) who has given us a great deal of evidence. As well as his noble companions who understood the evidences and implemented it when necessary.
Proof 1.
On the authority of Abu Sa`eed al-Khudree who said:
I heard the Messenger of Allah (swt) say, “Whosoever of you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; and if he is not able to do so, then [let him change it] with his tongue; and if he is not able to do so, then with his heart — and that is the weakest of faith.”
Note that the very first recourse was to change the situation with the hands ……not to abide it with patience, not to run and hide like a coward but to change it with your hands…..first….not last…
Lastly, notice that it says clear as day that hating it with your heart (is the weakest of faith).
This hadith establishes a graduated obligation to oppose wrongdoing, scaled according to one’s capacity. Crucially, it affirms that passive acceptance of injustice is not the normative ideal; rather, moral engagement is.
In the political context, this implies that unjust governance cannot be indefinitely tolerated when the conditions for meaningful change are present. The “hand” in this narration has been interpreted by many scholars to include forms of direct intervention, though always within the bounds of prudence and collective welfare.
Proof 2.
Keep in mind that those who say and claim it is a sin to go against the ruler the well-known exchange between Umar Ibn Al Khattab (ra) and a companion.
One day Khaleefah Umar bin al-Khattab stood up and delivered a speech in which he said: “O people, whoever among you sees any crookedness in me, let him straighten it.” A man stood up and said: “By Allah if we see any crookedness in you we will straighten it with our swords.” Umar said: “Praise be to Allah Who has put in this ummah people who will straighten the crookedness of Umar with their swords.”
Source: (Dr Muhammed as-Sallabi, ‘Umar ibn al-Khattab, His Life and Times,’ vol. 1, p. 213)
This is well known.
Understanding the proof:
Umar (ra) was humble and pious and just. The people had the right to say such statements because people like him and Abu Bakr (ra) were immense people and great leaders.
However, when the “Ahl Sunnah” started to be ruled by dynasties and oppressors and people who were less than these great men, they made much excuses for them.
Proof 3.
“Verily, tyrannical rulers will come after me and whoever affirms their lies and supports their oppression has nothing to do with me and I have nothing to do with him, and he will not drink with me at the fountain in Paradise. Whoever does not affirm their lies and does not support their oppression is part of me and I am part of him, and he will drink with me at the fountain in Paradise.”
One of the objectives of the Prophets is to establish justice in the land. It is contrary to the teachings of mercy and justice that people should support and affirm the lies of the oppressors.
Attempts to distort what the Blessed Messenger (saw) gave us concerning oppression and rulers.
Proof 4 & 5.
Narrated Anas bin Malik:
Allah’s Messenger (saw) said, “You should listen to and obey, your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian (black) slave whose head looks like a raisin.”
“If an Ethiopian slave with a cut off nose and ear were appointed as your ruler, you would have to listen to and obey his orders as long as he rules in accordance with the Book of Allah.”
This hadith puts to bed the idea that “Ahl Sunnah” have first that the ruler can only come from the Quraish. However, notice that this hadith comes to us with a very interesting addition. That we are to under no circumstances to rebel against a leader/ruler/caliph/sultan/imam/leader etc, of any racial/ethnic background as long as that person rules in accordance with the Book of Allah (swt).
Proof 6.
Narrated ‘Abdullah:
The Prophet said, “A Muslim has to listen to and obey (the order of his ruler) whether he likes it or not, as long as his orders involve not one in disobedience (to Allah), but if an act of disobedience (to Allah) is imposed one should not listen to it or obey it.
The hadith before this one mentions that we are to obey the ruler as long as they rule in accordance with the Book of Allah (swt). The hadith quoted above states that we are to obey the ruler as long as they do not impose upon those they rule over disobedience to Allah (swt).
So we can see that allegiance to a ruler is conditional upon two points.
a) That this ruler actually rules in accordance with the book of Allah (swt).
b) That this ruler does not impose upon the Muslim disobedience to Allah (swt).
Proof 7.
Narrated ‘Ali:
“The Prophet sent an army unit (for some campaign) and appointed a man from the Ansar as its commander and ordered them (the soldiers) to obey him. (During the campaign) he became angry with them and said, “Didn’t the Prophet order you to obey me?” They said, “Yes.” He said, “I order you to collect wood and make a fire and then throw yourselves into it.” So they collected wood and made a fire, but when they were about to throw themselves into it, they started looking at each other, and some of them said, “We followed the Prophet to escape from the fire. How should we enter it now?” So while they were in that state, the fire extinguished and their commander’s anger abated. The event was mentioned to the Prophet and he said, “If they had entered it (the fire) they would never have come out of it, for obedience is required only in what is good.”
This hadith has shown that thankfully the companions were not dimwitted. These people had the intelligence to understand that throwing themselves into fire even though the commander commanded them to do so, that this was something ridiculous. Also again the hadith states that the Blessed Messenger (saw) said, ‘obedience is required only in what is good.’
Here, obedience is explicitly restricted to what is morally sound. The implication is clear: authority does not generate morality; rather, morality as given by revelation defines the limits of temporal authority.
Proof 8.
“There is no obedience to the created in the disobedience of the Creator.”
Sources: (https://sunnah.com/ahmad:1095) & (Ahmad Al-Musnad Vol 1. p. 366, tradition no. 1065, p 372-373, tradition no, 1095, Al-Nasai Al Kubra Vol. 8 p 71 traditions 8667-8668, Mariful Qur’an pg 481 Volume 5)
Understanding the proof.
This can be used on many occasions. We are exhorted to obey our parents but they asked us to worship other than Allah (swt) we can refuse them. If a husband asked his wife to do something immoral she can refuse. If the wife asks the husband to do something immoral he can refuse. If a government or any authority asks us to do anything that is in disobedience to Allah (swt) we do not have to obey them.
The combined weight of Qur’anic and Prophetic evidence does not support a doctrine of unconditional political quietism. Rather, it establishes a dynamic ethical system in which:
Authority is obeyed when it is just, corrected when it errs, and resisted when it becomes oppressive—within the limits of wisdom and the preservation of the greater good.
The Ibadi Position on Rebellion
The Ibadi tradition articulates a nuanced and conditional approach to political resistance:
A.1 Foundational Principles
Obedience to just rulers is obligatory
Rebellion against just rulers is a grave sin
Resistance against unjust rulers may become obligatory
A.2 Conditions for Legitimate Resistance
Resistance is only justified when:
There is a high likelihood of success
It results in less harm than continued oppression
Conversely, rebellion is prohibited if it leads to greater chaos, bloodshed, or societal collapse.
This reflects a deeply pragmatic ethic that balances justice with social stability.
The Ibadis do not encourage revolts against their Imams to avoid bloodshed. It is justifiable only as a last resort and in extreme circumstances, The history of the Ibadi Imamate in Oman speaks for itself as the following list shows:
Source:(Shaykh Soud H. Al-Ma’awaly in his book: Ibadhism the Cinderella Story Of Islam)
So there you have it. Yet some so-called Islamic scholars and historians have the impudence to say that Ibadhis are Khawarij who are terrorists and shedders of blood.
Now compare/contrast this with the first four Caliphs and the Umayyads/Uthmaniyyun
Now compare/contrast this with the Abbasids:
Now let us also mention to you (the reader) that the position of the Ibadi school (Ahl Istiqamah) is as follows:
We are absolutely to obey the just and good rulers in our society.
To go against the just and good rulers in our society is a major sin.
To go against an unjust and corrupt ruler who is spreading fitna and fasad is meritorious, praiseworthy, and obligatory.
Now there is a caveat to point 3.
A) If going against the unjust and corrupt ruler will actually meet with little chance of success and cause more bloodshed and chaos than if one had not, it is a sin to go against the rulers. One must abide by their cruelty and oppression with great patience. Until the circumstance arises to change course.
B) If going against the unjust and corrupt ruler will actually meet with a great chance of success and it will cause less bloodshed, suffering, and chaos than as mentioned it is obligatory and meritorious to do so.
That is our position (the position of the Ibadi).
There are books that go into the above scenarios in greater details. Because an overview does not do justice to each and every individual case or scenario.
Comparative Observations
The Ibadi framework differs from other Islamic traditions in its emphasis on:
Accountability of rulers
Conditional legitimacy
Moral merit over lineage or political control
While other traditions often prioritize stability to avoid civil strife, the Ibadi approach maintains that stability without justice cannot be morally justified. Often times the people themselves cannot endure it.
Now a few points to make about some of our brothers from “Ahl Sunnah” and those that take an opposite stance.
The Majority sect does not have a consensus on the issue no matter what they claim. In fact, they even say that one can go against a ruler if they commit a clear act of disbelief. Shaykh Muhammed Al Yaqoubi (may Allah continue to benefit us by him) asked for the overthrowing of Assad in Syria. Or the Madhkali Salafi Muslims who are active in the overthrow of the government of Libya.
Their claim of ‘ijma’ of course excludes us (Ibadi), Zaidi, and 12er Shi’i
Name a single scholar in the history of “Ahl Sunnah” that was against the rebellion of an unjust ruler or tyrant that was A) Not on the government payroll or patronized by the government & B) Not admired and patronized by the elites.
The fact that the “Ahl Sunnah” will claim that going against the ruler will result in more bloodshed and death and yet they will not even entertain the idea that replacing an obstinate tyrant by force would actually result in less bloodshed and death in the end.
Their inconsistency in saying that those who rebel against the sultan/caliph/imam/leader ect. have left Islam but their recognition that if such a rebellion is successful that the new leadership (taken by force) is now legitimate!
Their inconsistency regarding the companions on this matter.
Some of their bizarre stances that are taken in geopolitics which is self evident today before the entire ummah!
We hold fast to the following:
“O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in the result.” (Qur’an 4:59).
That’s it. If we are all Muslims than we can certainly turn to the book of Allah (swt) to settle our disputes.
Conclusion
The Ibadi perspective offers a balanced approach to political authority:
It affirms the necessity of order and governance
It rejects unconditional obedience
It permits resistance under strict ethical and pragmatic conditions
Ultimately, the Qur’anic paradigm establishes that:
Authority is a trust, not an absolute right
Justice is a requirement, not an ideal
Resistance is a last resort, not a default position
“And do not obey the order of the transgressors—those who spread corruption in the land and do not reform.” (Qur’an 26:151–152)
This verse encapsulates the ethical core of the discussion: obedience is not a virtue when it enables injustice.
Islam does not command obedience to power. It commands obedience to justice.
Muslims are thus called to be responsible citizens who uphold justice, avoid chaos, and remain anchored in divine guidance. When oppression becomes systemic and inescapable, and when conditions allow for meaningful change, resistance may become not only permissible but necessary. Government’s all over the world are intelligent enough to know that if they oppress people there will be repercussions to their actions.
May Allah (swt) guide all governments in making just decisions.
Allah (swt) knows best and the help of Allah (swt) is sought.
We dedicate this particular article to all people suffering from oppression and injustice all over the world.
May this world be filled with peace and justice. Amin.
First and foremost, what is Neo-Umayyadism? It is a romanticized idea of the ideal Islamic state — a vision of when the so-called “real” and “orthodox” Muslims were at their peak. It is fiercely defensive of anything related to the Umayyads. This includes, but is not limited to, Mu’awiya I, Yazid I, al-Hajjaj bin Yusuf, Ubayd Allah ibn Ziyad, Marwan I, etc.
They see the Umayyad dynasty as the peak of Muslim potential — a period when Islam was free of Alidism, esotericism, and Shi’ism in all its forms.
They see the majority of Sunni Muslims as products of the Abbasid dynasty. They strongly believe that a Shi’ification of Sunnism took place under the Abbasids. They firmly believe that “Abbasid Sunnism” is a “gateway drug” that can lead any nominal Sunni into becoming a full-fledged Zaydi or Imami, etc.
There is certainly some underlying truth to their claims.
In our interactions with such people, they have gone so far as to accuse Shu’ayb ibn Muharram al-Albani al-Arna’ut, Ali ʿIzz ad-Din Abū al-Ḥasan ibn Muḥammed ash-Shaybānī, and even Aḥmad ibn Muḥammed ibn Ḥanbal himself of Shi’ism!
They see themselves as a bulwark against any Shi’i-led political influence.
They show young men this map and say to them, in effect:
“At its height, during the years 661 to 750, the caliphate was 11.1 million square kilometers, making it one of the largest contiguous empires in world history. It was an empire where the praise of Ali and his household was not central at all.”
“All that went away when the cursed Abbasids came along! The Ummah to this day is under their grip!”
Whereas a normative Sunni by today’s standards would recoil at being called a “Nasibi,” these people wear it as a badge of honour! They embrace it and wear it as a perfume whose aroma they hope reaches the nostrils of all who have the least favourable thing to say about Imam Ali ibn Abu Talib.
This movement is particularly strong in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and Iraq. It has gained traction in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Turkey, and Egypt.
Do not think that the reach of this movement is limited to the Middle East. That is a far cry from the truth. As one brother mentioned to us regarding its reach in Indonesia, where a marker of one’s true Sunnism is to name one’s child Yazid or Mu’awiya — or at the very least to have these in their full name.
Abu Bakr and Umar will not do, because the “Abbasid Sunnis” — whom they (the Umayyad Sunnis) see as Crypto-Shi’i — name their children Abu Bakr and Umar.
For the Umayyad Sunni, the Caliphs were four: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Mu’awiya.
From the historical and academic perspective, this is true for the Proto-Sunni.
Whereas in our (Ibāḍī) normal interactions with Sunni Muslims, they recoil and are shocked to find that certain companions of the Blessed Messenger (saw) had a hand in the assassination of Uthman ibn Affan; these Umayyad Sunnis have no problem accepting this.
In fact, one of the arguments against the sincerity of Mu’awiya is that the opponents of the Umayyads ask: “Why didn’t he track down and go after those who killed Uthman ibn Affan, then?”
These Umayyad Sunnis respond: “He did exactly that! Starting with Muhammed ibn Abi Bakr [the son of Abu Bakr], who had his head removed and was desecrated by being stuffed into the carcass of a dead donkey and set on fire!”
They are quite prepared to give a list of all those whom they accuse of having a hand in the assassination of Uthman ibn Affan, and how Mu’awiya and his proxies executed them one by one.
You see, dear reader — and you may want to sit down for this one — in their view, Ali ibn Abu Talib was, and is, a Kharijite, and everyone who supported him was, and is, a Kharijite!
These people, from what we have seen, tend for the most part to follow the Maliki school, the Salafi school, and the Hanbali school. However, there is real tension when the issue of the accusation of Ahmad ibn Hanbal being a Shi’i, or having Shi’i sympathies, comes up.
They have their own shaykhs and teachers, and for the most part these tend to stay in the background (due to some of their more controversial takes), even among Sunnis who share hostility and disdain towards Shi’is.
We can give you one free sample of one interaction between us (Ibāḍī) and these Umayyad Sunnis. You will not fail to notice a single reply from any other Sunni to this man, even though he is making a strong accusation against a major Sunni scholar.
This was an exchange in which one of our brothers defended the noble companion Hurqus ibn Zuhair (ra) from the vicious attacks of these people!
@UthmanAbw (notice the name Uthman — why, of course) says:
“Ibn al-Athir is a malicious, resentful Shiite like you, so don’t try to speculate. And he cites al-Tabari, may Allah have mercy on him. Al-Tabari, may Allah have mercy on him, doesn’t speak without a chain of narration and is lenient in transmission. It’s clear that the malicious Ibn al-Athir chose what pleased him and cut the chain so we wouldn’t critique the narration and know its truth.”
Prima Qur’an Comments: What a feral little otter pup! However, these gentlemen would be in for a treat once they read the following:
‘Ali told one of his followers named al-Ashtar: “I told you that I assigned to Muhammed bin Abi Bakr the governorship (of Egypt); (but) these Khawarij have revolted against him.” Thus, according to ‘Ali, Mu’awiya and his followers were the Khawarij.
So, maybe now that this post is public, someone will rush to the comment section on X to go and scold UthmanAbw.
Not all Sunni scholars are asleep.Shaykh Al-Diddu has taken notice of this and spoke about it here:
Translation as follows:
“The idea of Nusb (enmity towards Ali and his family) and the innovation of Nusb that has emerged now has led many people in Sham (Syria), for example, to say: ‘We are Umayyads, and our affiliation is entirely to Banu Umayyah; our history began with Abdul Malik bin Marwan, and our allegiance is to Yazid bin Mu’awiyah,’ and so on. There is no doubt that in this there are great exaggerations and excesses. For this Ummah is one Ummah, and its best are the noble Companions, then those who follow them in goodness, and so on. Just as the Rafidah (Shia) slander Mu’awiyah bin Abi Sufyan (may Allah be pleased with him, his father, and his mother), and slander Amr bin al-As (may Allah be pleased with him), and slander a number of the Companions, likewise these Nawasib (those hostile to the Prophet’s family) slander the noble Family of the Prophet (Ahl al-Bayt). Both of these two groups have strayed from the right path.” — Shaykh Al-Diddu
But unfortunately, Shaykh Al-Diddu is a product of Abbasid Sunnism — the very kind that this Neo-Umayyad Sunnism warns about.
Some Sunnis have even gone so far as to disavow certain books altogether!
Like the following, which is not considered a controversial attribution:
“The people of Sham (Syria) sought Abu Musa, so he fled to Mecca; then Amr and the people of Sham headed to Mu’awiyah, so they pledged allegiance to him as Caliph, and Sharik returned to Ibn Abbas. And Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) — when he prayed the morning prayer, he would say in his Qunut: ‘O Allah, curse Mu’awiyah, and Amr, and Abu al-A’war, and Habib, and Abd al-Rahman bin Khalid, and al-Dahhak bin Qais, and al-Walid.’ This reached Mu’awiyah, so when Ali cursed [them]…
[Highlighted Text] “He (Mu’awiyah) would curse Ali, and Ibn Abbas, and al-Hasan, and al-Hussein, and al-Ash’ath.”
Source: Abu Abdullah Muhammed bin Muslim bin Qutaybah al-Dinawari, Al-Imamah wal-Siyasah (The Imamate and Politics), ed. Dr. Ali Shiri, vol. 1 (Beirut: Dar al-Adwaa al-Haqq), p. 210 (d. 276 AH).
You can research the current controversy surrounding this work yourself. Many scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah have authenticated this book as the work of al-Dinawari. Some scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah have shown disappointment that he spoke about these matters concerning the Companions.
It used to be that many Salafis and Wahhabis would create a huge fuss over this attribution. However, now that the Umayyad Sunnis are in town, they have put their hand over the mouths of the others and told them to quiet down. They see in this work an angle they can utilize to their benefit.
From the Abbasid Sunni (majority Sunni) position, this is not a good look. Ali is said to specifically be cursing Mu’awiyah and Amr and a host of others. That just cannot be, because we need to show the world a highly edited version of past events. Shi’is love this work because it shows Ali cursing Mu’awiyah and Amr. Ironically, the Umayyad Sunnis love it for the same reason that the Shi’is do! Not that they like or approve of the cursing of Mu’awiyah and Amr — no.
Read the text again. It shows Ali as the initiator of such a practice!
This reached Mu’awiyah, so when Ali cursed [them]… “He (Mu’awiyah) would curse Ali, and Ibn Abbas, and…
So when we come to the following hadith, in which Mu’awiyah asks Amir b. Sa’d b. Abi Waqqas why he didn’t curse Abu Turab (Ali), the Umayyad Sunnis will smile and say, “Of course! He is only responding in kind to the curses directed towards him!”
In the middle of all the sectarian fighting going on, someone had the idea to release a film on the fitna itself!
In this particular moving scene, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to imagine what goes on in the head of some people. The Umayyad Sunnis see themselves as the people of truth. Ali and his supporters are the Kharijites who assassinated Uthman ibn Affan unjustly. So replace Mu’awiyah with Syria, and replace the assassination of Uthman with images of widows and children crying for justice.
Ali and his supporters are seen as the protagonists. Today they could be Iran, or even the Abbasid Sunnis with their perceived esoteric doctrines and love of Ali’s bloodline.
We could be mistaken (someone please correct us), but for dramatic effect we believe the video below has ʿAqīl ibn Abī Ṭālib — who is the full elder brother of ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib — and ʿUbayd Allāh ibn ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb, the son of Umar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb, or ʿAmr ibn al-ʿĀṣ, flanking Mu’awiyah. Both Ali’s brother and Umar’s son fought against Ali.
However, do you know what this @Abu_Sufyan33 or whoever put the Arabic text in the beginning say?
They say this is the fourth commander of the faithful. Mu’awiyah! When it shows Imam Ali do you know what it says? Imam ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib the leader of the Khawarij!
The text in the above clip is translated below:
“We seek nearness to Allah through this war. By Allah, we are not fighting except those who wronged Uthman, and Allah does not love the wrongdoers!!! These people killed their Caliph unjustly and aggressively! They killed the Caliph of the Messenger of Allah, Uthman bin Affan! And they command us not to fight so are you pleased with that?” — Mu’awiyah as depicted in the film.
“Indeed, this day is the day of distinction between truth and falsehood. Those who fight us today reject the pledge of allegiance! They understand [only] wealth and power as the greatest! So will you leave the soldiers of falsehood to rise over you today?” — ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib as depicted in the film.
“O killers of Uthman, if you come out to us, we will fight you to the exclusion of the rest of the Muslims! Come out, O killers! O Allah, bring out the killers! How could you, Ali?! Allah is the Greatest!!! Allah is the Greatest!!! Allah is the Greatest!!! Allah is the Greatest, Allah is the Greatest!!! Allah is the Greatest, Allah is the Greatest!!! Allah is the Greatest.” — Mu’awiyah as depicted in the film.
Then, of course, the moving nasheed:
Allah’s blessings upon Sham (Syria) through the Banu Umayyah, They swept away the filth of the tyrants, so it became green and radiant. When soldiers from the land of Idlib came to it, They chanted “Allah is the Greatest,” fearing not death. They blocked its liberation and let all mankind know, We have returned to Damascus with pride after defeating the arrogant. They chanted “Allah is the Greatest, Allah is the Greatest, Allah is the Greatest,” fearing not death. They took the enemies by surprise at dawn when they attacked fiercely. They conquered Aleppo [Shahba] at noon, then called out to mankind. Immediately they found the march, and headed for the land of wine [referring to the Homs/Hama region]. They conquered Hama at night, they conquered Hama at night, then called out, “O my enemy.” They conquered Hama at night, then called out, “O my enemy.” They conquered it, then marched on to prostrate in Al-Khalidiya. They marched towards Sham, marched towards Sham, marched towards Sham, And they returned it to Umayyad rule, and the era of the regime ended. So it became free, the era of the regime ended, so it became free. Allah’s blessings upon Sham through the Banu Umayyah, Like eagles sweeping away the filth of the tyrants, so it became green and radiant.
“Indeed, We created humans in the best form.” (Qur’an 95:4)
﷽
An interview with the honourable Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi on a very important topic.
Translation is as follows:
We come to another topic, and this time it relates to the circumcision of girls. Yes. Perhaps among the customs and traditions that people have inherited is that a girl must be circumcised just as a boy is circumcised. You mentioned in a previous fatwa that this means something permissible perhaps an advisory Sunnah was reported regarding it. However, people have greatly expanded in taking this concession that you spoke about, this permissibility, and they have begun committing acts that may not be good, that are harmful to the girl. So now, has your fatwa changed on this topic?
“No, the fatwa has not changed, and the fatwa, considering what exists in our jurisprudential heritage, was contrary to much of what the scholars of religion said on this matter.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Rather, I said in it that my wish was that Muslim doctors would speak about this matter.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“What I mentioned in that answer was shocking to many jurists and students of Islamic legal knowledge because it was contrary to what they are accustomed to.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Aha.
“Let us clarify the matter once again. The narrations that have come regarding the practice of khafd (female circumcision), which is known as circumcision for females. They are not free of criticism. None of these narrations can be relied upon with confidence. All the narrations that have come are not free of weakness, not free of defect.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And what can be accepted with great leniency from these narrations does not, in reality, indicate what many jurists have concluded. Some narrations, for example, such as the narration that circumcision is an honor for the woman. It contains no legal ruling, so it cannot be used even to establish recommendation (istihbab), because this description “an honor for the woman” does not indicate a legal ruling.” Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And the Messenger of Allah’s instruction (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) in another narration which is one of the most relied-upon narrations by those who hold the view of recommendation and those who hold the view of obligation regarding circumcision for females is that he said to Umm Atiyya: “Trim but do not exhaust” or “reduce but do not exhaust”. This indicates the opposite of what was intended, it indicates the opposite of what many jurists have said, even assuming acceptance of this narration with great leniency.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Moreover, I am more convinced by the view of those jurists and scholars, both early and late, who held that all these narrations are not free of criticism. Nevertheless The Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him) it is not established that he instructed anyone to do it, or commanded it for his daughters or his wives (peace be upon him) or the believing women. It is only according to the narration that when he migrated to Medina, a woman who performed circumcision said to be Umm Atiyya al-Ansariyya asked him, and he said to her: “Trim but do not exhaust.” Now this indicates that the intent was to lighten a practice that already existed.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And therefore the guidance was for “ishmam” (light touching), for minimal taking without exaggeration. It is also apparent from this report, assuming its acceptance once again that the woman was qualified and capable of doing it properly, otherwise the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) would never have permitted her!” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“So now let us summarize what we have said so far.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Aha.
“None of the narrations that have come regarding female circumcision, regarding the circumcision of girls, is free of criticism that weakens it. Right?” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
“And accordingly, the utmost that can be said is that it is among the permissible matters. Among the permissible matters in Islamic law. Now we say it is permissible, that it is within legal permissibility, if it is done by someone who is qualified and knowledgeable, aware of the correct method, taking the necessary precautions, and not exaggerating in it.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“So if we say it is permissible, and it is established that it is in fact practiced by people; meaning when we say it is permissible, the first conclusion we arrive at is that leaving it involves no sin in Islamic law and no wrongdoing.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And this is an important conclusion. We respect the views of our imams and scholars from the various Islamic schools of thought. Perhaps some early Shafi’i scholars are among those who held it obligatory, and some Hanbali scholars, but others among the scholars of the Islamic schools for example, the Ibadi, Hanafi, and Maliki did not go that far. Some of them spoke of permissibility, and some said it is recommended, and they did not mention the derived legal evidence. These jurisprudential views are respected and are part of our Islamic heritage, but they should be understood, in terms of legal ruling, in light of the evidence that reached them.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And in terms of actual practice, they never intended that it be done by women who lack qualification, knowledge, sufficiency, and capability, and who do not take the necessary precautions to avoid harming the girls.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Beautiful.
“So since the matter is such that it is no more than permissible, and there is no sin in leaving it and no wrongdoing upon one who leaves it, then we can take the matter further than this.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Because what has happened in people’s actual practice is poor application, even in this act. On one hand, as you noted, they imagine legal rulings that have been shown to have no validity or to be exaggerated. But in practice, there are many incidents in which young girls have suffered great harm from bleeding or tearing, yes? Or exaggeration in exhausting to the point of affecting the urinary tract and the genital area.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Not to mention the injury and impact on the ability to conceive and bear children and on legitimate enjoyment in marriage And these are cases I have personally seen, seen from reality. Therefore, since the matter reaches this level of harm and damage, and lack of knowledge of correct application and correct execution even in the permissible amount; especially since it is not studied in medicine at all. There are no women practicing surgery for women who know how to do it, because contemporary medical sciences do not teach it. There are no specifications, no method, no standards, no procedure for doing it which is unlike the obligatory circumcision for males.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“This is not studied at all; it is not in the curricula. And what some Muslim doctors have mentioned of benefits and advantages of it unfortunately, in following up, I did not find that they rely on scientific evidence. They were advocating for jurisprudential views, and they should have stopped at the limit of permissibility.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Because establishing health benefits should be based on sound medical evidence.But we do not find this. We find descriptions and praise and mentions, but without relying on sound scientific evidence that could be relied upon. And even if that were established, it would be conditional on correct execution but if it cannot be executed in a correct manner, because there is no one who can do it at all, since it is not studied and does not exist in medical curricula, then leaving it in this case is preferable either it is viewed as restricting the permissible due to the harms resulting from doing it, or it is viewed through the principle of blocking the means that lead to harm, damage, and corruption for the girls for whom it is done. And Allah Almighty knows best. And forgive me for the length.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Okay, but the question relates to this topic. Since you mentioned that you have seen cases through perhaps your contact with doctors and your participation in biology conferences
Yes.
Is it permissible because no text prohibiting it has come, for example, or forbidding it? Or because the evidence found leads to the conclusion that it is permissible? Why is it not forbidden if it leads to such harms? The matter is very open.
“The view of prohibiting it is based only on what was mentioned previously.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
There is no text from which prohibition can be taken from a prohibition by the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings be upon him and his family). Rather, it is based on what was mentioned previously. And therefore a group and this can increase people’s confidence; a group of fatwa bodies and fatwa institutions in our Islamic countries today are also saying to prohibit this act.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“And they say so also because of what they have learned and reached regarding the weakness of the evidence that has come on this matter, and because of what has been established for them of poor practice leading to great harm and extreme harm.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
“It has reached the point with some circumcisers that they perform it behind hospitals and health centers because they know the result so that it may be closer to rescue and first aid, they do it near hospitals. And there is no limit to what could be said about the instruments used they are far removed from the health requirements required in this matter, let alone complete ignorance of it. The cases that the Omani female doctors told us about are not minor cases that can be overlooked.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“But what remains is that the foundation we rely on is: is this matter obligatory in the religion of Allah, Blessed and Exalted? Is it recommended and called for? The matter is not so.”-Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Is it permissible? Yes, we cannot say it is not permissible. But permissibility is restricted by what was mentioned previously of light touching, minimal taking and that it be done by someone with complete knowledge and understanding. But even so, can this permissibility be restricted due to the magnitude of harms that result from its application and practice? Yes, it can be restricted, as is the case with a number of permissible matters. Therefore, the view that is most convincing and most suited to people’s conditions today is to leave this act. And Allah Almighty knows best.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Let us now move the ruling from the act to the actor. By this we are meaning the one who performs this task but does not possess this expertise. Is she committing something forbidden?
“Yes, she is committing a forbidden act, since she is ignorant. And whoever practices medicine without medical knowledge is liable. Yes.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
This is narrated as a report, but it has become a legal maxim. There is no doubt that such an act originally requires knowledge, understanding, and science, and that one should adhere to that. That is why, as mentioned, these reports. Yes, there are narrations about naming the place “al-khatanun” (the two circumcisers). These are sound hadiths, but we know that in such dual-form names, the description may often be used by predominance.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“For example It is said “the two black ones” for dates and water by predominance. It is said, for example, “the two moons” for the sun and the moon, by predominance. So this does not mean that the description applies to both described things together?” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes.
“Therefore we said that the view in principle is permissibility restricted by its conditions. But this permissible act should now be left because of the transgression that has occurred in it, the severe harms that have afflicted girls, the lack of a sound scientific method, and the lack of qualified people to perform it. And Allah Almighty is the one whose help is sought.” -Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi
Yes, may Allah reward you with good. Thank you. Yeah.
Prima Qur’an comments:
People come in different shapes, colours and sizes. Some people have features distinct from others. This is part of our diversity. It is plausible that some women have larger labia than other women. So perhaps in the view of some cultures they felt having a larger labia would not be appealing to a prospective partner. It could also be due to what they perceive as hygene related. Perhaps in places where water was scarce and sand is plentiful this practice came about.
After all, in the event of no availability of water or the preference to preserve the water for drinking we as Muslims perform tayammum.
Also, as the Shaykh mentinoned we also know of couples whose intimacy has been ruined through this practice. Some layman whom we spoke with from the Shafi’i school had insisted that the practice is to keep the excitability of women in check! Very unfortunate!
However, we do not know any reason that has any merit for the excising of a woman’s clitoris!
There is a principle in Shari’a law
لا ضرر ولا ضرار
“Lā ḍarar wa lā ḍirār” = No harm and no reciprocating harm.
Abu Sa‘īd al-Khudri reported: The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “There should be no harm or reciprocal harm. Whoever causes harm, Allah harms him, and whoever makes things difficult, Allah makes things difficult for him.
We also have in Islamic law we also have what is known as: ‘Preventing harm takes precedence over attaining benefit.’ This is also known as: darʾ al-mafāsid muqaddam ʿalā jalb al-maṣāliḥ.
Thus, as the Shaykh said we have no proof text that explicitly forbids the practice. We also have no proof text that estabilshes that this was done by the Blessed Prophet (saw). It is not established that he instructed anyone to do it, or commanded it for his daughters or his wives (peace be upon him) or the believing women.
Examination of the ‘go to’ hadith itself.
As the Shaykh mentioned the hadith is weak. In fact, Imam Abu Dawud (the one who transmits this hadith) himself said it was weak!
Narrated Umm Atiyyah al-Ansariyyah:
A woman used to perform circumcision in Medina. The Prophet (ﷺ) said to her: Do not cut severely as that is better for a woman and more desirable for a husband.
Abu Dawud said: It has been transmitted by ‘Ubaid Allah b. ‘Amr from ‘Abd al-Malik to the same effect through a different chain.
Abu Dawud said: It is not a strong tradition. It has been transmitted in mursal form (missing the link of the Companions)
Abu Dawud said: Muhammed b. Hasan is obscure, and this tradition is weak.
However, when you click on the link above you will find that al-Albānī (Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut) gave the hadith a grade of Sahih (meaning sound)!
So from our perspective (speaking of the Prima Qur’an team) if an adult woman of sound mine wants to have this procedure than proceed. However, as it is very clear that infants, tolddlers and small children are not capable of giving thier consent it is best to abandon this practic altogether. Allah knows best and his help is sought. May Allah (swt) assist Shaykh Dr. Kahlan bin Nabhan Al-Kharusi in bringing light to the people!
For the interested Omani law states as follows:
Child Law (Article 20): Explicitly prohibits any person (especially doctors, nurses, and guardians) from engaging in, promoting, or assisting in “harmful traditional practices to the child’s health”.
Executive Regulations of the Child Law (Ministerial Decision No. 125/2019, Article 4): This is the crucial defining clause, which explicitly lists “female genital mutilation of any kind” as a “harmful traditional practice to the child’s health”.
Penalties (Child Law, Article 67): Violators face imprisonment of no less than 6 months and no more than 3 years
If you have found this entry informative you may enjoy the following articles:
“And if two parties from the believers should fight, then you [O men] should reconcile between them. Then if one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah. And if it returns, then reconcile between them in justice and act justly. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly.” (Qur’an 49:9)
“And whoever kills a believer intentionally, their reward will be Hell. Therein they will stay indefinitely. Allah will be displeased with them, condemn them, and will prepare for them a tremendous punishment.” (Qur’an 4:93)
﷽
Introduction
Qur’an 49:9 stands as one of the most consequential verses in Islamic jurisprudence, politics, and theology concerning intra-community conflict.
The Ibadi tradition offers a uniquely rigorous and internally consistent reading of Qur’an 49:9, the verse commanding reconciliation. This article demonstrates how the Ibadi tafsir resolves tensions between the verse’s apparent designation of combatants as “believers” and its command to fight the transgressing party. The Ibadi position hinges on the distinction between kufr al-milla (disbelief of the religion) and kufr al-ni’ma (ingratitude of blessing), maintaining that the transgressor remains within the milla of Islam but enters a state of ingratitude subject to divine punishment. This framework is supported by the unique linguistic status of Qur’an 49:9, the Prophetic prohibition warning, and the strict rules of engagement established by the earliest Muslim community.
“And if two parties from the believers should fight, then make peace between them. But if one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah. Then if it returns, make peace between them with justice and be equitable. Indeed, Allah loves those who act equitably.” (Qur’an 49:9)
“min al-mu’minīn”–(مِنَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ) The literal translation of “min al-mu’minīn” is “From the believers” or “Among the believers.”
This is very important to see how this verse of the Qur’an has been translated into English.
“Hence, if two groups of believers fall to fighting, make peace between them; but then, if one of the two [groups] goes on acting wrongfully towards the other, fight against the one that acts wrongfully until it reverts to God’s commandment; and if they revert, make peace between them with justice, and deal equitably [with them]: for verily, God loves those who act equitably.”-Muhammed Asad
“And if two parties of believers fall to fighting, then make peace between them. And if one party of them doeth wrong to the other, fight ye that which doeth wrong till it return unto the ordinance of Allah; then, if it return, make peace between them justly, and act equitably. Lo! Allah loveth the equitable.” -Marmaduke Pickthall.
This verse has generated extensive commentary across all Islamic schools of thought. However, the Ibadi tradition offers a uniquely rigorous and internally consistent reading that deserves careful attention. Drawing on the Ibadi tafsir Al-Abriz, the Taysir al-Tafsir of Atfayyish, the tafsir of al-Hawwari, the Prophetic tradition, and the broader Qur’anic framework, this article will demonstrate how the Ibadi position resolves apparent tensions in the text while maintaining a coherent theology of faith, sin, and community.
Asbāb al-Nuzūl: Reason or occasion for the revelation.
Ibn Abbas (or his report transmitted in Tanwīr al-Miqbās) (7th century / died 68 AH / 687 CE)
“(And if two parties of believers fall to fighting) this was revealed about the hypocrite ‘Abdullah Ibn Ubayy Ibn Salul and his host and ‘Abdullah Ibn Rawahah, a true believer, and his companions; these two parties fell to fighting after an exchange of words, and so Allah forbade them from fighting each other and commanded them to make up, saying, (And if two parties of believers fall to fighting then make peace between them) by referring to the Book of Allah. (And if one party of them) the party of ‘Abdullah Ibn Ubayy Ibn Salul (doeth wrong to) persists and transgresses against (the other) the party of ‘Abdullah Ibn Rawahah al-Ansari, and refuses to make peace by referring the matter to the Qur’an, (fight you that which does wrong till it return unto the ordinance of Allah) until it accepts to make peace by referring to the ordinances of the Qur’an; (then, if it return) if it accepts to make peace by referring the matter to the Book of Allah, (make peace between them justly, and act equitably) towards both parties. (Lo! Allah loveth the equitable) Allah loves those who judge justly by the Book of Allah, and act upon it.”
Tafsir al-Wahidi (by Abu al-Hasan al-Wahidi) 11th century / died 468 AH / 1075 CE) 400 years after Ibn Abbas.
“(And if two parties of believers fall to fighting, then make peace between them…) [49:9]. Muhammed ibn Ahmad ibn Ja‘far al-Nahwi informed us> Muhammed ibn Ahmad ibn Sinan al-Muqri’> Ahmad ibn ‘Ali al-Mawsili> Ishaq ibn Abi Isra’il> Mu‘tamir ibn Sulayman> his father> Anas who related: “I said: ‘O Prophet of Allah, why do you not visit ‘Abd Allah ibn Ubayy?’ The Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, decided to go and visit him. He mounted an ass and the Muslims walked with him. It happened that the ground was full of manure. So when the Prophet, Allah bless him and give him peace, reached ‘Abd Allah ibn Ubayy, the latter said: ‘Keep away from me, the staunch of your ass is offending me’. A man from the Helpers said to him: ‘By Allah, the ass of the Messenger of Allah, Allah bless him and give him peace, smells better than you’. One of the men of ‘Abd Allah ibn Ubayy got angry; then the men of both parties became angry because of what was said. They exchanged blows and hurled leafless palm leaves and sandals at each others. We heard that it is about them that (And if two parties of believers fall to fighting…) was revealed”. This was narrated by Bukhari from Musaddid and by Muslim from Muhammed ibn ‘Abd al-A‘la; both Musaddid and Muhammed ibn ‘Abd al-A‘la related it from al-Mu‘tamir.”
Tafsir Ibn Kathir (by Imad al-Din Ibn Kathir) (14th century / died 774 AH / 1373 CE) 300 years after al-Wahidi and 650 years after Ibn Abbas.
“(And if two parties among the believers fall to fighting, then make peace between them both.) Therefore, Allah calls both opposing groups among Muslims, believers, although they are fighting each other. Al-Bukhari and other scholars relied on this Hadith as evidence that committing a sin does not nullify faith, no matter how major the sin is. This creed contradicts the creed of the Khawarij sect and those who accepted their idea, such as the Mu`tazilah sect.“
” Said bin Jubayr said that the tribes of Aws and Khazraj once got into a scuffle using date tree branches and slippers. Allah revealed this honourable Ayah comanding them to make peace between them. As-Suddi said, A man from Al-Ansar, whose name was Imran, had a wife called Umm Zayd. She wanted to visit her family, but her husband prevented her from visiting them by locking her in an upper room. So, none of her family could visit or see her. She sent someone to her family. They came, took her down from the room and wanted to take her away. Her husband was absent at the time, so his family called on their people. Their cousins came to help prevent the wife from going with her family. A push and shove situation occurred that led to them fighting using slippers. This Ayah was then revealed in their case, and the Messenger of Allah sent someone to bring peace between them, and they both agreed to resort to the decision of Allah the Exalted.'”
Prima Qur’an comments. Ibn Kathir immediately evokes the so called ‘Khawarij’ and Mu’tazilah’ in which he puports to represent their position.
He then pivots to the Aws and Khazraj getting into a scuffle. He also narrates a conflict between among the Ansar themselves.
The prominent Maliki jurist Qadi Abu Bakr ibn al-Arabi (d. 1148 CE) from his landmark legal exegesis, Ahkam al-Qur’an remarked the following:
“The first: It was narrated by Saʿīd ibn Jubayr from Ibn ʿAbbās that it concerned Aws and Khazraj. A man from them insulted another, so each group supported its clansman until fighting erupted between them. Then the Messenger of Allah (saw) came and reconciled them, and Allah revealed the verse commanding justice and fairness.”
“The second: It was narrated that the verse was revealed concerning a dispute between two groups of the Anṣār. They took the case to the Prophet (saw), who judged between them. But one side refused the judgment and became angry, which led to fighting. Then Allah revealed the verse: “And if two groups of the believers fight each other, then reconcile between them.”
“The third: Al-Suddī narrated that a man from the Anṣār was married to a woman, and they had a disagreement. The woman wanted to go to her family, but her husband refused. She gathered her people, and he gathered his people, and they fought one another. Then the Prophet (saw) reconciled them, and the verse was revealed concerning them.”
“The fourth:It was said that the verse was revealed about ʿAbdullāh ibn Ubayy ibn Salūl (the hypocrite leader) who quarreled with a Muslim. Each of them brought his group to support him until fighting almost broke out. Then the Prophet (saw) reconciled them, and the verse was revealed.”
“Al-ʿArabī said: The most authentic of the narrations is the last one. “The correct opinion is that the verse is general, and it is not restricted to a particular cause of revelation. The Qur’anic verse remains general in meaning, even if it was revealed about a specific event. What is narrated about Aws, Khazraj, Ibn Ubayy, or the story of the husband and wife all of it fits the meaning, but the ruling of the verse applies universally to every case.”
The fourth case involves the hypocrite ʿAbdullāh ibn Ubayy ibn Salūl.
The second case involves one who refuses the very judgement of the Prophet (saw). Which makes you wonder how will you reconcile between those who won’t even accept the authority of the Prophet (saw). It is likely that ibn al-Arabi so the futility of that case from a matn perspective.
Ibn al-Arabi likely saw that the first case and the third case cancel each other out.
Why? Because if the verse was revealed for the first case it would be redundant to be revealed concerning the third case and if it was revealed concerning the third case it would be redunant concerning the first case.
The Ibadi scholars weigh in.
The eminent scholar Al-Qutb al-A’imma (r) said:
(“And if two groups from the believers fight”) – They are called believers based on their apparent state known to us before the fighting. Or it means: ‘And if two groups from the believers’ – like calling a prepubescent child a ‘disobedient sinner’ (‘āṣin) based on his state before reaching puberty, even though their fathers have died.”
The eminent scholar Shaykh Al-Khalīlī (h) said:
“As for His saying, the Exalted, (“And if two groups from the believers fight”), it is possible to understand it based on considering the faith (īmān) of the two groups before the fighting. Just as one says: ‘The disbeliever believed,’ ‘The people repented,’ ‘The misguided one was guided,’ ‘The Muslim apostatized,’ and ‘The pious person sinned’ – this is said with regard to what they were upon, even though after his belief he is no longer a disbeliever. Similarly, after his repentance he is no longer a sinner, after his guidance he is no longer misguided, and whoever apostatizes from his Islam is no longer a Muslim. Likewise, the trader, after he has sinned, is not pious.”
“Similarly, the faith of the two groups: it is correct to consider it with regard to what they were upon before the fighting. However, the faith that prevents its ascription [being removed] from a person and a sinner is the faith upon which success and salvation in the Hereafter are contingent. This is just as Islam is used in contrast to disbelief (kufr), for conventionally, every monotheist is called a Muslim, even if he falls short in fulfilling the obligations of Islam, even though…”
Question: Does this observation by the respected scholars find evidence in the Qur’an?
Answer: Yes! by using Tafsīr al-Qur’ān bi’l-Qur’ān which is the method of explaining or interpreting the meanings of one verse of the Quran by using another verse from within the Quran itself.
(49:9)fa-in baghat iḥdāhumā ‘alā al-ukhrā — “if one of them oppresses the other”
Is there any verse outside of Qur’an 49:9 that suggest that this is the conduct of the righteous and those who fear Allah? Is there anywhere in the Qur’an where Allah uses this descriptor to describe the righteous and those who fear Allah?
The root b-gh-y is not used for ordinary sinning. It is used for transgression, oppression, rebellion — a specific and severe category. This specific category is never applied to believers or to the righteous anywhere in the Qur’an.
Form I verb baghā (بَغَىٰ) — 25 times
Every single Qur’anic usage of Form I in the active sense is negative. It means to transgress, oppress, rebel, or wrong someone.
Examples:
(2:213)baghyan baynahum — “out of jealousy among themselves”
(3:19)baghyan baynahum — “out of envy among themselves”
(7:33)wal-baghya bighayri al-haqq — “and oppression without right” (forbidden)
(10:23)yabghūna fi’l-ard bighayri al-haqq — “they rebel in the earth without right”
(28:76)fa-baghā ‘alayhim — “but he oppressed them” (Qarun)
(38:22)baghā ba’ḍunā ‘alā ba’ḍ — “one of us has wronged the other”
(42:27)la-baghaw fi’l-ard — “they would surely rebel in the earth”
(49:9)fa-in baghat iḥdāhumā ‘alā al-ukhrā — “if one of them oppresses the other”
(55:20)lā yabghiyāni — “they do not transgress” (the two seas)
Conclusion: Form I verb baghā is never used in the Qur’an to describe the righteous positively. It is always transgression, oppression, or rebellion. The only “neutral” usage is in the sense of “seeking” in a few places, but even then the context is not describing the righteous as such. Example: (3:83) afaghayra dīn Allāh yabghūna — “Do they seek other than the religion of Allah?” — which is a rebuke.
Noun baghy (بَغْي) — 11 times
Every single usage is negative. It means transgression, oppression, envy, or rebellion.
(2:90)baghyan — “grudging”
(2:213)baghyan baynahum — “out of jealousy among themselves”
(3:19)baghyan baynahum — “out of envy among themselves”
(6:146)bibaghyihim — “for their rebellion”
(7:33)wal-baghya — “and oppression” (forbidden)
(10:23)baghyukum — “your rebellion”
(10:90)baghyan wa ‘adwan — “in tyranny and enmity” (Pharaoh)
(16:90)wal-baghyi — “and oppression” (forbidden)
(42:14)baghyan baynahum — “out of rivalry”
(42:39)al-baghyu — “tyranny”
(45:17)baghyan baynahum — “out of envy”
Conclusion: The noun baghy is never used positively. It is always a blameworthy quality.
Noun baghiyy (بَغِيّ) — 2 times
Both usages refer to an unchaste woman — a negative term:
(19:20)wa mā kuntu baghiyyan — “I have not been unchaste” (Maryam’s defense)
(19:28)wa mā kānat ummuki baghiyyan — “nor was your mother unchaste”
Conclusion: Always negative.
Verbal noun bighā’ (بِغَاء) — 1 time
(24:33)wa lā tukrihū fatayātikum ‘alā al-bighā’ — “do not compel your slave girls to prostitution”
Conclusion: Always negative.
Active participle bāgh (بَاغ) — 3 times
All three occur in the same phrase:
(2:173)ghayra bāghin wa lā ‘ādin — “neither desiring [it] nor transgressing”
(6:145) same
(16:115) same
Conclusion: The participle bāgh here means “one who desires” or “one who transgresses” — in the context of eating forbidden food under necessity. It is not describing the righteous; it is describing the limits of a concession for the one in need. The righteous person is the one who does not desire the forbidden thing.
Perhaps the most striking feature of the Sunni understanding of Qur’an 49:9 is that this is the only verse in the entire Qur’an where they can claim the apparent believers are described as bāghī (transgressors)!
The Sunni reading must work harder to explain why the Qur’an uses a term for believers in 49:9 that it never uses for believers anywhere else.
If the question is which reading is on firmer textual footing, the Ibadi reading has the stronger case. This is not because it is the majority position, but because it is the reading that accounts for the most textual data with the no unresolved tensions.
Where as we have seen using Tafsīr al-Qur’ān bi’l-Qur’ān the Sunni understanding doesn’t hold under scrutiny.
This misunderstanding not only clashes with the Qur’an but clashes with sound tranmission from the Blessed Prophet (saw).
As we have seen it clashes with the Qur’an. Such a descrption is never applied to believers or to the righteous anywhere in the Qur’an.
It also clashes with the following:
“And whoever kills a believer intentionally, their reward will be Hell. Therein they will stay indefinitely. Allah will be displeased with them, condemn them, and will prepare for them a tremendous punishment.” (Qur’an 4:93)
The (eternal punishment for intentional killing of a believer) creates a tension that the Sunni framework struggles to resolve without collapsing into Murji’ism.
This verse presents a serious problem for the Sunni reading:
If the bāghī remains a believer, and they intentionally kill another believer, then Qur’an 4:93 applies to them: eternal Hell.
But Sunni theology generally holds that a Muslim who commits a major sin does not face eternal Hell they face punishment, then eventually enter Paradise.
So either Qur’an 4:93 applies to the bāghī (and they face eternal punishment), or Qur’an 4:93 does not apply to the bāghī (which shouldn’t require an strenuous explanation).
Narrated Ibn `Umar:
I heard the Prophet (saw) saying, “Do not revert to disbelief (kuffaran) after me by striking (cutting) the necks of one another.”
The Ibadi reading is that this confirms that intra-Muslim fighting is a form of kufr. In particular kufr al-ni’ma, the kufr that does not expel one from the milla.
The Ibadi reading has the advantage of taking the word kufr seriously while still maintaining that the fighters remain within the community. The Sunni reading must explain why the Prophet (saw) used the word kufr if he did not mean kufr in some sense. Look at the verse:
“Then if one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah.”
The verse does not describe the two parties who did ijtihād and erred. Or had a “difference of opinion” — it uses the language of transgression.
It cannot be imagined that Allah (swt) is asking believers to fight against those who are in conformity with Allah and his Messenger.
This is proven by the fact that one faction has to return to the command of Allah. If they were upon the command of Allah they would not be fought.
The Verse of the Qur’an Does Not Call Both Parties Believers While They Fight.
Let us look at the actual Arabic:
وَإِن طَائِفَتَانِ مِنَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ اقْتَتَلُوا Wa-in ṭā’ifatāni min al-mu’minīna iqtatalū
The structure is:
طَائِفَتَانِ (ṭā’ifatāni) — two factions
مِنَ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ (min al-mu’minīna) — from among the believers
اقْتَتَلُوا (iqtatalū) — they fought
The description “from among the believers” qualifies the subject before the action. The verse does not say “two factions of believers fought.” It says “if two factions from among the believers fight.”
Grammatically and logically, the min al-mu’minīn is identifying who these factions are drawn from — the believing community. It is describing their origin, their prior status, their membership in the community.
It is not saying they are believers in the state of fighting.
So when the Qur’an says “two factions from among the believers fought,” it is saying:
They were believers before the fighting.
The one who commits (baghy) transgression is to be fought.
The description “believer” applies to what they were, not to what they are doing.
The verse continues:
فَإِن بَغَتْ إِحْدَاهُمَا عَلَى الْأُخْرَىٰ فَقَاتِلُوا الَّتِي تَبْغِي Fa-in baghat iḥdāhumā ‘alā al-ukhrā fa-qātilū allatī tabghī “But if one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses.”
So the Qur’an:
Identifies them as from among the believers (prior state).
Describes one of them as transgressing (baghat).
Commands fighting the transgressing one — not both.
If both parties remained believers in the state of fighting, the verse would not single out one as the transgressor. The verse makes a moral distinction: one party is in the wrong. The other is the wronged party. The wronged party is not fought. The transgressing party is fought until it returns to Allah’s command.
This is why the Sunni framing of “two groups of believers who had a misunderstanding” is problematic. The verse does not describe a mutual misunderstanding. It describes one party transgressing against the other.
What they were: believers.
What one of them did: transgressed.
What the community must do: fight the transgressor until it returns.
The one who fights unjustly is the bāghī. The one who is fought against is the wronged believer.
So the question becomes: what is the status of the believer who transgresses?
This is where the Ibadi framework comes in:
They remain within the milla(the religion). They are not kuffār in the sense of kufr al-milla.
But they have entered kufr al-ni’ma. That is the ingratitude of blessing by transgressing against their fellow believers.
They are subject to fighting until they return, and to divine punishment if they do not.
This is a coherent, textually grounded framework. And it does not require reading the verse as describing a “big misunderstanding” between two parties who remain believers while fighting.
The Argument from A Fortiori Reasoning (Qiyās al-Awlawī)
“O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule other people; perhaps they may be better than them; nor let women ridicule other women; perhaps they may be better than them. And do not insult one another and do not call each other by offensive nicknames. Wretched (bi’sa) is the name of disobedience (l-fusūqu) after [one’s] faith. And whoever does not repent – then it is those who are the (l-ẓālimūna) wrongdoers.” (Qu’ran 49:11)
If ridicule — a word, a gesture, a nickname — is enough to earn the label fāsiq and ẓālim, then what about killing?
The Qur’anic reasoning is:
Premise 1: Ridicule and insult are prohibited, and those who persist in them are called fāsiq and ẓālim (Qur’an 49:11).
Premise 2: Killing a believer intentionally is a far graver offense . It is the destruction of a life, the breaking of the community, the ultimate transgression against a fellow Muslim.
Conclusion: Therefore, the one who kills a believer is at least a fāsiq and a ẓālim and in fact, far worse.
Notice the sequence. The verse does not say:
“Ridiculing is a minor sin.”
“Insulting is a peccadillo.”
“Nicknames are a trivial matter.”
It says:
The one who does these things has been labeled with disobedience (fusūq).
The one who does not repent is among the wrongdoers (ẓālimūn).
These are Qur’anic categories of serious moral failure. They are not casual descriptors. They are the same categories used elsewhere in the Qur’an for grave offenses.
Now place this next to Qur’an 4:93:
“And whoever kills a believer intentionally, their reward will be Hell. Therein they will stay indefinitely. Allah will be displeased with them, condemn them, and will prepare for them a tremendous punishment.” (Qur’an 4:93)
If ridicule earns fusūq and ẓulm, then intentional killing which earns eternal Hell and divine curse cannot possibly leave the perpetrator in the same moral category as before.
Dear readers! What planet or universe does this make sense? Taking the life of a believer is a lesser offense than ridicule?!
This is precisely the point. The Sunni framework that says:
Ridicule → fāsiq, ẓālim
Intentional killing of other Muslims → are the actions of a Mu’min?
This creates a moral inversion. The lesser offense (ridicule) earns the label fāsiq and ẓālim. The greater offense (killing) supposedly leaves one a Mu’min in good standing. It is a matter of ijtihad?!
This is incoherent. And it is precisely why the Ibadi framework of kufr al-ni’ma is more consistent:
Ridicule → kufr al-ni’ma (ingratitude)
Intentional killing → kufr al-ni’ma (ingratitude), and far more severe
Both are within the milla outwardly, but both have entered kufr al-ni’ma. The difference is in the degree of the offense and the severity of the punishment.
The Qur’an does not say that the one who ridicules is a Mu’min in good standing. It says he is a fāsiq and a ẓālim unless he repents. How much more, then, the one who kills?
The Two Types of Kufr: Kufr al-Milla and Kufr al-Ni’ma
The Ibadi position hinges on a critical distinction between two categories of kufr (disbelief/ingratitude):
1. Kufr al-Milla (Disbelief of the Religion): This is outright rejection of Islam, placing one outside the community of believers entirely. This is the kufr of the polytheists and those who deny God’s existence or reject the Prophethood of Muhammed(saw).
2. Kufr al-Ni’ma (Disbelief/Ingratitude of Blessing): This applies to a Muslim who commits a major sin (kabīra) but still affirms the oneness of Allah (tawḥīd) and belongs to the milla of Islam. Such a person is a kāfir in the sense of being ungrateful for Allah’s blessings, but not a kāfir in the sense of being outside the faith.
This distinction is rooted in the Qur’an itself. In Surah Ibrahim (14:7), Allah declares:
“And [remember] when your Lord proclaimed, ‘If you are grateful (shakartum), I will surely increase you [in favor]; but if you are ungrateful (kafartum), indeed, My punishment is severe.'” (Qur’an 14:7)
The verse establishes a direct correlation between gratitude (shukr) and increase in favor, and between ingratitude (kufr) and severe punishment. The one who fights and kills fellow believers is acting in kufr al-ni’ma. They are ungrateful for the blessings of faith, brotherhood, and life itself.
Crucially, the Qur’an does not promise paradise to the ungrateful (kafartum) as a standalone category. Paradise is promised to the believers, the righteous, the Allah-conscious, the patient, and the repentant. In no place is it ever promised to the ungrateful (kafir) as a category. Therefore, the bāghī cannot claim the promise of paradise while persisting in their transgression.
The Qur’an explicitly warns:
“And whoever kills a believer intentionally, their reward will be Hell. Therein they will stay indefinitely. Allah will be displeased with them, condemn them, and will prepare for them a tremendous punishment.” (Qur’an 4:93)
This verse presents a serious theological problem: How can a believer who commits such a sin face eternal punishment? The Ibadi answer is that the intentional killer has entered a state of kufr al-ni’ma—a state of ingratitude so profound that they are subject to the severe punishment promised in Qur’an 14:7.
Qur’an 2:112 and The Two Conditions
“Yes [on the contrary], whoever submits his face (wholeself/being) in Islam to Allah while being a doer of good will have his reward with his Lord. And no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve.”
The verse establishes two conditions:
أَسْلَمَ وَجْهَهُ لِلَّهِ (aslama wajhahu li’llāh) — submission of the face to Allah. This is the inward orientation: sincerity, devotion, turning toward Allah.
وَهُوَ مُحْسِنٌ (wa-huwa muḥsin) — being a doer of good. This is the outward manifestation: actions of obedience, iḥsān in practice.
The reward is contingent on both. Neither alone is sufficient. This is a key Qur’anic principle: faith and works are inseparable in the Qur’anic vision of salvation.
How This Fits the Ibadi Understanding
The Ibadi framework of kufr al-ni’ma (ingratitude of blessing) and kufr al-milla (disbelief of religion) maps directly onto this verse:
The person who claims belief but has no outward actions of obedience has entered kufr al-ni’ma. They have not left the milla — they are still outwardly Muslim, still part of the community — but they are not fulfilling the condition of iḥsān that Qur’an 2:112 requires for reward and security.
This is precisely why the Ibadi tradition takes outward conformity seriously. It is not enough to say “I believe”. The Qur’an demands that belief be accompanied by iḥsān (doing good).
By not, at the very least, calling out the lack of outward conformity, it becomes very easy for hypocrites to move about undetected, although the inward hypocrisy can only be dealt with by Allah.
The Ibadi framework does not pretend to judge the inward. It judges the outward, because that is what the community has access to, and it leaves the inward to Allah. But precisely because it takes the outward seriously, it does not allow outward conformity to be ignored.
Every Mumin is a Muslim but not every Muslim is a Mumin.
“The bedouins say, ‘We have believed.’ Say, ‘You have not believed; but say [instead], “We have submitted,” for faith has not yet entered your hearts.'” (Qur’an 49:14)
This verse is directly adjacent to Qur’an 49:9–12. It is part of the same surah, the same discourse, and the same thematic unit. And it establishes the exact distinction this article is builds on:
Term
Meaning
What it describes
Islam (أَسْلَمْنَا)
Submission, outward entry into the community
The dhāhir — what is visible, legal, social
Īmān (آمَنَّا)
Faith, inward conviction
The inward (bāṭin) —what is in the heart or the ḥaqīqa (reality) — is only accessible to Allah
The bedouins claimed īmān (inward faith). Allah corrected them: You have not believed; say instead that you have submitted. The outward profession of Islam is real, but the inward faith has not yet entered their hearts.
The bedouins in 49:14 are Muslims (aslamnā). That is they have entered the milla. But they are not yet believers (mā āmannā). Meaning īmān has not entered their hearts. Their status is:
Outwardly: Muslim part of the community, subject to its laws and protections.
Inwardly: Not yet a mu’min faith has not entered the heart.
Their reality: Their reality is known to Allah alone.
The Prophetic Warning
The Ibadi reading of Qur’an 49:9 is strongly supported by the Prophetic tradition.
“Do not revert after me as disbelievers, striking the necks of one another.”
The Arabic word used is kuffāran (كُفَّارًا). While some translations render this as “disbelievers,” the Ibadi understanding as reflected in our translation as “ungrateful ones” actually captures the essence of the warning. The Blessed Prophet (saw) was not saying that those who fight each other become actual disbelievers outside the fold of Islam. Rather, he was warning that fighting fellow Muslims is an act of extreme ingratitude (kufr al-ni’ma) that mimics the behavior of disbelievers.
Narrated Ibn `Abbas:
The Prophet (saw) said, “When (a person) an adulterer commits illegal sexual intercourse, then he is not a believer at the time he is doing it; and when somebody steals, then he is not a believer at the time he is stealing .”
The Prophet (saw) said, “An adulterer, at the time he is committing illegal sexual intercourse is not a believer; and a person, at the time of drinking an alcoholic drink is not a believer; and a thief, at the time of stealing, is not a believer.” Ibn Shihab said: `Abdul Malik bin Abi Bakr bin `Abdur-Rahman bin Al- Harith bin Hisham told me that Abu Bakr used to narrate that narration to him on the authority of Abu Huraira. He used to add that Abu Bakr used to mention, besides the above cases, “And he who robs (takes illegally something by force) while the people are looking at him, is not a believer at the time he is robbing (taking).
So when a person who is part of the milla of Islam is not described a believer at the moment they commit illegal sexual intercourse, steals, drinks, or robs then what is his status when he oppresses a fellow Muslim? Especially when this oppression leads to intentional killing?
The Ibadi commentary in Al-Abriz reinforces this point:
It is not valid to apply the name of ‘Believer’ to the one who commits major sins, as is apparent from the noble verse, because He described them with faith at the time of the fighting, before it.” (Al-Abriz, p. 315)
The Divine Method in Extinguishing the Fitnah of Fighting Between the Believers
“And if two factions among the believers should fight, then make settlement between the two. But if one of them oppresses the other, then fight against the one that oppresses until it returns to the ordinance of Allah. And if it returns, then make settlement between them in justice and act justly. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly. The believers are but brothers, so make settlement between your brothers. And fear Allah that you may receive mercy.” (Qur’an 49:9-10) -pg 314 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
“And the point of connection between this passage and the previous passage is what was mentioned regarding the possibility of the people being afflicted with ignorance. This leads to the fire of discord and the disintegration of the bonds of brotherhood. And the Muslims, in the throes of confusion and regret, hasten with the necessary remedy to heal the wounds of division and conflict, and to extinguish the flames of hatred and aversion. And if “And if two factions among the believers should fight, then make settlement between the two” — O leaders of the Muslim community — the sparks of conflict between two factions of the believers appear, leading to outbreaks of wars and bloody clashes, then hasten to mend the breach and gather the word.” -pg 314 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
” [This is] in light of what has been permitted to you of experience in the field of reform. The root [of the word] in the verb “should fight” (iqtatalū) is used in the sense of intending the occurrence. This is like His saying, the Most High: “O you who have believed, when you rise to [perform] prayer…” (5:6). [This is] because the command to reform is obligatory, and the nearest [course of action] when signs of enmity and verbal confrontations appear is that, because the matter is greater, blood has flowed and properties have been destroyed. And with this, there is a transition to the branch: “But if one of them oppresses the other.” And the meaning and the face [of it]: Al-Ta’ifah (the faction): the group distinguished from others by language, or history, or social specificity. And it is not valid to apply the name of “believer” to the one who commits major sins, as is apparent from the noble verse, because He described them with iman (faith) before their fighting, as became clear to you previously from His saying: “And if two factions among the believers should fight…” (49:9). If one of them does not submit to the other, [and] does not yield to the path of reconciliation, harmony, and agreement, it leads to arrogance and audacity in aggression against the other with force and weapons. [This is indicated by] His saying: “then fight against the one that oppresses until it returns to the ordinance of Allah” (49:9). So the leadership of the Muslim community aids the oppressed faction against the oppressive, transgressing faction until it submits to the command of Allah, and His command is what calls to it of responding to the call of reconciliation and justice, and refraining from injustice. “And if it returns, then make settlement between them in justice” (49:9).” -pg 314-315 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
“If the transgressing faction desists from its aggression and stops its crimes, then make peace — O leadership of the Muslim community — between the two factions with the balance of justice, to reach a solution that satisfies the guardians of both parties. And it may be among the crucial matters that contribute to extinguishing the flames of discord: the absence of demanding compensation from the two parties for blood and wealth, and emphasis upon the removal of justice, for the position is one of caution regarding bias and harm, especially if the damages of the two factions are vastly different, and their losses are greatly disparate. “And act justly. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly” (49:9) — meaning: return. And His saying “and act justly” is an emphasis upon the guardians of the matter to reaffirm the aforementioned testament of justice, because reform in matters of blood and destruction requires much study, focus, and deliberation, so that every possessor of a right is given their right. And the command to establish justice in the verse is general, encompassing all aspects of life and its multiple issues, whether at the level of individuals or groups. And the divine love for His servant who is just is not a sentimental emotion or a tender longing; rather, His love is His aid, support, and divine confirmation. Then the sentence “The believers are but brothers” (49:10) is in the position of explaining the previous [command] to make peace in His saying: “And if two factions among the believers should fight… then make settlement between them in justice” (49:9).” -pg 315 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
“The meaning: those gathered under the shade of faith are nothing but brothers, and He expressed the relationship of brotherhood without [mentioning] other human relationships like friendship, fatherhood, and sonship, because it is the most truthful and strongest, and in it The majority remain firm, and it is appropriate to draw attention in this noble verse to the fact that iman (faith) is a description of all Muslims from the various Islamic schools of thought, as long as one of them does not deny something known of the religion by necessity (which is categorical).” -pg 315-316 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
“Therefore, the people of a school of thought do not have the right to exclude another school of thought from that Qur’anic description (iman) due to a doctrinal branch in which it differs, or due to a baseless historical accusation, so that it becomes easy for them to impose war upon them. For they have been addressed by the explicit text of the Noble Qur’an: “The believers are but brothers” (49:10). They said: “Those are not believers.” But the truth is that they negated iman from them due to their school of thought, not according to the Qur’anic standard of the advisor: “So make settlement between your brothers”(49:10). The transition to reconciliation is based on the bond of faith, to emphasize what the word “only” (innamā) indicated, and to increase the affirmation of the two reconciliations mentioned previously: “So make settlement between them” (49:9) and “then make settlement between them in justice” (49:9). And the observation here is that He did not say: “So make settlement between the two factions,” but rather He shifted to the new description, which is established by His saying: “The believers are but brothers” (49:10). “And fear Allah that you may receive mercy” (49:10) is a follow-up to the divine obligation (the command and the prohibition) with the command of piety, to indicate the necessity of observing the required caution and not taking the matter lightly. And the meaning: And fear the punishment of your Lord by making immediate reconciliation between the believing brothers who have been separated, and [fear] the one who strives for reconciliation [regarding] the consequences of mercy in this world and the Hereafter.” -pg 316 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
The Necessary Etiquettes for Preserving Islamic Brotherhood
“O you who have believed, let not a people ridicule [another] people; perhaps they may be better than them; nor let women ridicule [other] women; perhaps they may be better than them. And do not insult one another and do not call each other by [offensive] nicknames. Wretched is the name of disobedience after [one’s] faith. And whoever does not repent — then it is those who are the wrongdoers. O you who have believed, avoid much [negative] assumption. Indeed, some assumption is sin. And do not spy or backbite each other. Would one of you like to eat the flesh of his brother when dead? You would detest it. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is Accepting of repentance and Merciful.” (Qur’an 49:11-12)” -pg 316 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
“After affirming the meaning of the bond of faith in this passage, it calls for what strengthens it, establishes it, and raises it to a new level, by encouraging individuals to good companionship. This is done by adopting a set of ethics and etiquettes that a person may be ignorant of or belittle, but which are among the foundations of building a Muslim society. Indeed, laxity in them undermines the unity of the Islamic brotherhood and threatens its pillars with collapse. The opening of the call with “O you who believe” (49:11) -pg 316 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz
Source: (pgs. 314-316 Al-Ibriz fi Tafsir al-Qur’an al-‘Aziz – Pure Gold in the Interpretation of the Noble Qur’an – First Edition 2019 CE 1440 AH -The fourth Volume/Part 4 )
This is an Ibadi tafsir published under the supervision of the Office of Fatwa in the Sultanate of Oman. It is a contemporary, simplified commentary on the Qur’an produced by a committee of scholars.
Authored by a select group of professors/scholars. This was done under the supervison and scholarly review of Ibrahim Muhammed Fadil bin Salman al-Sawafi.
Rules of Engagement
The passage from Atfayyish’s Taysir al-Tafsir provides the historical context for the revelation of Qur’an 49:9. It recounts a specific incident involving ‘Abdullah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul, the leader of the hypocrites (munafiqun) in Medina:
“It is mentioned in the story of Badr: Usama ibn Zayd was riding behind him [the Prophet], and on the donkey was Qutba ibn Abi Salul before he embraced Islam. Al-Khazraj passed by a gathering of the Jews, and they had idols and a Muslim with them. When the gathering was covered by the braying of the donkey, ‘Abdullah ibn Ubayy said: ‘Do not frighten us with your donkey.’ The Messenger of Allah (saw) stopped, descended, recited the Qur’an, and called them to Allah. ‘Abdullah said: ‘O man, there is nothing better than what you say, if it were true. So do not harm us in our gatherings.’ So the Messenger of Allah (saw) returned to his mount. Then ‘Abdullah ibn Rawaha said: ‘O Messenger of Allah, he is harming us in our gathering, so we are the polytheists…’ And the Jews and the Muslims almost fought. The Prophet (saw) continued to reconcile them until they were quiet, then he rode his mount. Then the verse was revealed.” Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 436)
This historical context confirms that the verse 49:9 was revealed to address civil strife (fitnah) within the Muslim community. The Prophet’s own action—reconciling rather than fighting—demonstrates the priority of peace.
The passage also cites a narration from Al-Hasan:
“One of them was a hypocrite (munafiq) supported by his people, and the other was a believer (mu’min) supported by the Muslims, so they fought. Then it was revealed.”
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 436)
The Rules of Engagement (Fiqh al-Baghy)
The early Muslim community established strict rules of engagement for fighting the transgressing believers. Ibn Mas’ud ruled:
“The wounded among them is not to be finished off, the captive among them is not to be killed, the fugitive among them is not to be pursued, and no spoils are to be divided regarding them.”
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 436)
These rules prove beyond a doubt that the bāghī remains a Muslim. You do not take spoils from Muslims, nor do you execute Muslim captives. The goal is to restore order, not to exterminate the transgressors.
And a caller announced on the Day of the Camel:
“Do not pursue a fugitive, do not finish off a wounded person, and do not kill a captive.”
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 436)
When a captive was brought to Ali on the Day of Siffin, he said:
“I will not kill you, for I fear Allah, the Lord of the Worlds.”Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 436)
This demonstrates the extreme caution the early Muslims exercised in shedding the blood of fellow believers.
The Sequence of Commands: Reconciliation, Fighting, and Justice
The Taysir al-Tafsir of Atfayyish provides a detailed legal analysis of the sequence of commands in Qur’an 49:9:
{“But if one of them transgresses against the other”} — after the request for reconciliation, and the refusal is merely [an act of] defiance. It has not yet been dealt with, so it necessitates {“then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah”}.
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 433)
Atfayyish highlights a critical detail in the verse’s structure. The command to “make peace” (fa-aṣliḥū) appears twice:
First:“If two parties fight, make peace between them.” (General reconciliation)
Second:“Then if it returns, make peace between them with justice.” (Post-fighting reconciliation)
He explains that the first reconciliation is directed at both parties. But if one party transgresses (baghat), the second command to reconcile is directed specifically at the transgressor—they are the ones who must be brought back to obedience first, before peace can be established.
The Al-Abriz commentary adds:
“If one of them transgresses against the other, then fight against the one that transgresses until it returns to the command of Allah.” The purpose of fighting is not to exterminate the transgressors but to bring them back to obedience. The commentary notes that the verb qātilū (fight) is used in the sense of willing the occurrence, similar to the command to establish prayer. The goal is correction, not destruction. (Al-Abriz, p. 315)
The Taysir al-Tafsir also confirms the linguistic point we discussed earlier:
{“Until it returns” (tafi’a)} — it is said that the meaning is: until it returns to the command of Allah, which is His ruling. [The word] tafi’a (returns) is used exclusively for returning to obedience after disobedience.
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 434)
This is a crucial theological point. The bāghī is not being called to “convert” to Islam (as a disbeliever would be). They are being called to return to obedience (ṭā’ah) after a state of disobedience (ma’ṣiyah). This confirms that they are already Muslims; they have simply fallen into kufr al-ni’ma.
“Until it returns” (tafi’a)}
Justice and Equity: The Goal of Reconciliation
The Taysir al-Tafsir emphasizes that reconciliation must be done “with justice” (bil-ʿadl). Why? Because the position is one of “suspicion of bias” (maẓinnat al-ḥayf). After blood has been shed, there is a natural tendency for one party to seek revenge or for the mediator to favor one side. The Qur’an commands absolute equity to prevent further injustice:
{“Then make peace between them with justice”} — the command [here] includes the prevention of wealth, and the blood-money for the killed and the wounded, and the corruption in the body. And the expression “with reconciliation” is because it may not lead to the restoration of every right to its owner, even if the reconciliation is [meant to be] clear. It is permissible for reconciliation to remove the corruption, even if it does not perfectly distinguish every right to its owner, if there is a fear of the continuation of the dissension.
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 434)
Atfayyish outlines the practical steps of reconciliation:
Prevention of wealth (badal min al-amwāl): The transgressor must compensate for destroyed property.
Blood-money (diyāt): Compensation for the killed and wounded.
Corruption in the body (al-fasād fī al-badan): Physical injuries must be accounted for.
This confirms that the bāghī is legally liable for their actions — proof that they are still a Muslim. You do not pay blood-money to a disbeliever’s family in the same way; you take their wealth as spoils.
The Al-Abriz commentary adds:
“This is a confirmation of the aforementioned instruction of justice, because reform in matters of blood and destruction requires much study, focus, and deliberation, so that every person with a right is given his right.” Sources: (Al-Abriz, p. 315) & (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 438)
The verse concludes with the statement that “Allah loves those who act equitably” (al-muqsiṭīn). This divine love is not a sentimental emotion but a promise of victory, success, and support for those who establish justice.
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 434)
The Brotherhood of Faith
Qur’an 49:10 immediately follows the verse on fighting:
“The believers are but brothers, so make peace between your brothers and fear Allah that you may receive mercy.” (Qur’an 49:10)
“Those gathered under the shade of faith are nothing but brothers, and the brotherhood relationship is without [the need for] other human relationships like friendship, fatherhood, and others, because it is the most truthful, strongest, and most powerful.” (Al-Abriz, p. 316)
This brotherhood is the basis for the command to reconcile. If the fighters were outside the milla of Islam, there would be no brotherhood to preserve. But because they are outwardly Muslims— guilty of kufr al-ni’ma — the doors to repentance and reconciliation must remain open so as to restore peace and unity.
The Taysir al-Tafsir notes that the sentence “The believers are but brothers” is in the position of explaining the previous instruction for reconciliation:
“And the meaning: Those gathered under the shade of faith are nothing but brothers, and the brotherhood relationship is without [the need for] other human relationships like friendship, fatherhood, and others, because it is the most truthful, strongest, and most powerful.”
Source: (Taysir al-Tafsir, Atfayyish, p. 438)
Source material: (Taysir al-Tafsir li’l-Qur’an al-Karim, Qutb al-A’imma Muhammed ibn Yusuf Atfayyish)
The Strength of the Ibadi Position
The Ibadi tafsir of Qur’an 49:9 offers a theologically rigorous and textually grounded reading that resolves several apparent tensions:
Principle
Ibadi Position
Evidence
Status of the Bāghī
Believer in milla, kāfir in ni’ma (ungrateful).
Qur’an 49:9 (nowhere in the Qur’an is bāghī for believers); Qur’an 14:7 (kafartum = severe punishment); Hadith Bukhari 7077 (“Do not revert as kuffāran“).
Goal of Fighting
To restore obedience and justice, not to exterminate.
Qur’an 49:9 (“until it returns to the command of Allah”); Taysir al-Tafsir (tafi’a = return to obedience after disobedience).
Rules of Engagement
No killing captives, no spoils, no pursuit of fugitives.
Ibn Mas’ud’s ruling in Taysir al-Tafsir, p. 436; the caller on the Day of the Camel; Ali’s statement “I will not kill you, for I fear Allah.”
Responsibility
The community leaders (ahl al-amr) must reconcile.
Qur’an 49:9 (“make peace between them”); Al-Abriz (leaders of the Muslim community).
Purpose
Eliminate rancor and hatred, establish justice.
Taysir al-Tafsir (purpose of the verse is the elimination of rancor and hatred); Qur’an 49:10 (brotherhood).
Nature of the Duty
Supporting the oppressed against the transgressor is a jihad.
Taysir al-Tafsir (a group of our people said: assistance of the oppressed is a jihad).
Conclusion
The Ibadi tafsir of Qur’an 49:9 offers a balanced theology that upholds the sanctity of faith while recognizing the gravity of sin.
The Ibadi position, is not one of extremism or excessive leniency. It is a rigorous, textually grounded, and spiritually profound reading of the Qur’anic text. It demonstrates that the Muslim community is called to be a community of justice, reconciliation, and mercy even in the midst of its most painful internal conflicts. It provides a framework for addressing intra-community conflict that neither demonizes the transgressor nor ignores their wrongdoing. It serves as a powerful reminder that faith and sin are not mutually exclusive—but the consequences of sin are severe, and the path to reconciliation requires justice, equity, and a steadfast commitment to the bonds of brotherhood.
The root b-gh-y is never used for believers elsewhere in the Qur’an.
The min al-mu’minīn describes prior state, not the state of fighting.
The hadith uses kufr language for intra-Muslim fighting.
Qur’an 4:93 creates a tension that the Ibadi framework resolves.
“Indeed, We have made it (ja’alnahu) an Arabic Qur’an that you might understand.” (Qur’an 43:3)
﷽
The truth of the matter is that the entire Muslim Ummah are in agreement that some aspect of the Qur’an is created. What they differ and disagree about are the specifics.
This debate has been framed incorrectly. It has been framed as a debate between those who believe the Qur’an is created and those who believe the Qur’an is uncreated.
The reality: The debate is about to what degree and which aspects of the Qur’an are created.
For example:
1. The Mushaf. The pages that the ink is printed upon. All Muslims call this the Qur’an. There is etiquette in regard to it. We do not bring it to dirty places. The proper disposal is to burn it’s pages. Yet, this is called ‘Qur’an’. Everyone who can be called Muslim agrees to this. That is that the Mushaf of the Qur’an is created. If there is a person who disagrees with this and or is hesitant to affirm this then know that they are upon something very strange.
2. The ink and the words which are written. The words and letters on the pages that were placed there by ink or the printing press. All Muslims call this the Qur’an. Everyone who can be called Muslim agrees to this. That is that the ink and the words on the pages are created.If there is a person who disagrees with this or is hesitant to affirm this then know they upon something very strange.
3. The recitation of the words of the Qur’an. This is is what we will be discussing today.
We will learn that the one who compiled ‘Sahih Bukhari’, whose full name is: Abū ʿAbd Allāh Muḥammed ibn Ismāʿīl ibn Ibrāhīm ibn al-Mughirah ibn Bardizbah al-Juʿfī al-Bukhārī and his supporter who compiled ‘Sahih Muslim’ . Both believed that their recitation of the Qur’an is created. This caused a boycott of Bukhari by major Hanbali scholars..
“Muhammed bin Yahya al-Nisaburi wrote to the people of Rayy, informing them of al-Bukhari’s position. The accusation was that al-Bukhari held “lafzi bil-Quran makhluq”. That his pronunciation/recitation of the Quran is created.”
“My father and Abu Zur’ah heard from him, then they both abandoned his hadith when Muhammed bin Yahya al-Nisaburi wrote to them that he [al-Bukhari] had made it apparent to them that his pronunciation of the Qur’an is created.”
Source: (page 462 from Volume 12 of Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’ (Biographies of the Noble Scholars) by Imam al-Dhahabi, edited by Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut.)
“[Al-Ma’idah: 64]. And his emigration (hijrah)(1) was from Mecca. He came to Iraq at the end of the night… [Quranic verse]: “If Allah helps you, none can overcome you; and if He forsakes you, who is there after Him that can help you?” [Al Imran: 160].”
“And Ahmad bin Mansur al-Shirazi said: I heard al-Qasim bin al-Qasim say: I heard Ibrahim, the scribe of Ahmad bin Sayyar, say: When al-Bukhari arrived in Marw, Ahmad bin Sayyar met him. So he said to him: “O Abu Abdullah, we do not oppose you in what you say, but the common people cannot bear this from you.” He [al-Bukhari] said: “I only ask about something I know to be true, fearing the Fire, lest I say other than it.” So Ahmad bin Sayyar turned away from him.”
“And Abd al-Rahman bin Abi Hatim said in Al-Jarh wa al-Ta’dil (2): Muhammed bin Isma’il al-Rayy came in the year 210 AH, and my father and Abu Zur’ah heard from him. And they abandoned his hadith when Muhammed bin Yahya al-Nisaburi wrote to them that he [al-Bukhari] had made it apparent to them that his pronunciation of the Quran is created.“
Then Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut comments on this.
By the way for those not familiar when you see the name Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut it is a reference to Abū Usāmah Shuʿayb ibn Muḥarram ibn ʿAlī al-Albānī al-Arnāʾūṭ.
Most people in Salafi/Athari circles simply refer to him as: al-Albānī.
So al-Albānī (Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut) comments:
“This is strange from Abu Zur’ah and Abu Hatim, for they both had already heard from him [al-Bukhari] and narrated from him, and they did not abandon him except based on the statement of their teacher al-Bukhari regarding the issue of lafz [pronunciation]. And it is not permissible for them to act upon this, due to what it entails of sin, caprice, and envy. And Imam al-Dhahabi said in Mizan al-I’tidal 1/111 in the biography of Abu Nu’aym, the author of Al-Hilyah: “The words of some of them regarding others are not to be relied upon, especially if it becomes clear to him that it is due to partisanship for a madhhab or envy. And no one is safe from that except one whom Allah protects. And I do not know of an era from the eras that is safe from that except the era of the Prophets and the Rightly Guided Caliphs. And if you wish, I could list that in volumes.” And al-Subki said in Tabaqat al-Shafi’iyyah 2/230: “The position of al-Dhuhali [Muhammed bin Yahya] regarding al-Bukhari came from envy of him.” And al-Subki said in Qa’idah al-Jarh wa al-Ta’dil 12: “And from what should be examined is the state of beliefs and their differences in relation to the critic and the criticized. For perhaps the critic is wronged in creed, so his criticism of him is [invalid].”-Shaykh al-Albānī
Source: (page 462 from Volume 12 of Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’ (Biographies of the Noble Scholars) by Imam al-Dhahabi, edited by Shu’ayb al-Arna’ut.)
Examining Shaykh al-Albānī charge of envy for abandoning Bukhari for his position on the createdness of the Qur’an.
Shaykh Shaykh al-Albānī’s argument in the highlighted footnote is essentially this: Abu Zur’ah’s criticism cannot be sincere because he also narrated from Muslim, who shared al-Bukhari’s theological position.
If Abu Zur’ah was willing to accept hadith from Muslim, he should have accepted them from al-Bukhari on the same grounds. Unless his abandonment of al-Bukhari was motivated by petty jealousy, or partisanship.
We have to be fair here in saying that Shaykh al-Albānī’s claim has a very strong basis.
This reasoning has some historical traction, but it is not the whole picture:
Muslim’s Position: It is well-established that Imam Muslim did agree with al-Bukhari on the lafz issue. Al-Bayhaqi explicitly stated that Muslim “was on the madhhab of al-Bukhari in the distinction” between recitation and the recited. Muslim also famously stood by al-Bukhari during the boycott, taking his written works back from al-Dhuhali and withdrawing from his circle.
Source: (Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’ 12/460, Huda al-Sari in the introduction to Fath al-Bari 2/264)
Imam Muslim was the only one who did not abandon Imam al-Bukhari, since they were upon the same creed. Their creed opposed that of the Hanbali who opposed them.
“And Makki bin Abdan said: Dawud bin Ali al-Asbahani came to Nisapur during the days of Ishaq bin Rahwayh. They held a session of debate for him, and he attended the circle of Yahya bin al-Dhuhali, and Muslim bin al-Hajjaj. A theological issue was discussed in which Yahya spoke, and he silenced him, saying: “Be quiet, O boy!” So Muslim did not support him. He returned to his father and complained to him. His father said: “Who was he?” He said: “Muslim.” He said: “You have returned from every single one of my hadiths!” [Meaning: you have ruined your standing with him]. When this reached Muslim, he gathered what he had written from him in a notebook, sent it to him, and said: “I will never narrate anything from you ever again.”
“Abu Abdullah al-Hakim said:I have noted this story from Tahir bin Ahmad, from Makki, and Muslim may have differed after this incident with Muhammed bin Yahya, but he only cut him off because of the issue of al-Bukhari. And al-Hafiz Abu Abdullah bin al-Akhram knew that, so he informed about the alienation [that occurred] later.”
“And I heard him [al-Hakim] saying:Muslim bin al-Hajjaj used to openly declare the statement regarding al-lafz [the pronunciation of the Quran], and he did not conceal it. When al-Bukhari settled in Nisapur, he openly declared more of the disagreement with him. When the issue of al-lafz occurred between al-Bukhari and al-Dhuhali, and the people of Nisapur were prevented from differing with him [al-Dhuhali], and he called to that, the majority of people cut off from Muslim, other than a few. It reached Muhammed bin Yahya, and he said one day: “Whoever says al-lafz is not created, it is not permissible for him to attend my circle.” So Muslim took his garment, placed it on his shoulder, stood up before the people, and sent to him what he had written from him, saying: “We only used to narrate from you because of al-lafz.” And Muslim used to openly declare the statement regarding al-lafz and not conceal it.“
“Abu Hamid bin al-Sharqi said: I attended the circle of Muhammed bin Yahya, and he said: “Whoever says: ‘My pronunciation of the Quran is created,’ let him not attend my circle.” So Muslim stood up from the circle.”
“Abu Bakr al-Khatib said: Muslim used to fight on behalf of al-Bukhari, until the relationship between him and Muhammed bin Yahya became estranged, due to his [al-Bukhari’s] reason.”
“I [al-Dhahabi] said:Then, [if] he was a Muslim due to his createdness [meaning: his stance on the creation of actions] he also turned away from al-Bukhari, and did not mention him as a narrator of hadith, nor did he name him in his Sahih. Rather, he began the book with the wording of those who stipulated al-lafz for whomever he narrated from, in a manner that claims consensus in the contemporary era is sufficient [to establish it], and he did not pause on that knowledge of the two of them, and he criticized whoever stipulated that. But rather, Abu Abdullah al-Bukhari said that, and his teacher Ali bin al-Madini, and it is the most correct and most sound [position]. And this is not the place to elaborate on this issue.”
“The Hafiz Abu al-Qasim bin Asakir said in Al-Atraf: It is after he mentioned [the Sahih of al-Bukhari]: Then he followed the path of Muslim bin al-Hajjaj, and he took the extraction of his book, its composition, and its arrangement into two parts. He intended to mention in the first part the hadiths of the reliable people of precision, and in the second part the hadiths of the people of covering and truthfulness, those who did not reach the rank of the firmly established. The death prevented him from completing this aspiration, and between him and this aspiration was the completion of his book. However, his book became famous and spread despite his need for it [to be completed].”
“And al-Hakim said: Muslim wanted to extract the Sahih into three categories, and upon three generations of narrators. He mentioned this at the beginning of his introduction, but he was not able to finish except the first category, and he died.”
Source: (page 628 from Volume 12 of Siyar A’lam al-Nubala’, in the biography of Imam Muslim)
The second point.
Abu Zur’ah’s Relationship with Muslim: Abu Zur’ah was not hostile to Muslim. In fact, Muslim submitted his Sahih to Abu Zur’ah for review, and Abu Zur’ah’s approval was seen as a mark of its authenticity. if Abu Zur’ah accepted Muslim’s Sahih despite his lafz views, why did he abandon al-Bukhari?
Insh’Allah we will update this page and provide an easily accessible online source when it becomes available.
If you would like to learn more about this specific subject please read the following: